Page 1 of 1
Prostitutes call for ban on GTA
Posted: 2006-02-15 07:13pm
by Dominus Atheos
Gamespot wrote:Sex workers cry foul, say game "accrues points to players for the depiction of rape and murder of prostitutes."
The Grand Theft Auto franchise is getting attacked from all angles. Joining the ranks of politicians, policemen, and attorneys in their crusade to see the game lifted from shelves are the nation's sex workers. On its Web site, the Sex Workers Outreach Project USA is asking parents to assist them in calling for a ban of Take-Two Interactive's controversial game.
Citing a 2001 document from the National Institute on Media and the Family's David Walsh, SWOP is calling "on all parents and all gamers to boycott Grand Theft Auto."
The organization quotes various points from Walsh's paper, including, "Children are more likely to imitate a character with whom they identify with. In violent video games the player is often required to take the point of view of the shooter or perpetrator."
Though the organization admits to being "adamantly opposed to any and all forms of censorship," as concerned parents themselves, they "wish to inform other parents of the potential danger extremely violent video games pose to children." Likewise, in the interest of promoting the rights of sex workers, the organization is opposed to the depiction of the rape and murder of prostitutes.
In the games, players can solicit "services" from prostitutes by driving their cars slowly near them. No sexual acts are in clear visible view, but during the "transaction," the player regains health and loses money. Though the player cannot actively rape prostitutes in the game, a possible rape is alluded to once during the storyline of Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas. The prostitutes, like every other character, are also subject to homicide at the hands of the protagonist.
According to its Web site, SWOP USA is an organization dedicated to improving the lives of sex-industry workers and to the promotion of a safe working environment for the industry.
I don't know whether to laugh, make fun of, or just gape.
Whores wrote:Sex workers cry foul, say game "accrues points to players for the depiction of rape and murder of prostitutes."
You can't rape anyone in these games, and the game doesn't reward you for murdering prostitutes any more than it rewards you for killing anyone else.
Hookers wrote:Though the organization admits to being "adamantly opposed to any and all forms of censorship," as concerned parents themselves, they "wish to inform other parents of the potential danger extremely violent video games pose to children."
That is just wrong on so many levels.
Posted: 2006-02-15 07:20pm
by Spice Runner
This stems from that silly notion that some people hold about video games influencing people's actions in real life. I don't know how that point system works in GTA, but I'm sure it doesn't encourage people to go out and murder prostitutes. These sex workers should parroting those anti-video game loons since they look like idiots.
Posted: 2006-02-15 07:21pm
by Darth Quorthon
Shoot, you beat me to it. Guess I took too long writing out the post.
Posted: 2006-02-15 07:26pm
by Dominus Atheos
Darth Quorthon wrote:Shoot, you beat me to it. Guess I took too long writing out the post.
I posted almost 10 minutes before you, there is no way it takes you that long to write out "Sorry if this is old news"
Posted: 2006-02-15 08:47pm
by AK_Jedi
Wait... sex workers are trying to get parents to help them ban the game? good luck.
Posted: 2006-02-15 10:29pm
by LongVin
But you pay the prostitutes for their services in the game...Of course you can run them over afterwards and take the money back.
Posted: 2006-02-15 11:03pm
by brianeyci
I wonder why they don't go after television. It's arguably more brainwashing/destructive, since it's passive and you don't have a choice.
If anything games give a stress relief outlet. I know someone who plays WoW probaby 8 hours a day and she's on her way to an accelerated masters degree.
Brian
Posted: 2006-02-16 09:51am
by Molyneux
Spice Runner wrote:This stems from that silly notion that some people hold about video games influencing people's actions in real life. I don't know how that point system works in GTA, but I'm sure it doesn't encourage people to go out and murder prostitutes. These sex workers should parroting those anti-video game loons since they look like idiots.
There *is* no points system in GTA; the closest thing is a money counter, and you don't get any more money for killing prostitutes in that game than you do for killing anyone else.
Actually, one of the best ways to get some cash in that game is to kill *pimps*.
Posted: 2006-02-16 09:58am
by WyrdNyrd
I think we can all agrre by now that none of the people criticising GTA actually know a thing about the game itself, just misinformation that they've heard 3rd ot 4th hand.
But hey, why spoil a good outrage with facts?
Posted: 2006-02-16 10:48am
by Jadeite
Molyneux wrote:
There *is* no points system in GTA; the closest thing is a money counter, and you don't get any more money for killing prostitutes in that game than you do for killing anyone else.
Actually, one of the best ways to get some cash in that game is to kill *pimps*.
Yes there is, its in your profile with your criminal rating.
Re: Prostitutes call for ban on GTA
Posted: 2006-02-16 01:10pm
by Admiral Valdemar
Hookers wrote:Though the organization admits to being "adamantly opposed to any and all forms of censorship," as concerned parents themselves, they "wish to inform other parents of the potential danger extremely violent video games pose to children."
I'll say. I almost got a paper cut off the GTA:VC box at one point. That would've ruin my day.
Posted: 2006-02-16 08:16pm
by Spice Runner
Molyneux wrote:
There *is* no points system in GTA; the closest thing is a money counter, and you don't get any more money for killing prostitutes in that game than you do for killing anyone else.
Actually, one of the best ways to get some cash in that game is to kill *pimps*.
Sounds fun. I don't know too much about the game itself. Unfortunately I've never really had the time to play it.