Page 1 of 2

Nintendo DS vs. Sony PSP: FIGHT!

Posted: 2004-05-12 01:14am
by phongn
Alrighty, at E3, the Nintendo DS was released -- their new portable gaming system with dual-screens. It is more powerful than an N64 yet small enough to fit in a largish pocket.

Sony has finally brought out their Playstation Portable and it too looks good.

If you want pics, use Google :p

Posted: 2004-05-12 01:27am
by Spanky The Dolphin
Wow, the PSP is truly gorgeous...

EDIT: Here are some really good and huge pics of the PSP:
http://www.ferrago.com/media/3562

Posted: 2004-05-12 01:44am
by Icehawk
Interesting, although I wonder if the two screen perspective thing will cause problems for developers or if they will even bother to make much use of it. An interesting idea though.

Personally im still leaning toward the PSP as it is more compact and I prefer the 16x9 display. The dual screen GB DS may very well have a higher price because of its extra LCD screen as well though we'll have to wait and see.

Posted: 2004-05-12 02:29am
by Ace Pace
Watching the DS in action (in comaprision to the PSP, who up till now has only shown movies), I think DS will win, HUGE battery life, no extravagent price, and look at the games!

Posted: 2004-05-12 04:44pm
by Anarchist Bunny
The PSP looks... ew.

Posted: 2004-05-12 04:51pm
by Sharp-kun
I have my dounts about the PSP. One of which is the fact that Sony have yet to show that it will be more durable than the PS2.

Posted: 2004-05-12 05:26pm
by Spanky The Dolphin
Anarchist Bunny wrote:The PSP looks... ew.
What's wrong with it, specifically?

I love it, personally. It's understated and fits with Sony's current design ethics for their other products.

Posted: 2004-05-12 06:57pm
by Robert Treder
Spanky The Dolphin wrote:
Anarchist Bunny wrote:The PSP looks... ew.
What's wrong with it, specifically?

I love it, personally. It's understated and fits with Sony's current design ethics for their other products.
To me, it looks good, but it also looks like it'd be a pain to hold.

The DS looks pretty sick. From what I hear, it'll have an IM-type service within its 30-ft range, and it allows for wireless multiplay, and you can play multiplayer even if you haven't bought the cartridge. And the lower screen can be used as a touch-screen. On top of that, it's backwards compatible with old Gameboy/Gameboy Advanced cartridges.

They say it has voice control, too, but I've always thought that was kind of a lame gimmick.

Posted: 2004-05-13 12:46am
by AnimeJet
http://www.nintendo.com/e3_2004/ds/ds_overview.jsp

-Dual screens, each 3" diagonally, backlit.
-Lower screen is touch screen
-Microphone w/ voice recognition
-Wireless gaming + chatting
-Two slots for backwards compatability and add-ons

DS is so gonna pwn PSP in the ass >.>

Posted: 2004-05-13 12:53am
by Spanky The Dolphin
The DS just seems to gimicky, though (that and it looks like it's made by Playskool). Then there's Nintendo's little platform dedication problem to deal with...

Posted: 2004-05-13 03:51am
by Clone Sergeant
Based on what I've read, the most recent photos of the DS are of a functioning prototype mockup and the final design has yet to be decided upon.

Both look very promising to me. The games being developed for the PSP will be probably be very competitive with whatever Nintendo puts out for the DS. Metal Gear:Acid and GT4 for example. On the other, hand the DS can run games that are in-between the N64 and the GCN in quality so expect a glut of retro ports (good and bad) for it. In all likelyhood, I will end up buying both. Unless the price point for the PSP is too ridiculous, given all the features Sony plans on shipping it with.

Posted: 2004-05-13 03:57am
by Icehawk
Has their been any concrete hardware specs released for either of them? Like how fast a processor and how much ram etc.?

Posted: 2004-05-13 07:17am
by Admiral Valdemar
Gimmicks!

Valdemar laughs, laughs I say, at those that insist on buying every console out there especially when brand new.

