1.Oh really? First of all that wasnt a transmission, it was a recording made by R2, we are talking about holographic communication between objects in space here and that requires the hyperwaves.vakundok wrote:1: I remember a holographic message that Leia sent to Kenobi in ANH ...Rightous Fist Of Heaven wrote:Uhm if hyperwaves are needed in order to send holographich transmissions to carry the data, then i do not see what is the point in this.vakundok wrote:Noone doubted this. The question is, whether holographic communication can only happen through holonet.
1. We saw that holographic messages can be recorded and stored indicating that holographic messages are only data.
2. Normal communication (which is also a data exchange) can happen through shields.
3. We saw shipboard holographic communication. In my opinion it is unlikely that holonet was used in that occassion.
Back to topic:
It is hard to see the result of the explosion, but it seems the structure behind the tower remained intact, but the left dome disappeared. On the frame when the explosion began a black thing appeared. I think it was the hole in the hull. It can indicate that there was no shield interaction but we did not see the surface of the collision so it is unconfirmed. I think without confirmation it canot be decided whether the shield were down or overloaded.
1.Where? And so what? Since hyperwaves are needed to carry the holographic signal for whatever reason, this is irrelevant.
2.Where? An example if you dont mind.
3.No shit sherlock if the signal is going thru the internal cables and such of the ship there would be no need for a carrier wave for the data stream.
2: Please?Ackbar and Lando communicated, during the Battle of Endor, didn't they?
3: You wrote: "hyperwaves are needed" and later "thru the internal cables", the latter means that hyperwaves do not needed, just a possible channel for the data exchange.
2.Oh sorry forgot about that one.Well since regular comms arent the same thing as holographic comms and they dont use holonet this is irrelevant to the matter at hand.
3.Oh for fucks sake, offcourse hyperwaves are not needed to carry the fucking signal internally where there are physical lines or cables transferring the data, but thru the void of space where there neither of these exist they must use a carrier wave aka hyperwaves in order to carry the data at speeds faster than light.
What the fuck really? Do you have some problem comprehending that there really is a difference between communicating with cables and such transferring the data than communicating thru space with the datastream remaining intact and going at sufficient velocity to avoid timelag in the transmissions.
