ONGEG Video: Q Who

PST: discuss Star Trek without "versus" arguments.

Moderator: Vympel

User avatar
Sonnenburg
Official Dave Barry Clone
Posts: 2305
Joined: 2002-11-05 08:35pm
Location: Gotham City
Contact:

ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Sonnenburg »

Taking a look at Q Who. Enjoy.

Video
Chuck

Image
User avatar
Ghost Rider
Spirit of Vengeance
Posts: 27779
Joined: 2002-09-24 01:48pm
Location: DC...looking up from the gutters to the stars

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Ghost Rider »

Your conclusion is something I think even the Trek writers either never thought of or some poor soul truly meant it to be, somewhere...somehow. Nonetheless it gives the entire Borg/Picard vendetta a wonderful angle.

All in all, I enjoyed that you mentioned the DeLancie change with that particular piece of dialogue.
MM /CF/WG/BOTM/JL/Original Warsie/ACPATHNTDWATGODW FOREVER!!

Sometimes we can choose the path we follow. Sometimes our choices are made for us. And sometimes we have no choice at all

Saying and doing are chocolate and concrete
User avatar
Stark
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 36169
Joined: 2002-07-03 09:56pm
Location: Brisbane, Australia

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Stark »

Yeah, it's pretty sad when you can look back and see compelling patterns or developments that you're 99% sure the writers didn't intend and never even noticed.
User avatar
Chris OFarrell
Durandal's Bitch
Posts: 5724
Joined: 2002-08-02 07:57pm
Contact:

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Chris OFarrell »

This was an excellent TNG episode and I'd agree a lot of that was because of how well Delance and Stewart played off against each other. I'm slightly surprised that you didn't comment on Q's final words to Picard and just how pointed they were, as well as Picard, somewhat humbled, admitting to Guinen that Q perhaps gave Starfleet a much needed kick in its complacency...

But regardless, it was cool. I think we saw that Sonya character at least twice more, once in the episode with the Packlards, once in another episode...but I could be wrong about that.
Image
User avatar
Patrick Degan
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 14847
Joined: 2002-07-15 08:06am
Location: Orleanian in exile

Post by Patrick Degan »

This one was definitely one of the season 2 standouts and especially for John DeLancie's performance as Q. The whole perception of the character changes with this episode: from troublemaker to teacher, and in this instance handing out a very brutal lesson our Starfleet heroes frankly weren't prepared to learn: "It's not SAFE out there." The real golden moment comes when, in response to Picard's plea for Q to tell him that the deaths of eighteen of his crew is just an illusion, Q simply says, "Oh, no. This is as real as your so-called life gets" and then calmly vanishes.

The scene in the briefing room with Q explaining the Borg is in this segment of the episode. In just a few lines of dialogue, the menace of this new threat is clearly and effectively outlined by DeLancie's understated monologue: "The Borg is the ultimate user. They are unlike any threat your Federation has ever faced. They're not interested in political conquest, wealth or power as you know it. They're simply interested in your ship and it's technology. They've identified it as something they can consume." This was an enemy you'd have to fight until one or the other was exterminated.

This really was the high-water mark for the Borg. From BOBW2, it was a relentlessly downhill slide into complete mediocrity.

What's interesting is the new take on Q that begins with this episode. Except for the odd-man-out third season entry "Deja Q", Q is more or less showing up to teach Picard lessons and it's implied that he is acting on behalf of the Continuum in doing so (and outright seen to be on a mission from his superiors in "True Q"). Take "Deja Q" out of the mix, and you've got an unbroken line of Q stories from this one which culminates with "All Good Things" in which Picard takes that last step onto a new plateau, taking a first look "at the uncharted possibilities of human existence" —which was where Q was leading him all along.
When ballots have fairly and constitutionally decided, there can be no successful appeal back to bullets.
—Abraham Lincoln

People pray so that God won't crush them like bugs.
—Dr. Gregory House

Oil an emergency?! It's about time, Brigadier, that the leaders of this planet of yours realised that to remain dependent upon a mineral slime simply doesn't make sense.
—The Doctor "Terror Of The Zygons" (1975)
User avatar
Alyeska
Federation Ambassador
Posts: 17496
Joined: 2002-08-11 07:28pm
Location: Montana, USA

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Alyeska »

Very good work Sonnenburg. I loved your commentary on Q, and I loved your comments about Worf. I look forward to seeing your review on BOBW and All Good Things.
"If the facts are on your side, pound on the facts. If the law is on your side, pound on the law. If neither is on your side, pound on the table."

