"Obi Wan Once Felt as you did..."

PSW: discuss Star Wars without "versus" arguments.

Moderator: Vympel

Post Reply
User avatar
Stravo
Official SD.Net Teller of Tales
Posts: 12806
Joined: 2002-07-08 12:06pm
Location: NYC

"Obi Wan Once Felt as you did..."

Post by Stravo »

No he didn't.

We all remember the scene in ROTJ when Luke impores to hsi father "Come with me." Vader's response was "Obi Wan once felt as you did." Except we all know from events on Mustafar that Obi Wan most certainly did NOT ask Vader to come with him nor in fact even offered Anakin a choice in returning to the light. Obi Wan showed up to kill Anakin and Anakin knew it.

In fact it was Anakin who seemed to be begging off the upcoming fight by asking Obi Wan not to force him to kill him. Obi Wan was indeed 'lecturing' to Anakin even then at the end instead of trying to talk to him.

We do know that Padme was the one who said "Come with me." and considering what Luke represented in the OT that is a far more touching connection and call back that a young man who had no memories of his mother and spent his whole life searching for and idolizing his father actually took on the mother role in that confrontation on Endor.

But Vader instead sees a connection to Obi Wan which IMHO makes no sense. Unless either Vader has romantacized that confrontation much as Obi Wan embelished the fall of Anakin and rise of Darth Vader for Luke. Perhaps Vader felt regret about what happened with Obi Wan and imparts that into Luke.

But even that makes little sense when one considers that the sole reason Anakin fell - willingly- was Padme. It was all about Padme in PT yet she rates not even a mention in the OT in particular a scene that is a direct call back to her imporing him on Mustfar to come away with her.

Thoughts on this weird comment by Vader?
Wherever you go, there you are.

Ripped Shirt Monkey - BOTMWriter's Guild Cybertron's Finest Justice League
This updated sig brought to you by JME2
Image
User avatar
Lord Revan
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 12238
Joined: 2004-05-20 02:23pm
Location: Zone:classified

Post by Lord Revan »

it's rather simple Luke at this point knows nothing (for all intents and purposes) about his mother, so the name Padme means nothing to Luke and Vader/Anakin knows this so Vader uses the Obi-wan in instead of Padme to drive his point across (that that Vader is loyal to the Sith and the Dark Side).
I may be an idiot, but I'm a tolerated idiot
"I think you completely missed the point of sigs. They're supposed to be completely homegrown in the fertile hydroponics lab of your mind, dried in your closet, rolled, and smoked...
Oh wait, that's marijuana..."Einhander Sn0m4n
User avatar
Tychu
Jedi Master
Posts: 1260
Joined: 2002-07-28 01:20am
Location: Deer Park, Long Island, New York
Contact:

Post by Tychu »

Obi Wan did not go to Mustafar to kill Anakin. Your forgetting the whole scene when Obi walks down the ramp when Anakin is killing Padme. For a person who is trying to kill Anakin he is stalling quite a bit. Obi Wan was offering or trying to bring Anakin to see the errors in his ways. Only when Anakin reveals that he dosent care about the Jedi and Obi Wan is when Obi pulls out his saber. Remember he was hesitant to take on the mission given by Yoda to him in the first place
"Boring Conversation anyway" Han Solo

"What kinda archeologist carries a weapon........Bad Example" Colonel Jack O'Neil

"My name is Olo... Hans Olo" -Dr. Daniel Jackson

"Well you did make the Farmingdale Run in less than 12 parsecs" --Personal Quote

"Just popped out for lunch" - Rowan Atkinson as Mr. Bean
User avatar
Stravo
Official SD.Net Teller of Tales
Posts: 12806
Joined: 2002-07-08 12:06pm
Location: NYC

Post by Stravo »

Tychu wrote:Obi Wan did not go to Mustafar to kill Anakin. Your forgetting the whole scene when Obi walks down the ramp when Anakin is killing Padme. For a person who is trying to kill Anakin he is stalling quite a bit. Obi Wan was offering or trying to bring Anakin to see the errors in his ways. Only when Anakin reveals that he dosent care about the Jedi and Obi Wan is when Obi pulls out his saber. Remember he was hesitant to take on the mission given by Yoda to him in the first place
I always read it as Obi Wan was hesitant to be assigned but when it was time to go he was ready to kill him. Remember Padme could see it right away.

"You're going to kill him."

"He has become a very great threat."

