Modeling Comp WIP (second version)

[Warspite]

With so few days to go for the deadline, I scrapped my previous work, and started on this...



Very loosely based on an image from here (Scroll down to the bottom).

The ship is Perry Rhodan inspired (sort of, it started as an outrigger for a shuttle), that huge upturned bowl is a shield to prevent accidents to the rest of the "unmodeled" landscape. As you can see it's all still in grey primer, don't know what to paint with...
Polygon count is on the 30-40k region, a lot of lathes, splines, lattice modifiers and regular polygons with some booleans, extrusions and bevels thrown into the mix.

Some closer shots of the central models: here and here.

[salm]

some booleans

he said the evil B-Word... the B-Word! Ruuuuuuuun!!!!

[dragon]

ok out of curosity what did you use to make that. And its an interesting idea.

[Shinova]

ok out of curosity what did you use to make that. And its an interesting idea.

Looks like Max to me. (Looks like a skylight)


Most of the people here use Max, I bellieve.

[salm]

ok out of curosity what did you use to make that. And its an interesting idea.

yeah, i think it´s max. wanna try it? get a trial version here:

3DS Max Trial

Looks like Max to me. (Looks like a skylight)


Most of the people here use Max, I bellieve.

antares uses blender and julhelm uses milkshape.

[Warspite]

Shinova hit it on the spot, Max 5 to be exact.

And what's wrong with booleans?????
(And when will Discreet get decent algorithms for error-free shapemerges????)

[salm]

And what's wrong with booleans?????

they tend to give you a whole bunch of weird edges and vertices where there shouldn´t be any, somethimes screwing up your smoothing groups.

[Antares]

And what's wrong with booleans?????

they tend to give you a whole bunch of weird edges and vertices where there shouldn´t be any, somethimes screwing up your smoothing groups.

That's right. At least in Blender a mesh is fucked up after applying boolean operations to it. The mesh still looks good afterwards, but using subdivison surfaces with such a result it's getting horrible.

But don't have those words influence your motivation Warspite. You have to be happy with what you are doing and nobody else

[Warspite]

they tend to give you a whole bunch of weird edges and vertices where there shouldn´t be any, somethimes screwing up your smoothing groups.

Yeah, I try to go easy on any operation (boolean or shapemerge). In this case I used one shapemerge on the ship (to make a cargo door), and a boolean for the two tanks on the concrete shield, and the square area for the tower, the rest was with poly manipulation.


What do you think is better, detach faces where you're going to operate, or operate directly on the geometry?