"The captain claimed our people violated a 4,000 year old treaty forbidding us to develop hyperspace technology. Extermination of our planet was the consequence. The subject did not survive interrogation."
User avatar
Singular Intellect
Jedi Council Member
Posts: 2392
Joined: 2006-09-19 03:12pm
Location: Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Singular Intellect »

Yes, Q definitely comes across as more dark in this episode, which is a good thing IMO.

Incidently, his trick of just snapping his fingers and flinging the Enterprise seven thousand lightyears in about eleven seconds translates to well over twenty billion times faster than C. :shock:
"Now let us be clear, my friends. The fruits of our science that you receive and the many millions of benefits that justify them, are a gift. Be grateful. Or be silent." -Modified Quote
User avatar
Vympel
Spetsnaz
Spetsnaz
Posts: 29312
Joined: 2002-07-19 01:08am
Location: Sydney Australia

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Vympel »

I'm surprised you didn't make any jokes about Total Recall - the actress who plays Ensign Gomez was the three-breasted prostitute. :)
Like Legend of Galactic Heroes? Please contribute to http://gineipaedia.com/
User avatar
El Moose Monstero
Moose Rebellion Ambassador
Posts: 3743
Joined: 2003-04-30 12:33pm
Location: The Cradle of the Rebellion... Oop Nowrrth, Like...
Contact:

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by El Moose Monstero »

Interesting about the toning down of the character (whether by deLancie or direction), I always assumed that the dark trickster/teacher figure was intentional. I love Q in this and in the end of All Good Things, especially the latter, the final conversation with Picard remains one of my favourite scenes of TNG for the interaction between the two actors. I always felt pleased that I missed out on Voyager's Q episodes, so with the exception of the DS9 one, Q is largely unspoiled for me.
Image
"...a fountain of mirth, issuing forth from the penis of a cupid..." ~ Dalton / Winner of the 'Frank Hipper Most Horrific Drag EVAR' award - 2004 / The artist formerly known as The_Lumberjack.

Evil Brit Conspiracy: Token Moose Obsessed Kebab Munching Semi Geordie
User avatar
DaveJB
Jedi Council Member
Posts: 1917
Joined: 2003-10-06 05:37pm
Location: Leeds, UK

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by DaveJB »

Ghost Rider wrote:Your conclusion is something I think even the Trek writers either never thought of or some poor soul truly meant it to be, somewhere...somehow. Nonetheless it gives the entire Borg/Picard vendetta a wonderful angle.
I don't know if it was intended or not, but likely the fact that the early Borg episodes were written by people who did believe in Roddenberry's utopian stuff (Hurley, possibly Piller as well) and then someone like Ron Moore (who never seemed to subscribe to any of Roddenberry's views) co-writing First Contact was responsible for this little arc.

A lot of the credit for this episode is probably deserved by the director, Rob Bowman, who by all indications forced the story into a more serious, downplayed mode than was originally intended. Not surprisingly, once Berman took over Bowman only showed up on the series once more, and that was apparently because no-one else wanted to do a certain FX-heavy episode. :roll:
Glom
Youngling
Posts: 85
Joined: 2008-12-07 06:36am

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Glom »

DaveJB wrote:Ron Moore (who never seemed to subscribe to any of Roddenberry's views)
Ron Moore wasn't up on the vision? Wow! You'd never realise it looking at his latest work.
User avatar
PREDATOR490
Jedi Council Member
Posts: 1790
Joined: 2006-03-13 08:04am
Location: Scotland

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by PREDATOR490 »

It is interesting to note that by doing this Q not only saved the Federation from the Borg.
Without this intervention, Wolf 359 would never have occured and Benjamin Sisko wouldnt have been shipped to DS9 after the loss of his wife in that battle.
If the Bajor wormhole was opened again then not only would the Federation be unprepared for the Borg - who realistically never were much of a constant threat beyond sporadic attacks.
They would have been even less prepared for the inevitable confrontation with the Dominion which ended up using a considerable amount of technology the Federation had been developing against the Borg. The Defiant being the most obvious example.

