Page 1 of 1
Star Wars Scaling (again)
Posted: 2009-12-20 06:31pm
by Kurgan
I found this thread over at OT.com (not advertising, mind you) and wondered if
anyone here wanted to contribute their wisdom to it:
http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic. ... pic/10969/
When it comes down to it, the scales of vehicles are really inconsistent between movies, even between shots.
Re: Star Wars Scaling (again)
Posted: 2009-12-20 07:02pm
by VT-16
Part of the mistakes are confusing the three ESB/ROTJ command bridges, though. The one from the MF flyby in ROTJ is different from the Executor and ISD-II ones from those films. It's more likely the film crew made a separate detailed bridge for another ship than the Executor (which already has one for the shuttle flyby scene).
Re: Star Wars Scaling (again)
Posted: 2009-12-21 02:05pm
by Darth Yan
I don't really inderstand what they are saying.
Re: Star Wars Scaling (again)
Posted: 2009-12-22 05:57am
by The_Saint
There's more finger pointing going on than there ever has been here or Spacebattles...
The alarm bells ring when it's (to paraphrase) "we can't use the numbers in the Technical Commentaries because we simply just don't trust the tf.n types"...
Re: Star Wars Scaling (again)
Posted: 2009-12-22 08:00am
by Darth Yan
a part of me wonders if this guy is making shit up.
Re: Star Wars Scaling (again)
Posted: 2009-12-22 12:40pm
by Kurgan
The_Saint wrote:There's more finger pointing going on than there ever has been here or Spacebattles...
The alarm bells ring when it's (to paraphrase) "we can't use the numbers in the Technical Commentaries because we simply just don't trust the tf.n types"...
Yeah, but those tf.n types really can't be trusted...
