Sothis wrote:Anyone, be they a Trekkie, a Warsie, or a fan of eating raw chicken, will, if educated in the field of physics, reach the same conclusions- that the Empire wins.
In fact, you don't need to be a super-whizz at science to figure out the simple logistical stuff- the Empire's bigger resources, better construction technology, faster FTL...
A lot of Star Trek fans and Star Wars fans simply don't care about the versus debate. They probably view the rest of us as being oddities- even as they stand around with their phasers and lightsabers
Being well educated in physics should tell you that both Trek and Wars are unrealistic fantasies that won't work in our world, right? ; ) I know, I know, hehe.
You don't need a science degree to see who wins, you can simply go "okay, Empire controls a whole galaxy," while the Federation has trouble with a tiny portion of one quadrant, and the Empire wins by sheer numbers, even if you somehow thought they were primitives in comparison (worst case scenario for the Empire: phasers bypass shields somehow, force and hyperdrive "don't work" in Federation space, only low end numbers apply, etc).
Watching Voyager removes most doubt that the Federation is faster. The very concept alone shows that it takes them a long time, even in their more advanced ships, to travel around like that. Star Trek V contradicts this of course, but one example vs. seven seasons of it (plus a few examples in TNG). Most people think ST5 sucked anyway and tend to ignore it.
About the only ways one can reasonably assume that Trek would win (if you're familiar with both) would be to say that the Good Guys Always Win and they'll find some technobabble way to do it, the godlike beings will help them (prophets, Q, the traveler, the dowd, etc) or the Empire will act utterly stupid, with enough incompetence to allow the good guys to win. You know, the "best case scenario" for the Feddies... all the Trek galaxy allies and the Rebels help them, etc.