Page 1 of 1
Attack of the Amatures: Anakin vs Luke
Posted: 2003-02-07 12:11am
by BlkbrryTheGreat
Anakin from AOTC vs Luke (end of ESB/ROTJ)
IMO
Anakin in AOTC didn't demonstrate anywhere close to the aptitude that Obi-Wan and Qui-gon did in TPM, or Yoda did in AOTC. But then again, Luke wasn't exactly hot stuff compared to them, even when he did become a Jedi.
Posted: 2003-02-07 12:40am
by Brother-Captain Gaius
I'd give it to luke. He had better control over his emotions and was more dosciplined as well.
Posted: 2003-02-07 10:58am
by Lord Pounder
This thread has already been done.
Posted: 2003-02-07 11:13am
by Bartman
Anakin had several years of training by this time, as opposed to the few months of rushed training Luke recieved. I can't think of anything that Anakin did that Luke would have done better.
Posted: 2003-02-07 05:18pm
by Slartibartfast
Anakin is all fancy-schmancy with his moves. He is also whinier and much more hot headed.
"Obi Wan hates me weeoweeowee!"
"I just massacred a whole village weeoweeowee!"
And that is AFTER he has received a lot of training.
Posted: 2003-02-08 12:04am
by Darth Servo
I vote Luke.
BTW, shouldn't this be in Pure Star Wars?
Posted: 2003-02-08 12:06am
by DPDarkPrimus
Luke at least shut up and listened to his instructor after he was apprenticed.
Posted: 2003-02-08 12:09am
by Solid Snake
Slartibartfast wrote:Anakin is all fancy-schmancy with his moves. He is also whinier and much more hot headed.
"Obi Wan hates me weeoweeowee!"
"I just massacred a whole village weeoweeowee!"
And that is AFTER he has received a lot of training.
Kung Pow is the fucking greatest. LMAO
Posted: 2003-02-08 12:20am
by Joe
Anakin. Has the edge in training, and may be a little more talented naturally.
However, I think uber-Luke from the EU could deal with Anakin.
Posted: 2003-02-08 03:27am
by Slartibartfast
SolidSnake wrote:Slartibartfast wrote:Anakin is all fancy-schmancy with his moves. He is also whinier and much more hot headed.
"Obi Wan hates me weeoweeowee!"
"I just massacred a whole village weeoweeowee!"
And that is AFTER he has received a lot of training.
Kung Pow is the fucking greatest. LMAO
Hahahaha, can't believe you got that
Yeah, Anakin is a lot like that whiney biatch.
Posted: 2003-02-08 02:38pm
by NecronLord
Er doesn't RotJ luke kick the shit out of vader, who is anakin + some more training and the power of the dark side?
Luke
Posted: 2003-02-08 02:45pm
by Stormbringer
Darth Servo wrote:I vote Luke.
BTW, shouldn't this be in Pure Star Wars?
Yes, it should and shall be.
Posted: 2003-02-08 05:20pm
by Darth Phoenix
Voted for Luke beacuse Luke had better control of his emotion and would not open itself for the enemy like Anakin did trought out EP2
Posted: 2003-02-08 05:54pm
by Admiral Drason
Anakin lasted 10 seconds against a Sith Lord.
Luke lasted 10 minutes against a Sith Lord.
Luke wins hands down.
Posted: 2003-02-08 06:03pm
by Mr Bean
Er doesn't RotJ luke kick the shit out of vader, who is anakin + some more training and the power of the dark side?
Don't forget how little of Anakin is left in Vadar, he's mostly machine and stupieded machine at that
Posted: 2003-02-08 11:26pm
by Kuja
Admiral Drason wrote:Anakin lasted 10 seconds against a Sith Lord.
Luke lasted 10 minutes against a Sith Lord.
Luke wins hands down.
How about this:
Anakin got zapped by lightning once and was down for several minutes.
Luke was zapped over and over and got up almost immediately.
Luke.
Posted: 2003-02-09 02:15pm
by Lord_Xerxes
All Anakin would have to do is point out how he is Luke's father again, and Luke would be reduced to tears once more.
Or perhaps he could describe how much of a hot piece of ass Luke's mother was.
Luke: "So that's where that smell on the end of my lightsaber came from..."