Wether or not this could have factored into Q's antics is entirely up to speculation though. It does seem rather apparant that Q has an above average intrest in Picard. His one appearance in DS9 pretty much established him as someone looking for a bit of a challenge and Sisko didnt satisfy with being 'easier to provoke'

I rather liked this episode, even watching it briefly in hindsight it manages to remain effective. Although, the ending bit with Guinan seemed a bit interesting. She told Picard the werent supposed to meet them yet and that in time the Federation might be able to reason with them. I'm guessing thats what would happen after a situation like Endgame for whatever Borg survived.
That would make for a pretty interesting twist in Admiral Janeway's future, if the Borg had decided to be diplomatic while the Feds have 'ways to defend against the Borg'
Letting the Borg become a member of the Federation and teaching them to seek better ways to improve life for everyone ?
User avatar
The Romulan Republic
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 21559
Joined: 2008-10-15 01:37am

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by The Romulan Republic »

PREDATOR490 wrote:It is interesting to note that by doing this Q not only saved the Federation from the Borg.
Without this intervention, Wolf 359 would never have occured and Benjamin Sisko wouldnt have been shipped to DS9 after the loss of his wife in that battle.
If the Bajor wormhole was opened again then not only would the Federation be unprepared for the Borg - who realistically never were much of a constant threat beyond sporadic attacks.
They would have been even less prepared for the inevitable confrontation with the Dominion which ended up using a considerable amount of technology the Federation had been developing against the Borg. The Defiant being the most obvious example.

Wether or not this could have factored into Q's antics is entirely up to speculation though. It does seem rather apparant that Q has an above average intrest in Picard. His one appearance in DS9 pretty much established him as someone looking for a bit of a challenge and Sisko didnt satisfy with being 'easier to provoke'
I wouldn't put it past Q to have worked out such a long-term plan. The Q can travel through time, correct, and across the galaxy? I'm sure Q knew all about the Dominion. In any case, I don't think he was warning the Federation/Picard about the Borg specifically, so much as he was using the Borg as an example of the many dangers they would face.
I rather liked this episode, even watching it briefly in hindsight it manages to remain effective. Although, the ending bit with Guinan seemed a bit interesting. She told Picard the werent supposed to meet them yet and that in time the Federation might be able to reason with them. I'm guessing thats what would happen after a situation like Endgame for whatever Borg survived.
That would make for a pretty interesting twist in Admiral Janeway's future, if the Borg had decided to be diplomatic while the Feds have 'ways to defend against the Borg'
Letting the Borg become a member of the Federation and teaching them to seek better ways to improve life for everyone ?
I like to think that the Borg originated from something very like the Federation. Their are actually certain similarities to how they operate, with both seeking to advance to a more perfect state through incorporating the abilities and resources of other species. The differences are probably more in the methods they use than the goal. It might also add a further explanation of why the Borg are so interested in the Federation, if they originated from something similar. I think part of the effectiveness of the Borg as a character/enemy is that while they provide a stark contrast with the Federation, their are also some similarities.

It would be interesting to eventually see some sort of negotiation between the two. The Borg don't normally negotiate, but they can be brought to do so if its clearly in their interests (Species 8472). If the Federation develops to a point where its a serious threat to the Borg, but is willing to negotiate, it might be possible. After all, the Borg as depicted in Voyager at any rate have a great deal to gain from working with the Federation, since they seem rather stagnant and unable to develop.
User avatar
Themightytom
Sith Devotee
Posts: 2818
Joined: 2007-12-22 11:11am
Location: United States

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Themightytom »

The Romulan Republic wrote:
I like to think that the Borg originated from something very like the Federation.
you really don't want to read the crap fest that is the Destiny Trilogy than.

I'd heard that "The neutral Zone" was actually supposed to be a two parter featuring the Borg, but they copped out. I WEPT when Soonenburg commented they were originally supposed to be insects because thst one decision alone would hsve kept the borg from sliding into "typical alien of the week" Even if they had decided to include the nano probe stupidity, how much more terrifying would it have been or picard to find himself mutating into a giant insect? he DEFINITELY wouldn't be back from THAT in one episode.

Just to add to the commentary that Q sent picard to he borg to demonstrate that humanity is not as evolved as it seems to presume it is, the episode where Worf was skipping through alternate realities gave us a dark look at what would have happened if the borg had assimilated Earth. When they created an anomaly that began to regurgitate alternate universe enterprises, one of them had no problem trying to annihalate worf's shuttle so they could stay where they were and not go back.

