Ford Prefect wrote:Because he's a completely selfish manipulative bastard? Because he didn't any of those things for the good of his nation? He is Evil, afterall, it would surprise me to discover Edge went about his actions to improve the lives of others; as opposed to serving his own purposes.
But he
did do those things to improve the lives of others
! So they would like him!
Come now, yes, Edge is very blatantly Evil, but it's not like he
hides his proclivity. He is very honest about his selfishness, so people accept that and judge him by the results of his actions, which are generally beneficent. I mean, if nothing else, he wants to rule the best nation possible, so he is going to improve it as much as he can reasonably manage. How is this worse than, for instance, Verdigris?
Darth Raptor wrote:Seriously, while Edge may have improved Syvoria greatly it supposedly pales in comparison to the status quo thousands of years ago. Furthermore, he's responsible for the escalating brutality of the war.
In some ways the world is better now than before, in other ways worse. It also depends on what aspects we're judging by. It's better for the average Syvorian than it was a couple thousand years ago, though. Go back a bit farther and stuff gets fuzzier... . As for the war, well, there are some distinct advantages to total warfare, again, depending on your frame of moral reference. In some ways, it parallels discussion over the use of the atomic bomb in World War II. Though undoubtedly cruel, Edge's techniques might well have saved lives in the final analysis... well, Syvorian lives anyway.
Plus, Edge is a dick. The way he toys with people's lives is downright loathsome.
Well yeah, that kind of is
.
Noble Ire wrote:
Indeed. Similarly, Palpatine is an interesting an rather cool character, but I've never been ever able to actually like him, because he's a manipulative egomaniac with no apparent redeeming features. Whiel Edge isn't on his level (yet, at least), he's not much better.
Edge has essentially consummate capability. He could rule by force or by suggestion, and he chose suggestion. Hell, as long as we're at it, he didn't even take the option of openly ruling the entire nation. He still lets the Council have general governmental domain. All in all, he actually demonstrates considerable restraint --and he
does give people options. What do you think Zixer would do, if he was granted this nearly unstoppable power? Do you think he would be as understanding?
On another note, I still like Winter's character design. He looks rather... bewildered.
I think I mentioned when I very first drew him that he was seriously mentally disjointed.