Page 1 of 1

Should I make this forum viewable by guests?

Posted: 2002-12-17 02:35pm
by Darth Wong
This forum is currently visible only if you're logged in. I did this because it's a spoiler forum. But is this important? Is it worth the inconvenience of having to log in just to view the forum? Or should I make it guest-viewable?

Posted: 2002-12-17 02:47pm
by Sea Skimmer
I'm always logged in, thus resulting in me not giving a damn.

My opinion (for what it's worth)

Posted: 2002-12-17 02:59pm
by Pastor Andy
As a long-time visitor to the site, I was considering whether or not to become registered. The fact that this particular forum was viewable only to those who had registered helped to make the decision for me. Thus, keeping this forum for registered users only may be seen as a possible "recruiting method."

Re: My opinion (for what it's worth)

Posted: 2002-12-17 03:19pm
by neoolong
Pastor Andy wrote:As a long-time visitor to the site, I was considering whether or not to become registered. The fact that this particular forum was viewable only to those who had registered helped to make the decision for me. Thus, keeping this forum for registered users only may be seen as a possible "recruiting method."
The problem being that they wouldn't know about it until after they registered or read one of the posts that mentions it.

Posted: 2002-12-17 03:44pm
by C.S.Strowbridge
Hmm ... Is there a way to limit posts untill a person is registered for say 24 hours. That way we wouldn't get people reading one post and deciding to flame the board because of it.

Sort of a cooling off period for posting.

Posted: 2002-12-17 04:21pm
by Bug-Eyed Earl
Sea Skimmer wrote:I'm always logged in, thus resulting in me not giving a damn.
Ditto.

Posted: 2002-12-17 05:27pm
by Pastor Andy
The problem being that they wouldn't know about it until after they registered or read one of the posts that mentions it.
And that's exactly how I learned of this particular forum. I couldn't stand the idea of the latest piece of Trek-drivel being bandied about without at least availing myself of the discussion.

Posted: 2002-12-17 05:31pm
by Master of Ossus
I don't see why this forum should not be opened to everyone. It is labelled "spoilers," so they know what they're getting. Besides, there's nothing secret going on here. It's not like the Moderator forum, where we need to have a closed forum to discuss things. I think it should be opened, though I am glad that some of our guests have decided to register as a result of this forum's closed status.

Posted: 2002-12-17 05:38pm
by FaxModem1
Open it up for peopl who are not logged in, so they can enjoy it, or to put it simpler.

OPEN SESAME!

Posted: 2002-12-17 05:43pm
by Pastor Andy
though I am glad that some of our guests have decided to register as a result of this forum's closed status.
It is both a pleasure and a privilege to join you. My only regret now is not registering sooner! :cry:

Posted: 2002-12-17 05:47pm
by Shinova
Pastor Andy wrote:
though I am glad that some of our guests have decided to register as a result of this forum's closed status.
It is both a pleasure and a privilege to join you. My only regret now is not registering sooner! :cry:

POKAGE!!!


Image



Welcome to stardestroyer.net :)

Posted: 2002-12-17 05:50pm
by FaxModem1
You know, I as a ewbi, escaped being poked by never being noticed, I never got poked. How very odd.

Posted: 2002-12-17 05:56pm
by Crayz9000
FaxModem1 wrote:You know, I as a ewbi, escaped being poked by never being noticed, I never got poked. How very odd.
*stab*

Posted: 2002-12-17 09:38pm
by Yogi
No real reason not to. There's a giant *Spoiler* tacked onto the title for those who didn't know that discussing a movie would spoil it.

Posted: 2002-12-18 12:16am
by Darth Wong
OK, while the hidden forum appears to have gotten us at least one new recruit as an unexpected bonus, most people seem to be saying that it should be public-viewable. So it's now publicly viewable.

Posted: 2002-12-18 12:42am
by Darth Akwat Kbrana
I never got poked. ::feels left out::

Anyway, getting back to the topic, it makes no real difference to me...

Posted: 2002-12-18 12:44am
by Master of Ossus
Darth Akwat Kbrana wrote: I never got poked. ::feels left out::
Terribly sorry. There's clearly been an oversight.
Darth Wong wrote:OK, while the hidden forum appears to have gotten us at least one new recruit as an unexpected bonus, most people seem to be saying that it should be public-viewable. So it's now publicly viewable.


In that case, this thread has served its purpose. Thread closed.