Obi Wan was ready to kill him the moment he stepped off that ramp. Yes he was stalling but you cannot compare his "You've become all you've tried to destroy." to "Come away with me. Leave this all behind and help me raise our baby."

Luke's intent on Endor clearly mirrored Padme's and NOT Obi Wan's attitiude on Mustafar. And in response to the rather interesting take that Luke wouldn't know Padme if Vader said "Your mother felt the same way." I think it would have some emotional impact on Luke. But I agree that Luke obviously had a deeper bond with Obi Wan than anyone else even a vague mother figure.
Wherever you go, there you are.

Ripped Shirt Monkey - BOTMWriter's Guild Cybertron's Finest Justice League
This updated sig brought to you by JME2
Image
User avatar
Ghost Rider
Spirit of Vengeance
Posts: 27779
Joined: 2002-09-24 01:48pm
Location: DC...looking up from the gutters to the stars

Post by Ghost Rider »

Actually to take Stravo's a step further...especially since this is Anakin's viewpoint.

HE percieved Obi-Wan a threat the instant he saw him. He didn't do anything to Padme until he saw a threat and then jumped the gun.

In Anakin's mind Obi Wan was there to kill him. Luke wasn't. Personally I see it a bit of Lucas not knowing what the past was, and really we should chalk it up to Vader manipulating rather then reaccounting his thoughts at the time.
MM /CF/WG/BOTM/JL/Original Warsie/ACPATHNTDWATGODW FOREVER!!

Sometimes we can choose the path we follow. Sometimes our choices are made for us. And sometimes we have no choice at all

Saying and doing are chocolate and concrete
User avatar
Tychu
Jedi Master
Posts: 1260
Joined: 2002-07-28 01:20am
Location: Deer Park, Long Island, New York
Contact:

Post by Tychu »

Stravo wrote:
Tychu wrote:Obi Wan did not go to Mustafar to kill Anakin. Your forgetting the whole scene when Obi walks down the ramp when Anakin is killing Padme. For a person who is trying to kill Anakin he is stalling quite a bit. Obi Wan was offering or trying to bring Anakin to see the errors in his ways. Only when Anakin reveals that he dosent care about the Jedi and Obi Wan is when Obi pulls out his saber. Remember he was hesitant to take on the mission given by Yoda to him in the first place
I always read it as Obi Wan was hesitant to be assigned but when it was time to go he was ready to kill him. Remember Padme could see it right away.

"You're going to kill him."

"He has become a very great threat."

Obi Wan was ready to kill him the moment he stepped off that ramp. Yes he was stalling but you cannot compare his "You've become all you've tried to destroy." to "Come away with me. Leave this all behind and help me raise our baby."
i see where your coming from. I think though that Obi-Wan is facing a dilema. He knows he's going to have to kill Anakin. But theres a diffrence in knowing something and wanting to do something. He went to Mustafar because he knew he had to Kill Anakin, but he didnt go to Mustafar because he wanted to Kill Anakin. When Obi-Wan declared Anakin a Sith he knew he was going to kill Anakin
"Boring Conversation anyway" Han Solo

"What kinda archeologist carries a weapon........Bad Example" Colonel Jack O'Neil

"My name is Olo... Hans Olo" -Dr. Daniel Jackson

"Well you did make the Farmingdale Run in less than 12 parsecs" --Personal Quote

"Just popped out for lunch" - Rowan Atkinson as Mr. Bean
User avatar
VT-16
Sith Marauder
Posts: 4662
Joined: 2004-05-13 10:01am
Location: Norway

Post by VT-16 »

Hell, even towards the end of the fight, he was still willing to talk to the guy, rather than just hack and slash away.

Then there's the "high-ground" quote, of course.
User avatar
Isolder74
Official SD.Net Ace of Cakes
Posts: 6762
Joined: 2002-07-10 01:16am
Location: Weber State of Construction University
Contact:

Post by Isolder74 »

Well its possible that Obi Wan had hoped all along that Padme might be able to wake him up to what he is becoming and only appeared once he begin to feel that Anakin was getting out of control.

All througout the fight Obi Wan seemed to try again and again to find his friend in the person he was fighting even to the end.

