Page 1 of 2

Gears of War gets a 10/10

Posted: 2006-11-07 10:35am
by Count Dooku
1up.com gave Gears of War a 10/10 rating this morning. I keep up with their blogs, and I really thought they were going to be critical when reviewing the game. http://www.1up.com/do/reviewPage?cId=3154958

IGN gave Gears a 9.4/10, which isn't too shabby either: http://xbox360.ign.com/articles/744/744356p1.html

I think I'm going to go get myself a copy of this game. Anyone want to join me in on-line coop?

Posted: 2006-11-07 10:42am
by Molyneux
ARRGH! GRAMMAR SMASH!

It's "gets", not "get's"...

To be on-topic, I'm considering getting the console just for this game. You can't go wrong with chainsaw bayonets.

Posted: 2006-11-07 11:22am
by NmEnforcer
This game is definitely on my "watch list." I am still trying to decide between the 3 systems. I really want a Wii, but it's just because the controllers are so interesting.

This, along with Halo 3, is one of the reasons I'm strongly leading towards the 360. (The pricepoint on the PS3 is another major factor)

Posted: 2006-11-07 11:28am
by Ubiquitous
Thanks for the links, but there was no need to break them - you only break links if we don't want the other side knowing we have linked to them.

Posted: 2006-11-07 11:54am
by Lagmonster
I'm holding out for Microsoft's greed; good Xbox games like Halo often eventually or simultaneously make their way to the PC, where they will be prettier and easier to control.

Also, I unbroke the links. Game reviews aren't critical.

Posted: 2006-11-07 11:55am
by Count Dooku
NmEnforcer wrote:This game is definitely on my "watch list." I am still trying to decide between the 3 systems. I really want a Wii, but it's just because the controllers are so interesting.

This, along with Halo 3, is one of the reasons I'm strongly leading towards the 360. (The pricepoint on the PS3 is another major factor)
Don't forget the new Rainbow Six game - it looks fan-freaking-tastic.

Posted: 2006-11-07 12:05pm
by TheFeniX
Lagmonster wrote:I'm holding out for Microsoft's greed; good Xbox games like Halo often eventually or simultaneously make their way to the PC, where they will be prettier and easier to control.
I don't know. Whereas, I've never played it, I heared some horrible things about the Halo PC port. The graphics were much better, but the game took too much hardware to run for what it offered. Basically, it was a pain to get it to run smooth.

But, Gears of War is Epic Games, so it should have a better track record.

Posted: 2006-11-07 12:13pm
by Lagmonster
TheFeniX wrote:
Lagmonster wrote:I'm holding out for Microsoft's greed; good Xbox games like Halo often eventually or simultaneously make their way to the PC, where they will be prettier and easier to control.
I don't know. Whereas, I've never played it, I heared some horrible things about the Halo PC port. The graphics were much better, but the game took too much hardware to run for what it offered. Basically, it was a pain to get it to run smooth.

But, Gears of War is Epic Games, so it should have a better track record.
I only played Halo on the PC, so I can't compare, but I do know that I can't play FPS games on a console. I just don't have the dexterity for it. Add to that the fact that I can always afford a good computer and it's not a huge problem, really.

Posted: 2006-11-07 12:27pm
by Ace Pace
Epic apprently has no plans for a PC port.

Posted: 2006-11-07 01:19pm
by Stark
Halo got 10/10 back in the day too. :D

PS, 1up impressed me with the shockingly low quality of their journalism in their FIRST PARAGRAPH, so they aren't even as impressive as 'EDGE selling out' back in the 90s. :) 'Oh it's got flaws but we'll give it a perfect score anyway'. LOL!

EDIT - Le sigh, the only other game to use Vietcong's cover system is a 360 game. Hardly seems fair.

Posted: 2006-11-07 01:51pm
by Lagmonster
Ace Pace wrote:Epic apprently has no plans for a PC port.
One thing I never bet on is Microsoft failing to probe a market. It may never come to PC, but that would be surprising as all hell.

Posted: 2006-11-07 01:56pm
by Ace Pace
Stark wrote:Halo got 10/10 back in the day too. :D

PS, 1up impressed me with the shockingly low quality of their journalism in their FIRST PARAGRAPH, so they aren't even as impressive as 'EDGE selling out' back in the 90s. :) 'Oh it's got flaws but we'll give it a perfect score anyway'. LOL!

