The Dominion vs. SW Clones

[Darth Servo]

1. Clone armor and Stormtrooper Armor only protects them a little. And even then it doesnt portect at all. Stormtroopers have been killed with one shot to the chest and plenty of Clone troopers were killed by laser fire in AOTC.

Define "a little". Show that the amount of energy clone/stormtrooper armor can block is less than the energy put out by a phaser, particularly since phasers have NEVER done the kind of damage that blasters did to walls in the films.

2. The added armor would slow down a trooper and the bright color white would give away their position easily. Although the Jem'Hadar wear no such armor, they have more maeuverability and their dark colors blend in better to the AR-558 environment.

JH troops have NEVER shown superior maneuverability to SW troops. Color deosn't mean jack to clone troops. In AOTC, the clones were engulfed by a dust cloud created by the crashing Trade Fed ship and they went right on fighting, UNHINDERED!

3. The Machine guns would take to long to set up for a full assult, they would be used for defence like in the movie Aliens. But they would also have men opporating them.

In TESB the E-web was set up in less than 10 seconds. The clones will have plenty of time when the JH are morinically charging towards them.

4. They couldnt steam role over anyone. Thier are 150 of them and they are out numbered by the Jem'Hadar.

Wait a mimute. I thought the scenario was for 150 of each. Did I remember this wrong? And if the clones are defending the position, they will have PLENTY of time before hand to set up their big guns

http://www.stardestroyer.net/Empire/Ess ... ml[quote]5. I dont care what you think about Mech sizes, but in this battle there are none for back up.[/quote]You STILL never posted a pic to prove that AR-558 took place in caves. Those pics on your webpage do NOT show a rook over anyone's head.

But to humor you--as nearly everyone else has already pointed out:
JH idiotically charging the line with hand weapons + Clones with sci-fi machine guns = big pile of rotting JH meat.

[Master of Ossus]

Guys, I would remind you that elite Reman shock-troops were used by the Romulans during the Dominion War to take out priority targets, that were presumably defended by large groups of JH soldiers and/or by elite JH.

Now, judging from the combat effectiveness (or lack thereof) of the Reman forces shown in ST:Nemesis, we see an incredible disparity between the two sides in this conflict. Reman troops REPEATEDLY missed people who were not protected by cover of any kind and were standing still at ranges of well under 10 meters. Clone troopers scored incredible accuracy while moving against targets over 100 meters away during the Battle of Geonosis. If Reman troops are effective at battling Jem'Hadar forces, the clone army would have NO trouble defeating such a crappy military organization.