He even tried to make Anakin see what he has become. But to no avail. The fight ended with Obi Wan defeating Anakin but not killing him outright(don't tell me he couldn't have just cut him in half). Perhaps there is more to that than we really actually saw.
Hapan Battle Dragons Rule!
When you want peace prepare for war! --Confusious
That was disapointing ..Should we show this Federation how to build a ship so we may have worthy foes? Typhonis 1
The Prince of The Writer's Guild|HAB Spacewolf Tank General| God Bless America!
User avatar
Stravo
Official SD.Net Teller of Tales
Posts: 12806
Joined: 2002-07-08 12:06pm
Location: NYC

Post by Stravo »

The heart of the observation is not whether Obi Wan never tried to talk to Anakin or was just out to kill him but whose sentiments better fit Luke's intent on Endor - Padme's or Obi Wan's. I posit that clearly Padme's interaction with Anankin on Mustafar is a far more perfect fit to Luke on Endor than Obi Wan's.
Wherever you go, there you are.

Ripped Shirt Monkey - BOTMWriter's Guild Cybertron's Finest Justice League
This updated sig brought to you by JME2
Image
User avatar
Darth Wong
Sith Lord
Sith Lord
Posts: 70028
Joined: 2002-07-03 12:25am
Location: Toronto, Canada
Contact:

Post by Darth Wong »

Luke expects to die along with Vader and the Emperor if he can't convert Vader, because of the impending Rebel attack. It's not so much different from Obi-Wan's intent as it might seem. If Obi-Wan had no intention of trying to convert Anakin, he wouldn't have bothered arguing with him about the righteousness of his cause.
Image
"It's not evil for God to do it. Or for someone to do it at God's command."- Jonathan Boyd on baby-killing

"you guys are fascinated with the use of those "rules of logic" to the extent that you don't really want to discussus anything."- GC

"I do not believe Russian Roulette is a stupid act" - Embracer of Darkness

"Viagra commercials appear to save lives" - tharkûn on US health care.

http://www.stardestroyer.net/Mike/RantMode/Blurbs.html
User avatar
Civil War Man
NERRRRRDS!!!
Posts: 3790
Joined: 2005-01-28 03:54am

Post by Civil War Man »

This is fairly half-assed reasoning, but keep in mind that the subject of Padme would still be extremely painful to Vader. If he said, "Your mother felt the same way," they might enter some line of conversation about her, and it would be hard to keep them from eventually arriving on the fact that Vader was directly responsible for her death. I doubt Anakin would want to dwell on that memory, nor would he want to reveal it to his son and even further alienate the last known remnants of his family.
User avatar
Solauren
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 10406
Joined: 2003-05-11 09:41pm

Post by Solauren »

"Anakin, Chancellor Palpatine is evil"
"From my point of view, the Jedi are evil"
"THEN YOU ARE LOST"

Combined with his talk with Anakin at first, it's pretty obvious Obiwan had hoped to not have to kill him.
However, Anakin never had proof of that, and might have been infuring.

Also, we have no idea if that had a discussion on board the Death Star. It's possible Obiwan did say 'look, there good in you, come back with me"
User avatar
Vympel
Spetsnaz
Spetsnaz
Posts: 29312
Joined: 2002-07-19 01:08am
Location: Sydney Australia

Post by Vympel »

There's no evidence of a conversation on the Death Star- the novel didn't mention it, that's for sure. By that time, Obi-Wan had already convinced himself. Notice how he calls Anakin "Darth".

Anyway, I think Vader inferring that Obi-Wan once thought as Luke did from their few words exchanged on Mustafar is weaker than Vader saying "your mother ... once thought as you do."

I think that was one of the great lost opportunities. It probably would've brought up too many unanswered questions, and Luke's reaction would need to be different.
Like Legend of Galactic Heroes? Please contribute to http://gineipaedia.com/
User avatar
Straha
Lord of the Spam
Posts: 8198
Joined: 2002-07-21 11:59pm
Location: NYC

Post by Straha »

I think Obi-Wan went to Mustafar hoping Anakin, his dear friend and someone who he viewed like a son, would repent and come back. He delays fighting Anakin, he tries to talk to Anakin the entire time to see if the possibility of repentance is possible, and he doesn't kill Anakin, all this seems, to me at least, to mean that Vader knew, through force empathy or later reflection, that Obi-Wan wanted to go back to Yoda with Anakin at his side, and didn't actually want to kill Anakin as he was supposed to.
'After 9/11, it was "You're with us or your with the terrorists." Now its "You're with Straha or you support racism."' ' - The Romulan Republic

'You're a bully putting on an air of civility while saying that everything western and/or capitalistic must be bad, and a lot of other posters (loomer, Stas Bush, Gandalf) are also going along with it for their own personal reasons (Stas in particular is looking through rose colored glasses)' - Darth Yan
User avatar
Hotfoot
Avatar of Confusion
Posts: 5835
Joined: 2002-10-12 04:38pm
Location: Peace River: Badlands, Terra Nova Winter 1936
Contact:

Post by Hotfoot »

Vympel wrote:There's no evidence of a conversation on the Death Star- the novel didn't mention it, that's for sure. By that time, Obi-Wan had already convinced himself. Notice how he calls Anakin "Darth".

