Syrian moderate rebel 'spymaster' slams CIA for 'ignoring' detailed intel on Isil since 2013

N&P: Discuss governments, nations, politics and recent related news here.

Moderators: Alyrium Denryle, Edi, K. A. Pital

Post Reply
User avatar
Honorius
Youngling
Posts: 124
Joined: 2015-07-27 09:58am

Syrian moderate rebel 'spymaster' slams CIA for 'ignoring' detailed intel on Isil since 2013

Post by Honorius »

"Sigh"
The "spymaster" of a key moderate Syrian rebel group has accused the CIA of failing to act on reams of detailed intelligence his network has been supplying the US on Isil since 2013 - including GPS coordinates of its leaders and headquarters.
The Free Syrian Army’s spy chief insisted proper use of the intelligence his agents provided from within Isil’s ranks, and often at grave risk to their life, could have critically damaged the jihadist group on several occasions.
Speaking to Le Monde in Turkey, “M”, as the French newspaper dubbed the man for security reasons, said: “From the moment Daesh (the Arab acronym for Isil) had 20 members to when it had 20,000, we have shown everything to the Americans. When we asked them what they did with this information, they always gave evasive answers, saying it was up to their decision-makers”.
The Free Syrian Army, or FSA, was founded by a group of defected Syrian Armed Forces officers and soldiers in July 2011, and received backing from Britain and the US for its moderate line.
Le Monde was shown photographs of a training camp in the northern province of Latakia frequented by foreign Isil fighters. “Naturally I transmitted this to my Western contacts with the GPS coordinates but had not response,” he is cited as saying. “Agents of mine also managed to get hold of phone numbers of Isil officials, serial numbers of satellite equipment and IP addresses. But once again, zero response.”

In 2014, FSA fighters under the banner Hazzm Movement were supplied anti-tank missiles in a covert CIA programme and received US military training in Qatar on their use.
In the summer of 2014, while Isil besieged Mossul in Iraq, “M” helped devise a secret plan presented to the Americans to rout Isil from northern Syria on the Azaz-Alep line. The plan was detailed street by street, hour by hour, and included the precise itinerary of fighters and their refuelling points. “In every village held by Daesh, knew the number of armed men, where their offices and hideouts were. We had located snipers and mines, we knew where the local emir slept, the colour of his car and even the brand. From a tactical and strategic point of view, we were ready,” he said.
However, the Americans failed to give the green light, he said.
“They were reluctant to provide us satellite images. They said their planes couldn’t help once the fighting with Isil started. All they offered us was to get rid of a few obstacles before the start of the offensive,” he said.
He then provided the US with details of the Isil command structure in Raqqa, from the emir to those in charge of checkpoints and pages of GPS coordinates. “That was a year and a half ago and Raqqa is still the capital of Daesh,” he said.
Obama has been screwing the FSA since 2013. That they still exist at all is thanks to Erdogan keeping their supply lines open and providing weapons in large enough amounts to keep the fight going for a Free Syria that chooses its leaders via free ballots.
Simon_Jester
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 30165
Joined: 2009-05-23 07:29pm

Re: Syrian moderate rebel 'spymaster' slams CIA for 'ignoring' detailed intel on Isil since 2013

Post by Simon_Jester »

The various militias and factions of the Syrian Civil war that are not aligned with Assad or Da'esh, the 'moderates...'

They are numerous, fractious, poorly coordinated or uncoordinated, and their leadership comes from all over the place politically. How do we know this so-called "spymaster" is telling the truth? How do we know he correctly interpreted and understood what was happening at the time? How do we know he wasn't exaggerating the skill and preparation of his own forces? He has every reason to make himself (and his friends) look good at the expense of others, and no one can realistically confirm or deny his claims.
This space dedicated to Vasily Arkhipov
User avatar
Honorius
Youngling
Posts: 124
Joined: 2015-07-27 09:58am

Re: Syrian moderate rebel 'spymaster' slams CIA for 'ignoring' detailed intel on Isil since 2013

Post by Honorius »

Simon_Jester wrote:The various militias and factions of the Syrian Civil war that are not aligned with Assad or Da'esh, the 'moderates...'

They are numerous, fractious, poorly coordinated or uncoordinated, and their leadership comes from all over the place politically. How do we know this so-called "spymaster" is telling the truth? How do we know he correctly interpreted and understood what was happening at the time? How do we know he wasn't exaggerating the skill and preparation of his own forces? He has every reason to make himself (and his friends) look good at the expense of others, and no one can realistically confirm or deny his claims.
Considering the US had no intel at all in September of 2014 and the FSA was still fighting for Tishrin Dam where US Airstrikes could have helped them seize it and link two separate pockets of FSA Soldiers on both sides of the Euphrates, I believe the story.

FSA was still very potent in September of 2014 and Airstrikes wasted on Kobane could have helped them move on Manbij, al--Bab, Deir Haftr, el-Rai, Jarabulus, and secured Tishrin Dam and have a jump off point to Raqqah. FSA had very potent Armored Forces unlike the PKK terrorists Obama decided to save, and focusing on helping FSA push IS out of the Manbij and Deir Hafr Plains would have handcapped them, boosted the FSA's recruitment base, and opened Raqqah up in 2015 to be recaptured by FSA.

Obama dropped the ball massively and wound up spreading the war to Turkey.
Post Reply