Page 1 of 1
Quarterly SD.net CG Modelling Contest Judging thread!
Posted: 2004-10-01 01:23am
by Beowulf
The contestants:
Salm with his Bioncle lego guy:
Julhelm with his guns and a chick:
Warspite with his retro Sci-Fi rocketship:
Vote for the person who you think did the best job modelling.
Note: the rules will be changing for the next contest.
You have two weeks to vote on this. Spam in this thread will be shot on sight.
EDIT: That sound you hear is Salm pwning the other contenders. Congrats. Rules for next contest up tomorrow.
Posted: 2004-10-01 03:25am
by Frank Hipper
Lots of talent shown by everyone, my vote goes to Antares, though.
His detail and nearly "organic" look in his images is what pegged it for me.
Very nice.
Warspite gets a runner-up, not only for skill but for his entering
a single image for judging. Thoughtful and professional of him.
Posted: 2004-10-01 07:08am
by Chardok
They are all excellent, but I like the realism of Julheim's models. Excellent attention to detail (And I would know...) The weapons are top-notch, and would, with a few simple textures, cut it in any modern war game.
Antares' is awesome as well, lots of goodies in there, especially the full-color lab complete with alien-in-the-tube.
The bionicle model wins on coolness factor, but only because I'm a bionicle fan-whore. I love those fucking things. They are quite good, but with a bit more....could take the show for me. I don't even know what's missing...it's small, though...but it would tip everything. maybe just a tad more detail on the masks? That is, after all, what bionicle is all about....I'm not sure. Ecxellent work, though, Salm. Now replace your Avatar with a bionicle guy and lose the frightening kid from the haunted painting.
The sci-fi retro rocket, while an excellent model, just didn't do it for me asthetically. Technically, it looks to be a very good model. the lighting is superb, the paint scheme works quite well, and all combine to give it a very bleak, military feel, which is as it should be, since back in the day something like this would be envisioned, it would undoubtedly be housed in a military base. So it really captures the essence of the model. It is an excellent all-round picture, too, incorporating elements of the background into the entire model.
All told, very excellent work, gentlemen, you all obviously put alot of effort into these pictures and you deserve a collective round of applause from all of us here. Don't waste those talents, either! Use em! Congratulations all.
Posted: 2004-10-01 08:29pm
by The Cleric
Antares, for sheer amount of detail.
Posted: 2004-10-04 04:36pm
by Julhelm
Antares gets my vote for the sheer effort he must've put into those aliens.
Posted: 2004-10-04 09:20pm
by StarshipTitanic
The Alien with guns is so freaking cool.
Posted: 2004-10-13 11:32am
by Beowulf
Reminder: The poll closes Real Soon Now.
Posted: 2004-10-14 11:02pm
by Jaded Masses
I vote for Julhelm, his chick picture really captures the essence of the white high-school chick stereotype. I can just see the pink t-shirt, the artificially faded jeans, the sneakers. Perfect.
(Actually I accidentally voted for Antares, but I meant Julhelm
)
Posted: 2004-10-15 02:40am
by Beowulf
Contest is closed. Antares has won. Congradulations. Next contest to begin Saturday sometime.
Posted: 2004-10-15 10:15am
by salm
congrats to antares. you deserve the victory for modelling skills and for speed. making all these modells within a month, wow.
Posted: 2004-10-15 10:55am
by Antares
salm wrote:... within a month ....
I just re-read the rules and found no rule mentioning that the models had to be finished within "one month" (from what starting point?).
Most models (and especially the scenes) were made long ago...
(There are actually two threads about them in this forum. That's the main reason why i didnt get suspicious, when Beowulf had inspected my pictures)
So since i am (obviously) cheated i am out and the next in line is the winner
Sorry for cheating, but i really thought this is a general show off.
Do i get kicked from the board now?
EDIT:
found it:
6. All candidate images must be new for this contest. No fair using prior images.
i always searched for a peroid of time.
You may call me a fucking cheater now !
omg... how embarrassing. why was nobody doubting this? ...
It seems like nobody remembered my work posted on this board:
http://bbs.stardestroyer.net/viewtopic. ... highlight=
http://bbs.stardestroyer.net/viewtopic. ... highlight=
Can somebody BANN me please?
So congrats to YOU salm
Posted: 2004-10-15 11:15am
by Beowulf
The rule was that the image must be new for the contest, which began Jul 21.
So it was really more like 2 1/2 months. Apology accepted Antares.
*Antares' body falls to the floor after being force choked.*
Congrats to Salm.
Posted: 2004-10-15 12:02pm
by salm
umm.... yipie.
meh, you´re still better.
i´ll beat you in the next contest though.
actually julhelm also has 3 votes because of jaded masses´ vote.
Posted: 2004-10-15 12:57pm
by Beowulf
salm wrote:umm.... yipie.
meh, you´re still better.
i´ll beat you in the next contest though.
actually julhelm also has 3 votes because of jaded masses´ vote.
You know what? damn it... new voting thread! or rather same thread, new poll.
Voting ends monday.
Posted: 2004-10-15 05:01pm
by Shinova
I actually did know or at least strongly suspected you, but the images I've not seen threw me off slightly and I just felt like not saying a peep.
Oh well, you always have the next contest.