"Since when is "the west" a nation?"-Styphon
"ACORN= Cobra obviously." AMT
This topic is... oh Village Idiot. Carry on then.--Havok
User avatar
The Romulan Republic
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 21559
Joined: 2008-10-15 01:37am

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by The Romulan Republic »

Themightytom wrote:
The Romulan Republic wrote:
I like to think that the Borg originated from something very like the Federation.
you really don't want to read the crap fest that is the Destiny Trilogy than.
Why? What's so crappy about it?
I'd heard that "The neutral Zone" was actually supposed to be a two parter featuring the Borg, but they copped out. I WEPT when Soonenburg commented they were originally supposed to be insects because thst one decision alone would hsve kept the borg from sliding into "typical alien of the week" Even if they had decided to include the nano probe stupidity, how much more terrifying would it have been or picard to find himself mutating into a giant insect? he DEFINITELY wouldn't be back from THAT in one episode.
Never underestimate the reset button. Don't forget that Paris and Janeway managed to turn into salamanders and back in one episode. Of course, that was Voyager, not TNG.
User avatar
Setzer
Requiescat in Pace
Posts: 3138
Joined: 2002-08-30 11:45am

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Setzer »

Barclay mutated into an insect, I think. It was more ridiculous then scary.
Image
User avatar
PREDATOR490
Jedi Council Member
Posts: 1790
Joined: 2006-03-13 08:04am
Location: Scotland

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by PREDATOR490 »

The Romulan Republic wrote: I like to think that the Borg originated from something very like the Federation. Their are actually certain similarities to how they operate, with both seeking to advance to a more perfect state through incorporating the abilities and resources of other species. The differences are probably more in the methods they use than the goal. It might also add a further explanation of why the Borg are so interested in the Federation, if they originated from something similar. I think part of the effectiveness of the Borg as a character/enemy is that while they provide a stark contrast with the Federation, their are also some similarities.
I distinctly recall the Queen telling Data the Borg used to be like the Federation / humans before and the link to the clip Patrick posted has Guinan claiming the Borg have been around for 'thousands of centuries'.
We also have Seven of Nine stating the Borg memory is fragmented from as far back as 900 years - 'Dragons Teeth' ?
Additionally, a rogue starfleet officer gone Maquis in DS9 literally called the Federation worse than the Borg to Sisko's face along the lines of what you just stated. So it does make for a valid reason why the Borg would be interested in them.
As for the latter, the Dominion were supposed to be a 'stark' contrast to the Federation too. They are a combination of races led by the changelings who think they are better than everyone else and bring 'order' to the peons.
Exchange 'changelings; with humans and 'order' with the Prime Directive you get the Federation treading extremely close to that kind of thinking. Naturally, the Dominion are the 'bad guys' and get rendered into the 2D 'bad' enemies to a degree but you could make the point that the Federation will end up like the Dominion in the end.
The result of the encounters with the Borg and the Dominion are making the Federation become much more militaristic with their forces and with people like Janeway who literally decide to alter time on a selfish whim...
The Romulan Republic wrote: It would be interesting to eventually see some sort of negotiation between the two. The Borg don't normally negotiate, but they can be brought to do so if its clearly in their interests (Species 8472). If the Federation develops to a point where its a serious threat to the Borg, but is willing to negotiate, it might be possible. After all, the Borg as depicted in Voyager at any rate have a great deal to gain from working with the Federation, since they seem rather stagnant and unable to develop.
My interpretation is the Borg look on everyone else like the Q or even the Federation look down on people. The latter do it with their Prime Directives etc.
The Voyager reviews already have one instance where Janeway was going to let mass genoicde happen because the Prime Directive said so and it is the 'natural evolution'.
The Borg depicted here just look at E-D as a resource. Like you might look at cattle.

Hence, inorder to negotiate with the Borg you need to actually make yourself 'worthy'. Like anyone wanting to join the Federation or those seeking to get help have to meet the rules of the almighty Prime Directive.
If your Pre-warp your not worth shit to the Federation except when you have something we want and we can put cloaked observation posts on your planet to watch you etc.
TNG: Who Watches the Watchers
TNG Insurrection: - In which case the Federation WERE acting like the Borg = You have something we want, GTFO so we can take it

I would suspect this is what Guinan meant. The Federation may be able to make the Borg recognise them as more than the shit they are used to.
Which leads to the situation which followed. The Federation managed to do so and the Borg decided the people were worth assimilating as much as their technology.
It stands to reason that the Borg have rarely negotiated with anyone and thus their ability to do so has been reduced to all but the basics like in Scorpian and thus inorder to really get on with the Borg your going to have to teach them to play nice as well as see you as an equal rather than a bug under the microscope.
User avatar
Themightytom
Sith Devotee
Posts: 2818
Joined: 2007-12-22 11:11am
Location: United States

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Themightytom »

Setzer wrote:Barclay mutated into an insect, I think. It was more ridiculous then scary.
The Romulan Republic wrote:
Themightytom wrote:
The Romulan Republic wrote:
I like to think that the Borg originated from something very like the Federation.
you really don't want to read the crap fest that is the Destiny Trilogy than.
Why? What's so crappy about it?

