Page 1 of 2
PDA's...are they worth it?
Posted: 2003-09-28 11:30pm
by Hobot
I am now in the exciting world of post-secondary education and I have decided I should make an effort to be more organized. Now, I know I can do that the old fashioned way (agenda book, or the like) but being a technophile I am leaning towards a more complicated and electronic way of doing it. I was thinking of getting a PDA, but there is such a wide variety in terms of price and functionality that I'm overwhelmed; I need some direction!
Posted: 2003-09-28 11:37pm
by Crayz9000
Just get a low-end Palm. They have most of the stuff you'll need, come with synchronization software and are supported by a bunch of organizer programs.
Posted: 2003-09-29 12:31am
by SPOOFE
A PDA is only worth it if you remember to actually use it. I knew a guy that got a Palm, and didn't use it for anything other than cheapo PDA games and a Palm version of the Kama Sutra. 'Twas pretty much a waste of money for him.
Then there's me eldest bro, who uses his PDA for pretty much everything.
Posted: 2003-09-29 01:42am
by MKSheppard
Buy a Sony CLIE and welcome into the world of Cheep (read FREE!) ebooks!
Posted: 2003-09-29 02:08am
by kojikun
The newer Sony PDAs have built in video and audio recording, which could be very useful for lectures and such.
Posted: 2003-09-29 02:22am
by Dalton
I always carry a pen and paper on me. Much more convenient than a fragile battery-hog like a Palm, and you can even tear off bits of paper and give them to people!
Shep, how much is that CLIE thing? It would be more convenient than carrying a book everywhere.
Posted: 2003-09-29 02:39am
by Hotfoot
Dalton wrote:I always carry a pen and paper on me. Much more convenient than a fragile battery-hog like a Palm, and you can even tear off bits of paper and give them to people!
Shep, how much is that CLIE thing? It would be more convenient than carrying a book everywhere.
And so Dalton is laid to waste by the fact that the "fragile battery-hog" is more versatile than his palty pen and paper.
Thus endeth the old age...
Seriously though, I use a Palm m515, and it does good work for most of what I need it for, though eventually I'd like to upgrade to something like the Zire 71 so that I can have smaller fonts (higher res) and maybe a faster processor (the built-in camera would be handy too...my photographic memory doesn't translate to others as well as a digital photo).
Posted: 2003-09-29 03:07am
by MKSheppard
Dalton wrote:
Shep, how much is that CLIE thing? It would be more convenient than carrying a book everywhere.
I got my B&W Clie for about $128 off Ebay, I'll let you know how it
turns out
Posted: 2003-09-29 03:49am
by TrailerParkJawa
Im of the mind that only very busy and very organized people need a Palm. ie) Sales, Sales Support, or other folks that travel alot.
I dont see them being much use for students. I dont use one at work, a trusty compostition notebook and pencil are cheap and easy. Plus I can spill soda on it, drop it, lose it, etc and Im not out much money.
Posted: 2003-09-29 05:53am
by Spanky The Dolphin
My PDA Megumi-chan is a basic Palm Zire. I've found it to be pretty useful for the rather lowend stuff I use it for.
Posted: 2003-09-29 10:13am
by MKSheppard
Spanky The Dolphin wrote:My PDA Megumi-chan is a basic Palm Zire. I've found it to be pretty useful for the rather lowend stuff I use it for.
Out of curiosity, do you name everything you own
I named my Palm IIIxe Guderian, only because I had to when I installed
the Palm Software on my computer
Posted: 2003-09-29 12:49pm
by phongn
I have a Palm VII, but I hardly use it.
Posted: 2003-09-29 01:57pm
by GrandMasterTerwynn
Hah, I own an old HP 360LX handheld PC. It runs Windows CE (gasp!), uses AA batteries, and has a paltry 8 MB of internal memory. But, it reads CF cards and can use a fair number of PCMCIA cards. And it has a built-in keyboard.
