StarDestroyer.Net BBS

And this retort DOES NOT VALIDATE YOUR ORIGINAL CLAIM THAT PHASERS CAN DO IT. SINCE HAND WEAPONS DON'T VAPORIZE THE DROIDS TO TAKE THEM OUT, WHY DOES IT MATTER IF PHASERS CAN VAPORIZE THEM? PHASERS HAVE FAR MORE DEVASTATING EFFECTS THAN BLASTERS, SO NO REASON TO THINK THEY WON'T HURT THE DROIDS JUS...

Name one time we've seen hand phasers vapourize 1" thick armour plate, you bullshitting asshole. Name one time we've seen SW hand weapons vapourize 1" thick armour plating, you ignorant, dishonest cumstump of a manwhore. (Hurray for warsie debating skills! No proof/evidence needed, just r...

Mentioned yes, but why are they never used? Photon grenades we've never actually seen in use. That hardly means they don't exist and that no one ever uses them. Wide beam phasers have been shown on multiple occasions, although I think they might have all been the hand type phasers. Don't recall if ...

Actually, they are a bunch of hippy moron's, the majority dont even know how to pilot manually, the average boyscout would be able to beat them if they didnt have their technobabble. But thats beside the point. Even Starfleet cadets can fight in HtH against 3-1 odds against most races and hold thei...

Why are you all assuming (and wrongly so) that phaser won't affect either metal or the droids? We've seen hand phasers not only damage, but completly vaporize metal, both mundane and armor. If this is just more warsie wanking, then I digress. But it you have a legitimate reason/evidence/proof to thi...

Are all warsies as ignorant as you guys? Do you all leap to childish insults so quickly when you have nothing of value to say? I never said Q would be helping the Feds win beyond what the OP states. I have however proved that Q is well beyond the scope and power of any Jedi/Sith. For the quadrillion...

That ISD did not "blow up." You can see in the damn movie (remember visuals trump everything else) that the bridge got hit by an asteroid. The captain and bridge crew were killed as a result. The ship doesn't stop functioning just because the bridge is gone. Batman method rebutall: Proof ...

Um, IIRC, from the movie and novelization. Going into the asteroid field was at best seen as extremely hazardous, and at worst tanamount to suicide. Didn't one of the ISD's blow up in the asteroid field? No. Empire Strikes Back script says Before him are the hologram images of twenty battleship com...

Don't see anything about Q helping either side, just Q setting the stage for the VS. ...Q shows up, with gifts. Five fully functioning, unmanned Imperial Star Destroyers just pop into existence, containing within their data-banks through the magic of Q-Tech a sort of "Everything You Wanted to ...

My god Batman, do you ever actually debate, or just naysay and play the really annoying devils advocate? Lets see just how easy it is to do what you are doing, which is not even close to debating. Evidence for Q preventing people from sensing their presence? Evidence for Q being sensed by someone he...

As the witnessed effects don't incorporate any heavy metals-yes? And you're still assuming since the lady in the commercial said it was so, it must be so. Um, the witnessed effect incorporated a starship, I'd say that qualifies as heavy metals. It wasn't a 'commercial. IIRC it was more of a Starfle...

Just out of curiosity, and since I havent been following too much, are you honestly trying to claim Scrubula that Tarkin and Vader did not allow Leia and folks to escape? Try reading before you reply, it'll save alot of timewasted on these ignorant questions. I'm claiming that stormtroopers were ne...

Except that you didn't. What, pray tell, is your evidence for the Stormies not having been instructed to miss? You mean besides the stormtroopers talking amongst themselves and the stormtroopers that were firing on and trying to get through the door at them in the bridge/chasm room? Troopers who we...

So you're assuming that Q could stop the force users from sensing him with no evidence for his ability to do so? Are you assuming that the emperor could sense Q, even if Q didn't want him to, with no evidence for his ability to do so? Considering that Q seems capable of doing anything he can think ...

You're asking him to prove a negative, and assuming that the scientist says "reorganize all matter" when he says "reorganize matter". Has it not occurred to you that certain materials are not naturally occurring in a starship and may resist reorganization the same way certain ma...

You can't honestly be so stupid to think the empire would leave a wormhole to a whole new galaxy practically unguarded, and base this decision on the fact that the initial encounter there was an easy one. For fuck's sake, it's a totally unknown galaxy. I'm saying it's highly doubtful that a 500+ ca...

The evidence is there canonically being a plan to let them escape and lead the DS to the Rebel base, which is kinda hard if they get flatlined on the way to the landing bay. Of course, instead of actually giving any such evidence, you merely claim it exists. I've already offered one alternative (Va...

"The movies are gospel, everything else is gossip."

-George Lucas

What more do you really need?

Or do you rank Chee and others above the Lucas?

Therefore, when the first reports come in that this phenomina has opened (escpecially if its close to core worlds) they would deploy a large force, possiblly several sector forces at the least to ensure that if there is a battle there will be a sufficient force to defeat all unknowns. Um, they didn...

The inability to deferentiate between a brochure claim and what actually happens never ceases to amaze me. Think. What does the genesis device actually do? Claiming that it can affect dense elements equally as well as those it was designed to work on is a no limits fallacy. As for taking the word o...

There's plenty of evidence for the Stormtroopers doing so. Dont' suppose you actually want to back up that claim with some, gee, i don't know, evidence maybe? Ya know, like I did when disproving this foolish idea. I take it the idea of chronolgy is beyond you. By that time the plan to release and t...

And could somebody explain exactly what does stormtrooper accuracity has to do with CAPITAL SHIP combat As I said before, when ST ships purposely miss, many here would say "That's not that impressive." When stormtroopers are supposedly doing the same thing, suddenly it's 'skill and discip...

It's a common Trekkie tactic to claim that good always triumphs over evil. I contend differently. When you have an enemy that essentially will committ any atrocity, any terror attack, any mass extermination -- regardless that we'd all like to believe that good wins in the end -- in reality it doesn...

the molecular structure of any given matter can be restructured -- changed -- into anything else of identical mass. Any matter can be restructured into anything else of identical mass. What part of this are you guys not understanding? There is nothing in those passages to point to denser materials ...

Praxis posted So your assertion is that: 1) Darth Vader placed a homing beacon on the Falcon, so that when they escape he can follow the Falcon to the Rebel Base. 2) Then he ordered them killed so that they can't escape. Care to try to prove that the stormtroopers had any orders from Vader at all? ...