Clone Troopers in Episode 3(Possible Spoilers!)

[YT300000]

Most of the CGI work with the Clonetroopers was absolutely awesome, but some of it was just terrible. There are some close-up scenes that are blatantly fake, and a scene where Obi-Wan and Lama Su are looking over a regiment of clonetroopers that is obviously fake. There is nothing wrong with using low tech (i.e. dudes in clonetrooper armor) when necessary; Peter Jackson isn't afraid to use low tech, and he does so with great success. Obviously the CGI is going to be absolutely necessary for many of the scenes, but I think real actors would have been better for a select few of them.

There's no reason why Obi vs Jango needed CGI at all. Instead of a doll that looks like it's made with Play Doh, we'd should have invisible wires.

But, the battle looked entirely real.