Page 1 of 2

Which one do you like better?

Posted: 2003-03-16 08:53am
by His Divine Shadow
I've made two banners for my site:

Banner 1:
Image

Banner 2:
Image

Now I like Banner 1, but Banner two is more 'situationally'(sp?) correct.

Posted: 2003-03-16 09:18am
by Kenny_10_Bellys
Number 1 looks better, but as you say number 2 is more pertinent. Why not use both, they're both excellent?

Posted: 2003-03-16 09:42am
by His Divine Shadow
Well I've added both on my link page.

Posted: 2003-03-16 09:45am
by XaLEv
Shouldn't there be an '&' between 'quotes' and 'extracts'?

Posted: 2003-03-16 09:46am
by His Divine Shadow
XaLEv wrote:Shouldn't there be an '&' between 'quotes' and 'extracts'?
Oh crap, there was that too, just redid the fonts and made a mental note to put in the '&' later, looks like I forgot :P

The font I use doesn't support the '&' sign so I use Arial

Posted: 2003-03-16 09:50am
by His Divine Shadow
There, updated.

Posted: 2003-03-16 11:45am
by haas mark
I prefer the first.

Posted: 2003-03-16 02:58pm
by Brother-Captain Gaius
I would prefer the second, if the the caption was moved and the color of it was changed, so its easier to read.

Posted: 2003-03-16 03:08pm
by Sea Skimmer
The "look sir" line on the second one is hard to read. So I'd go with number one. If it can be moved, go with two.

Posted: 2003-03-16 03:13pm
by Sir Sirius
Number one is better.

Posted: 2003-03-16 03:21pm
by His Divine Shadow
Sea Skimmer wrote:The "look sir" line on the second one is hard to read. So I'd go with number one. If it can be moved, go with two.
I moved the text a bit.

Posted: 2003-03-17 07:47am
by haas mark
The second one seems ...empty... between the stormies, whereas on the first one, the color contrast is great, and it seems fuller. I still prefer the first.

Posted: 2003-03-17 01:21pm
by Kuja
I like the second one.

Posted: 2003-03-17 08:12pm
by Andrew J.
Second one.

Re: Which one do you like better?

Posted: 2003-03-18 02:09am
by Rob Wilson
His Divine Shadow wrote:I've made two banners for my site:

Banner 1:
Image

Banner 2:
Image

Now I like Banner 1, but Banner two is more 'situationally'(sp?) correct.
I can't see Banner number 1, but I really like Banner number 2 anyway. :)

Posted: 2003-03-18 02:18am
by His Divine Shadow
Try and reload it a few times, it ought to work.

Posted: 2003-03-18 02:25am
by Rob Wilson
His Divine Shadow wrote:Try and reload it a few times, it ought to work.
Even when I go to the URL, it shows nothing, and using Select All/Properties tells me it's a 32x32 GIF :?

Posted: 2003-03-18 02:28am
by His Divine Shadow
Rob Wilson wrote:
His Divine Shadow wrote:Try and reload it a few times, it ought to work.
Even when I go to the URL, it shows nothing, and using Select All/Properties tells me it's a 32x32 GIF :?
hmm, it's not tho, it's a JPEG, very similar to the one you see.

Try clickin on this link:
http://www.hisdivineshadow.com/misc/images/banner.jpg

Posted: 2003-03-18 12:49pm
by Rob Wilson
His Divine Shadow wrote:
Rob Wilson wrote:
His Divine Shadow wrote:Try and reload it a few times, it ought to work.
Even when I go to the URL, it shows nothing, and using Select All/Properties tells me it's a 32x32 GIF :?
hmm, it's not tho, it's a JPEG, very similar to the one you see.

Try clickin on this link:
http://www.hisdivineshadow.com/misc/images/banner.jpg
Um, That's the same link. :?

I know it's a Jpeg, but there's nothing showing when I go there, and when I use properties it says it's a Gif image (even though it gives the filename as Jpg). Don't worry about it, everyone else can see it, so it's just another manifestation of my Computers idiosyncrasies. :wink:

Posted: 2003-03-18 01:07pm
by His Divine Shadow
Rob Wilson wrote:Um, That's the same link. :?
Yeah, I was thinking that maybe the problem was with my server dusplaying images remotely/directly on the forum.

Posted: 2003-03-18 01:12pm
by His Divine Shadow
Rob Wilson wrote:Um, That's the same link. :?
Yeah, I was thinking that maybe the problem was with my server dusplaying images remotely/directly on the forum.

Posted: 2003-03-18 01:37pm
by Rob Wilson
His Divine Shadow wrote:
Rob Wilson wrote:Um, That's the same link. :?
Yeah, I was thinking that maybe the problem was with my server dusplaying images remotely/directly on the forum.
Well everyone else can see it and have commented, so it must be at my end. So by default I'll say Banner 2 is the better one. :D

Posted: 2003-03-18 07:37pm
by Bartman
Put me down for number 2 as well. But it probably would be better if you could float the stormy on the left a few dozen pixels to the right. The empty space is just a touch too large.

Posted: 2003-03-19 07:15pm
by FaxModem1
Banner two, since it is more colorful and not as blueish as the first picture is.

Posted: 2003-03-19 07:52pm
by Asst. Asst. Lt. Cmdr. Smi
Although it looks empty compared to the other, I still prefer the second one. It also fits with the quote better.