Page 1 of 1

Help me get a new CPU Heatsink+Fan

Posted: 2004-04-30 01:53am
by Shinova
I'm not sure if I'll be buying from Fry's but anyway,



Yes, I know how to dress ridiculously long links


From that list, which should I get?

Posted: 2004-04-30 11:33am
by General Zod
real men use water coolants. if you can afford it that is. :D

Posted: 2004-04-30 11:36am
by phongn

Posted: 2004-04-30 07:53pm
by Shinova
What's the second best?

Posted: 2004-04-30 09:31pm
by Dalton
phongn wrote:This one
My friend has that monster. You actually have to brace the thing because it's so heavy.

Posted: 2004-04-30 09:41pm
by InnocentBystander
Darth_Zod wrote:real men use water coolants. if you can afford it that is. :D
Water cooling is unnecessary and extravagant. The only reason you'd water cooling is: Your computer is in a region that gets excessively hot or you’re over clocking your computer. And, if I might comment, over clocking is an enthusiasts hobby which does very little to actually improve your computer’s performance, if anything it shortens its lifespan at the cost of an unnoticeable number of frames per second or loading time. I’ve done it, it was fun, but it’s really just an excuse to tinker with your hardware. All you need is a heat sink with a fan on top and a pair of fans in the case to keep the air moving, air in, air out, that is the key.

Posted: 2004-04-30 09:55pm
by Shinova
Dalton wrote:
phongn wrote:This one
My friend has that monster. You actually have to brace the thing because it's so heavy.
An unforseen complication. I wonder what I should use to "brace" the thing.

Posted: 2004-04-30 11:09pm
by phongn
Dalton wrote:
phongn wrote:This one
My friend has that monster. You actually have to brace the thing because it's so heavy.
You do? I thought the age of needing bolts was long gone ...

There should be other Zalmans that don't require as strong mounting, but they won't perform near as well.

As for why I recommended it -- it isn't the best cooler. However, it is relatively quiet while still providing good cooling.

Posted: 2004-04-30 11:34pm
by Dalton
Shinova wrote:An unforseen complication. I wonder what I should use to "brace" the thing.
phongn wrote:You do? I thought the age of needing bolts was long gone ...
AFAIK, and according to my friend, you have to actually put a screw through it, the motherboard and screw it into the case to make sure it doesn't crack the socket...

Posted: 2004-04-30 11:51pm
by Pu-239
InnocentBystander wrote:
Darth_Zod wrote:real men use water coolants. if you can afford it that is. :D
Water cooling is unnecessary and extravagant. The only reason you'd water cooling is: Your computer is in a region that gets excessively hot or you’re over clocking your computer. And, if I might comment, over clocking is an enthusiasts hobby which does very little to actually improve your computer’s performance, if anything it shortens its lifespan at the cost of an unnoticeable number of frames per second or loading time. I’ve done it, it was fun, but it’s really just an excuse to tinker with your hardware. All you need is a heat sink with a fan on top and a pair of fans in the case to keep the air moving, air in, air out, that is the key.
Isn't it quieter though?

Posted: 2004-05-01 12:13am
by Vertigo1
Pu-239 wrote:Isn't it quieter though?
In some cases, yes. However, it all depends on the pump and how many fans you have on your radiator.

Posted: 2004-05-01 12:14am
by phongn
Yes. Watercooling is typically very quiet.

Posted: 2004-05-01 03:22am
by InnocentBystander
Pu-239 wrote:
InnocentBystander wrote:
Darth_Zod wrote:real men use water coolants. if you can afford it that is. :D
Water cooling is unnecessary and extravagant. The only reason you'd water cooling is: Your computer is in a region that gets excessively hot or you’re over clocking your computer. And, if I might comment, over clocking is an enthusiasts hobby which does very little to actually improve your computer’s performance, if anything it shortens its lifespan at the cost of an unnoticeable number of frames per second or loading time. I’ve done it, it was fun, but it’s really just an excuse to tinker with your hardware. All you need is a heat sink with a fan on top and a pair of fans in the case to keep the air moving, air in, air out, that is the key.
Isn't it quieter though?
Does noise matter that much to you? Your using the computer to play games mostly, you wouldn't hear it. Besides, you get used to whatever sounds your computer makes after a while. My old computer had a DVD-ROM drive back when they were new; I went to use it the other day, the drive was really very nosiy; but I didn't notice back when I used it everyday, you just live with it.
Besides, as you don't buy those cheap $5 fans I doubt there would be a sound issue.
Also, don't you have to refill the water every now and then?

Posted: 2004-05-01 01:56pm
by Pu-239
InnocentBystander wrote:
Pu-239 wrote:
InnocentBystander wrote: Water cooling is unnecessary and extravagant. The only reason you'd water cooling is: Your computer is in a region that gets excessively hot or you’re over clocking your computer. And, if I might comment, over clocking is an enthusiasts hobby which does very little to actually improve your computer’s performance, if anything it shortens its lifespan at the cost of an unnoticeable number of frames per second or loading time. I’ve done it, it was fun, but it’s really just an excuse to tinker with your hardware. All you need is a heat sink with a fan on top and a pair of fans in the case to keep the air moving, air in, air out, that is the key.
Isn't it quieter though?
Does noise matter that much to you? Your using the computer to play games mostly, you wouldn't hear it. Besides, you get used to whatever sounds your computer makes after a while. My old computer had a DVD-ROM drive back when they were new; I went to use it the other day, the drive was really very nosiy; but I didn't notice back when I used it everyday, you just live with it.
Besides, as you don't buy those cheap $5 fans I doubt there would be a sound issue.
Also, don't you have to refill the water every now and then?
Actually, I don't use water cooling. I have a Pentium II 450 w/ passive cooling :P .

Posted: 2004-05-01 10:40pm
by Shinova
I ended up grabbing the Zalman cooler that's part aluminum, part copper instead of the all-copper one. More or less same great and quiet performance, none of the excessive weight.

It's working great now. Thanks everyone for your suggestions. :)

Posted: 2004-05-01 11:01pm
by phongn
Shinova wrote:I ended up grabbing the Zalman cooler that's part aluminum, part copper instead of the all-copper one. More or less same great and quiet performance, none of the excessive weight.

It's working great now. Thanks everyone for your suggestions. :)
Gah, I forgot about that. The AlCu version actually has superior cooling performance over the pure-Cu one and is lighter to boot.