Like the others have said, a PDA is only worth as much as you use it. I've used mine to do book editing and reading while on the go (Using Pocket Word)
Posted: 2003-09-29 01:59pm
by Stravo
I've been toying with the idea of getting one but I am so inherently disorganized that I don't know if I'll be able to use the PDAs to their potential to make it worth the expense.
Posted: 2003-09-29 02:00pm
by Ghost Rider
I could see the usage but the problem is the amount of usage.
Sorta like phongn and Stravo, if I got one...I would either not use it, or because of the general mess that I have of things...who knows what would happen to it(So far only my watch, keys and wallet are the only things I truly know where they are at all times)
Posted: 2003-09-29 02:01pm
by Spanky The Dolphin
MKSheppard wrote:Spanky The Dolphin wrote:My PDA Megumi-chan is a basic Palm Zire. I've found it to be pretty useful for the rather lowend stuff I use it for.
Out of curiosity, do you name everything you own
I named my Palm IIIxe Guderian, only because I had to when I installed
the Palm Software on my computer
Nah, only things like computers and the like.
Sarah and Megumi-chan are so far the only things that I've named. The PDA was mostly named for the same reason as yours.
Posted: 2003-09-29 09:02pm
by phongn
I'm highly tempted to get an old Newton MessagePad 2100.
Posted: 2003-09-30 12:22am
by MKSheppard
Stravo wrote:I've been toying with the idea of getting one but I am so inherently disorganized that I don't know if I'll be able to use the PDAs to their potential to make it worth the expense.
Always buy the second generation models going out on the discount
market for roughly the $100~ and under range each year if you want
a PDA. Let the morons with more money than common sense fund
every PDA manufacturer's R&D efforts.
Posted: 2003-09-30 12:29am
by Hobot
Wow, my problems were solved today when a guy brought in two big boxes full of Palm IIIe's and portable keyboards and sold them for 60 Canadian (40 odd US) each. According to him, he bought them wholesale. I searched the web for free useful software and now I have a lean mean organizing machine! I even found a neat little circuit diagram design program which might be useful (I'm doing electronics).
Posted: 2003-09-30 09:12am
by phongn
Is that the folding Palm/Targus keyboard?
Posted: 2003-09-30 01:57pm
by Soulman
I don't use my PDA as a PDA. I mainly use it as a ebook reader (thanks Baen) and when I get an SD card I'll be able to watch tv programmes that I've recorded on my PC. I rarely use it for organising anything.
Posted: 2003-09-30 03:52pm
by MKSheppard
Soulman wrote:I don't use my PDA as a PDA. I mainly use it as a ebook reader (thanks Baen) and when I get an SD card I'll be able to watch tv programmes that I've recorded on my PC. I rarely use it for organising anything.
Wait...how the hell can you record a damned TV show and make it fit on
a SD card?
Posted: 2003-09-30 03:58pm
by Hotfoot
MKSheppard wrote:Soulman wrote:I don't use my PDA as a PDA. I mainly use it as a ebook reader (thanks Baen) and when I get an SD card I'll be able to watch tv programmes that I've recorded on my PC. I rarely use it for organising anything.
Wait...how the hell can you record a damned TV show and make it fit on
a SD card?
Using DiVX compression and turning down the resolution slightly, you could easily make a half-hour show show smaller than 120MB, and there are 256MB SD cards out there (heck, I've seen 512MB cards, though those are usually a different type).
Posted: 2003-09-30 04:01pm
by MKSheppard
Hotfoot wrote:(heck, I've seen 512MB cards, though those are usually a different type).
Cost you $400 tho
Posted: 2003-09-30 04:05pm
by Hotfoot
MKSheppard wrote:Hotfoot wrote:(heck, I've seen 512MB cards, though those are usually a different type).
Cost you $400 tho
What? No way. Heck, the 256MB ones I saw were as low as $80. The 512s were something like $140 I think, but then they don't fit in a standard palm expansion slot.