EDIT - Le sigh, the only other game to use Vietcong's cover system is a 360 game. Hardly seems fair.
Gamespots review is a more realistic 9.6, from what I've seen of the video review, looks like it deserves it, with the only problems being..no real story and a weird difficulty curve.

Posted: 2006-11-07 02:00pm
by Arrow
Ace Pace wrote:Epic apprently has no plans for a PC port.
Only because MS hasn't sent them a check. Yet...

Honestly, I expect GoW (and Mass Effect) to follow the Halo model, where it comes out of the PC a while later. Although hopefully PC users won't have to wait much more than a year to year and half.

Posted: 2006-11-07 02:01pm
by Darth Garden Gnome
Did anyone else think their TV spot for GoW sucked? "Mad World?" What? That doesn't belong there. I want hard fucking core rock-your-face-off metal in a commercial like that.

Posted: 2006-11-07 02:10pm
by Ace Pace
Darth Garden Gnome wrote:Did anyone else think their TV spot for GoW sucked? "Mad World?" What? That doesn't belong there. I want hard fucking core rock-your-face-off metal in a commercial like that.
You mean the nice and peaceful run that ends with him shooting up a monster in a building? I rather liked it.

Posted: 2006-11-07 02:13pm
by Darth Garden Gnome
Nice and peaceful? Sorry, there's nothing peaceful about fucking space marines. When they're running around with nothing to do, heavy metal follows them around regardless. :P

Posted: 2006-11-07 04:36pm
by Max
Darth Garden Gnome wrote:Did anyone else think their TV spot for GoW sucked? "Mad World?" What? That doesn't belong there. I want hard fucking core rock-your-face-off metal in a commercial like that.
I personally liked it....made it more sad and gave me the feeling of hopelessness...

However, the "FPS Hide n Seek" type games like this aren't really all that fun for me. Pretty....but I get bored with them.

Posted: 2006-11-07 05:30pm
by Shogoki
TheFeniX wrote:I don't know. Whereas, I've never played it, I heared some horrible things about the Halo PC port. The graphics were much better, but the game took too much hardware to run for what it offered. Basically, it was a pain to get it to run smooth.

But, Gears of War is Epic Games, so it should have a better track record.
Halo was a horrible resource hog, they like, counteroptimized it for the PC, probably because it was trying to use directx 9, but IIRC you could force it to use dx8 and it worked much much faster while looking the same.

Posted: 2006-11-07 05:51pm
by Spanky The Dolphin
Heh, 1up...

Posted: 2006-11-07 07:18pm
by Vendetta
Darth Garden Gnome wrote:Nice and peaceful? Sorry, there's nothing peaceful about fucking space marines. When they're running around with nothing to do, heavy metal follows them around regardless. :P
Proper space marines would get gothic chants. At all times.

The point of the GoW ad is "you're fucked, no really". Metal doesn't work, metal is power music, for in charge people.

Posted: 2006-11-07 07:29pm
by Elaro
Well, I like the trailer. Nice "cognitive dissonance" effect.

Also, about the Halo PC situation. Well, it's not the smoothest run in the track, but I've got a Radeon X1300 (budget card) and it runs at about 30-45 F/s. It's okay, I guess.

Posted: 2006-11-07 07:31pm
by TheMuffinKing
Eh GoW is all right. I don't like the camera or the controls, yet another console proving the superiority of the PC for FPS games. The game looks nice, but I would prefer: 1. Cheat codes. I WANT ENTERTAINMENT not aggravation. 2. No more of this stupid checkpoint save crap. I want to save as I choose. Very freaking annoying.

Posted: 2006-11-07 07:37pm
by Stark
Cheat codes? LOL!

Posted: 2006-11-07 07:39pm
by TheMuffinKing
Cheats FTW! Except multiplayer, then its boring.

Posted: 2006-11-07 07:51pm
by Stark
Hey, that raises a point - I was GOING to say 'lol teh fps are 34sy fag' but PC fpses are easy. CONSOLE fpses can be crazy nuts hard, like those stupid James Bond fpses. Stuff like FEAR is a walk in the park on 'super hard', but console games seem to be harder. WIERD.