Glancing across the list of thread topics I see plenty of whimsical theories.And Kurgan, for the love of God; shut up. This topic doesn't belong on the PSW board, because the PSW board is not for debating purely whimsical theories. Nobody wants to debate whether or not Plagueis was re-incarnated as Palpatine's ex-girlfriend because there's just too little evidence to hold any form of meaningful discussion on the subject. Stop pushing your luck.
I think what I proposed is possible within the framework of demonstrated Sith powers in the EU. That doesn't mean it happened in canon, but that's not the issue. Many hypotheticals are "what would happen" and then it's up to the imagination of the posters. If "nobody" wants to discuss it, that's up to the people reading, not one or two folks who think it's stupid.
If it's being a "back-seat moderator" to tell people not to troll a thread, then it would see the same is true of people who troll a thread to say that it's stupid and they need to shut up. I don't see the big deal. This topic wasn't meant as a spam, but it's genuine speculation about a purely SW topic.
If anyone would rather blow off steam trolling this thread in the hopes it would die because they don't like the idea, who am I to stop them?