Never underestimate the reset button. Don't forget that Paris and Janeway managed to turn into salamanders and back in one episode. Of course, that was Voyager, not TNG.
Yeah Voyager was further down alon the progression of rediculousness though, Picard/Locutus was one o the first instances of radical mutation/radical reset.

Reguarding the destiny series, Spoiler
I could seriously write pages, but regarding specifically the Borg, they retcon an awkward genesis of the borg, by creating an advanced race that has apparently been present the whole time. The series involves lots of time travel, lots of suspiciously convenient plot devices, retcons, "forgotten" technologies" and ends with a pretty sanitized ending complete with stickers and ponies, and wonderfully happy lives for all the drones that make up the borg. They even manage to write Worf into dueling with a Hirogen with his trusty batleth. They hang enough lanterns to light new york. Essentially the origin for the borg also flis in the face of what you stated you would like to think.

"Since when is "the west" a nation?"-Styphon
"ACORN= Cobra obviously." AMT
This topic is... oh Village Idiot. Carry on then.--Havok
User avatar
Kuja
The Dark Messenger
Posts: 19322
Joined: 2002-07-11 12:05am
Location: AZ

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Kuja »

"If you can't take a little bloody nose, maybe you'd better go back home and hide under your bed. It's not safe out here. It's wondrous, with treasures to satisfy desires both subtle and gross. But it's not for the timid."

The entire climax remains one of my favorite pieces of sci-fi, anywhere.
Image
JADAFETWA
User avatar
JME2
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 12258
Joined: 2003-02-02 04:04pm

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by JME2 »

Kuja wrote:"If you can't take a little bloody nose, maybe you'd better go back home and hide under your bed. It's not safe out here. It's wondrous, with treasures to satisfy desires both subtle and gross. But it's not for the timid."

The entire climax remains one of my favorite pieces of sci-fi, anywhere.
That's probably my favorite piece of Q dialogue in all of Star Trek.

And I only thumbed through the last third of the final Destiny book, but it looks like it was indeed the crap fest that that brief perusal (and the earlier review of Book 1) made it out to be.
Samuel
Sith Marauder
Posts: 4750
Joined: 2008-10-23 11:36am

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Samuel »

Setzer wrote:Barclay mutated into an insect, I think. It was more ridiculous then scary.
A spider actually. No, the technobble didn't make sense in that case either.

The borg from this episode and the card game are the best- all others are discontinuity and Federation propaganda.
User avatar
Gandalf
SD.net White Wizard
Posts: 16351
Joined: 2002-09-16 11:13pm
Location: A video store in Australia

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Gandalf »

Samuel wrote:The borg from this episode and the card game are the best- all others are discontinuity and Federation propaganda.
Which card game?

If you mean the first edition of the Decipher one, I'd agree to an extent.
"Oh no, oh yeah, tell me how can it be so fair
That we dying younger hiding from the police man over there
Just for breathing in the air they wanna leave me in the chair
Electric shocking body rocking beat streeting me to death"

- A.B. Original, Report to the Mist

"I think it’s the duty of the comedian to find out where the line is drawn and cross it deliberately."
- George Carlin
Glom
Youngling
Posts: 85
Joined: 2008-12-07 06:36am

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by Glom »

Are you going to do a video review of First Contact?
User avatar
General Zod
Never Shuts Up
Posts: 29211
Joined: 2003-11-18 03:08pm
Location: The Clearance Rack
Contact:

Re: ONGEG Video: Q Who

Post by General Zod »

Themightytom wrote:Even if they had decided to include the nano probe stupidity, how much more terrifying would it have been or picard to find himself mutating into a giant insect? he DEFINITELY wouldn't be back from THAT in one episode.
I dunno, species 90210 wasn't all that scary. :lol:
"It's you Americans. There's something about nipples you hate. If this were Germany, we'd be romping around naked on the stage here."
Post Reply