Anyway, I think Vader inferring that Obi-Wan once thought as Luke did from their few words exchanged on Mustafar is weaker than Vader saying "your mother ... once thought as you do."

I think that was one of the great lost opportunities. It probably would've brought up too many unanswered questions, and Luke's reaction would need to be different.
It would also be a terrific tie-in to the conversation Luke has with Leia on Endor about her parents.

Or at least it could have been.
Do not meddle in the affairs of insomniacs, for they are cranky and can do things to you while you sleep.
Image
The Realm of Confusion
"Every time you talk about Teal'c, I keep imagining Thor's ass. Thank you very much for that, you fucking fucker." -Marcao
SG-14: Because in some cases, "Recon" means "Blow up a fucking planet or die trying."
SilCore Wiki! Come take a look!
FTeik
Jedi Council Member
Posts: 2035
Joined: 2002-07-16 04:12pm

Post by FTeik »

Solauren wrote:"Anakin, Chancellor Palpatine is evil"
"From my point of view, the Jedi are evil"
"THEN YOU ARE LOST"
"Come with me father."
"I have to obey my master"
"Then my father is truly dead."
User avatar
Faqa
Jedi Master
Posts: 1340
Joined: 2004-06-02 09:32am
Contact:

Post by Faqa »

Maybe Luke's appeal, in it's unconcious parallel to that day on Mustafar nearly twenty years ago, threw Vader off? Majorly?

He may have thrown that response out to cover his OWN turmoil and emotion here.

Or maybe, to take another perspective, Vader's blocked Padme out by this point? He killed her, from his POV. He's had a long time to cope with that. Maybe his coping was utter, perfect repression? To the point where he barely remembered her?

I agree, in-universe, that connecting Luke to Padme makes more sense than to Obi.
"Peace on Earth and goodwill towards men? We are the United States Goverment - we don't DO that sort of thing!" - Sneakers. Best. Quote. EVER.

Periodic Pwnage Pantry:

"Faith? Isn't that another term for ignorance?" - Gregory House

"Isn't it interesting... religious behaviour is so close to being crazy that we can't tell them apart?" - Gregory House

"This is usually the part where people start screaming." - Gabriel Sylar
User avatar
Patrick Degan
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 14847
Joined: 2002-07-15 08:06am
Location: Orleanian in exile

Post by Patrick Degan »

"You were my brother, Anakin! I LOVED you!"
When ballots have fairly and constitutionally decided, there can be no successful appeal back to bullets.
—Abraham Lincoln

People pray so that God won't crush them like bugs.
—Dr. Gregory House

Oil an emergency?! It's about time, Brigadier, that the leaders of this planet of yours realised that to remain dependent upon a mineral slime simply doesn't make sense.
—The Doctor "Terror Of The Zygons" (1975)
User avatar
Coyote
Rabid Monkey
Posts: 12464
Joined: 2002-08-23 01:20am
Location: The glorious Sun-Barge! Isis, Isis, Ra,Ra,Ra!
Contact:

Post by Coyote »

Vympel wrote:There's no evidence of a conversation on the Death Star- the novel didn't mention it, that's for sure. By that time, Obi-Wan had already convinced himself. Notice how he calls Anakin "Darth".
Obi-Wan was oddly exact and proper about people's titles. I noticed watching RoTS again that no sooner had he learned about Chancellor Palpatine declaring the First Galactic Empire that he immediately began referring to him as 'the Emperor'...
Something about Libertarianism always bothered me. Then one day, I realized what it was:
Libertarian philosophy can be boiled down to the phrase, "Work Will Make You Free."


In Libertarianism, there is no Government, so the Bosses are free to exploit the Workers.
In Communism, there is no Government, so the Workers are free to exploit the Bosses.
So in Libertarianism, man exploits man, but in Communism, its the other way around!

If all you want to do is have some harmless, mindless fun, go H3RE INST3ADZ0RZ!!
Grrr! Fight my Brute, you pansy!
Post Reply