Page 1 of 1

nVidia 6200 vs ATi X300

Posted: 2005-07-05 09:00pm
by Pu-239
Which is better (laptop chips, so don't say get something better)? Essentially Dell D610 vs http://www.compusa.com/products/product ... pfp=BROWSE

Oh, and how do they compare in durability/quality?

Re: nVidia 6200 vs ATi X300

Posted: 2005-07-05 09:15pm
by Hamel
Pu-239 wrote:Which is better (laptop chips, so don't say get something better)? Essentially Dell D610 vs http://www.compusa.com/products/product ... pfp=BROWSE

Oh, and how do they compare in durability/quality?
The 6200, 128 bit version that is.

Posted: 2005-07-06 04:27am
by Tiger Ace
The 6200, aslong as its not turbo cache.

Posted: 2005-07-06 11:43am
by Nephtys
I did a little research a while back online, and most people seem to back up nVidia's 6X00 line more than Radeon's X300-600-800 series.

Posted: 2005-07-06 11:59am
by Praxis
Check Tomshardware, the 6200 outperforms the X300 in practically every benchmark and even outperforms the X600 Pro in the ones I looked at.

Posted: 2005-07-06 12:10pm
by Ace Pace
Nephtys wrote:I did a little research a while back online, and most people seem to back up nVidia's 6X00 line more than Radeon's X300-600-800 series.
Because on the lower end it sucks(6200>X300, 6600GT>>X700), while higher end you have SLI, SM3(purty).

Posted: 2005-07-06 12:35pm
by The Grim Squeaker
Isnt ATI releasing it's own version of SLI (Crossfire) that will be compatible with any two cards?

On the mid-high range Ati cards are good also, especially when you get to high end power supplies (Geoforce's cards arent as bad today as with the older cards, but still not as good as ATI's)

Posted: 2005-07-06 12:44pm
by Tiger Ace
the .303 bookworm wrote:Isnt ATI releasing it's own version of SLI (Crossfire) that will be compatible with any two cards?

On the mid-high range Ati cards are good also, especially when you get to high end power supplies (Geoforce's cards arent as bad today as with the older cards, but still not as good as ATI's)
Ah..so many problems.

ATi has its own version of SLI, called Crossfire, which has 1 main problem: Currently it requires a master card(to take the current gen as an example), either of the X800 or the X850 varaiety, from THAT connect to any card card in that line.

The problem is the master card(retailers don't want another card to confuse buyers), and the Crossfire system itself, not giving the best of benchs compared to SLI.

Second, midrange(200$ price), ATi losses. you cannot twist 6600GT>X700 in any way.
300-400$, if you find an X800XL at a good price, it might beat out the 6800GT, however you do lose SM3, and with that, future power.

High end, most people think for the price an X850 will cost, its better to get a pair of something.

Another problem with ATi is the 7800GTX, which is totally kicking ass with its great aviability, while ATi's next gen card(R520), is apprently having yield problems.