Valdemar knew many people who bought the first version of the N-Gage for full price only to find a newer, better designed version come out for cheaper.

My GB Colo(u)r has always been faithful to me when the need for portable videogaming has been necessary.

Other than that, I read a damn book.

Posted: 2004-05-13 12:39pm
by Ace Pace
Spanky The Dolphin wrote:The DS just seems to gimicky, though (that and it looks like it's made by Playskool). Then there's Nintendo's little platform dedication problem to deal with...
People who have used the DS say its easy to get used to, and its very fun.


On the PSP, we have seen NO games running on it, only movie trailers, makes me wonder.

Posted: 2004-05-13 01:58pm
by phongn
Spanky The Dolphin wrote:The DS just seems to gimicky, though (that and it looks like it's made by Playskool). Then there's Nintendo's little platform dedication problem to deal with...
IIRC, Nintendo has always been pretty dedicated to their portable machines, if not their home consoles.

Posted: 2004-05-13 02:18pm
by Vendetta
Ace Pace wrote: On the PSP, we have seen NO games running on it, only movie trailers, makes me wonder.
We have seen mockups though, which look like reasonable PS2 games.

Posted: 2004-05-13 02:20pm
by Ace Pace
My bad, watching GS live, it seems some games running, I don't remember names. But why music\video\games? Why are they going the bloated N-gage way?

Posted: 2004-05-13 03:48pm
by The Kernel
Icehawk wrote:Has their been any concrete hardware specs released for either of them? Like how fast a processor and how much ram etc.?
Yes, and the PSP is far more powerful. The PSP uses a MIPS CPU very similar to the one in the PS2 with 32MB of RAM and 4MB of embedded cache on the GPU (strikingly similar to the PS2 eh?). For all intents and purposes, the PSP is just as powerful as the PS2, only in a handheld package.

Judging by what we've seen of the DS games, it doesn't appear to be even as much of a polygon pusher as the N64. We'll know more as soon as Nintendo releases official specs.

Posted: 2004-05-13 03:56pm
by The Kernel
Robert Treder wrote: To me, it looks good, but it also looks like it'd be a pain to hold.
It uses the same setup as the late Lynx which was a joy to hold.

Posted: 2004-05-13 05:23pm
by Admiral Valdemar
If you want to see what the PSP can do, can we say MGS2 level quality?

Posted: 2004-05-13 05:31pm
by SirNitram
Ace Pace wrote:My bad, watching GS live, it seems some games running, I don't remember names. But why music\video\games? Why are they going the bloated N-gage way?
Don't you mean 'The same way the Playstation went'?

Posted: 2004-05-13 05:36pm
by SAMAS
Admiral Valdemar wrote:Gimmicks!

Valdemar laughs, laughs I say, at those that insist on buying every console out there especially when brand new.

Valdemar knew many people who bought the first version of the N-Gage for full price only to find a newer, better designed version come out for cheaper.
No, I think the games were humiliation enough. :mrgreen:
My GB Colo(u)r has always been faithful to me when the need for portable videogaming has been necessary.


*Taunts AV with SP and copies of Metroid Zero Mission and Advance Wars*

Posted: 2004-05-13 06:01pm
by Spanky The Dolphin
Admiral Valdemar wrote:If you want to see what the PSP can do, can we say MGS2 level quality?
Nice. I might actually look into getting one once they come out.

Posted: 2004-05-13 07:00pm
by Hamel
One of the pictures of the DS had Mario Kart 64(?) on the display. A wall looked extremely pixelated as if it was rendered on a 486.

OTOH, the Metroid game looked 64'ish

Posted: 2004-05-13 07:10pm
by Bob McDob
Ace Pace wrote:
Spanky The Dolphin wrote:The DS just seems to gimicky, though (that and it looks like it's made by Playskool). Then there's Nintendo's little platform dedication problem to deal with...
People who have used the DS say its easy to get used to, and its very fun.


On the PSP, we have seen NO games running on it, only movie trailers, makes me wonder.
Actually, there were games running on it at E3, which my understanding is looked "fantastic".