StarDestroyer.Net BBS

I thought about the trash compactors on the Death Star, and realized, that I don't know if they make sense. I mean, I have read that trash is compacted for shooting it out into space (as done in normal normal Star Destroyers). The problem is, that all ships bigger as a Star Destroyer (including the Executor and of course the Death Star) got a, or in the case of the Death Star, several, recycling plant(s).
So why do they still compact thier trash, when they not shoot it out (the compactor was deep within the station and shooting trash out seems impossible with such a large ship) and recycle it instead?

Compacted Trash takes less space to store!


Duh!

Maybe compacting it is a prerequisite for recycling. Or they seperate the recycleable materials out and compact the rest.

**Complete speculation mode on

Perhaps, "just because" -- that is, since it's possible a lot of the Death Star's construction used modules or units that (internally at least) are the same or similar to other large capital ships, the trash compactors were included in the design even though she didn't need them. Another possibility is the Imperial Navy wanted them included because the other ships in the fleet have them, and by god, this battle station is gonna have them!

(RW example: Sea Shadow, stealth ship built by Lockheed for the USN as stealth demonstrator, was required to have a paint locker. Why? - because BuShip inspectors demanded it have one, since every ship in the navy has a paint locker.... )

i'd be more interested in why the death star had a tentacle monster lurking in its trash compactor than the trash compactor itself.

Darth_Zod wrote:i'd be more interested in why the death star had a tentacle monster lurking in its trash compactor than the trash compactor itself.

Probably an old pet of Tarkin's...

StarshipTitanic wrote:

Darth_Zod wrote:i'd be more interested in why the death star had a tentacle monster lurking in its trash compactor than the trash compactor itself.

Probably an old pet of Tarkin's...

they must use the toilet to get rid of dying pets the same way we do then.

Darth_Zod wrote:i'd be more interested in why the death star had a tentacle monster lurking in its trash compactor than the trash compactor itself.

Came from contaminated water or brought in with some supplies. or it was on board a supply ship and escaped. Dianogas are alot like rats they have t heir ways of getting around into places like that

Darth_Zod wrote:i'd be more interested in why the death star had a tentacle monster lurking in its trash compactor than the trash compactor itself.

We may be able to tie it in with the function of the trash compactor. The tentacle monster could be there because it feeds on organic matter that is on the trash, so it cleans it before they compact it for recycling.

Hows does the dianoga (tentacle monster) survive the squishing process though?

Crazedwraith wrote:Hows does the dianoga (tentacle monster) survive the squishing process though?

it disappears... if the film is anything to go by...

Crazedwraith wrote:Hows does the dianoga (tentacle monster) survive the squishing process though?

It does not have bones. also it appeared to dissapear somewhere when it realized the compactor sequence was begining. It went somewhere before the walls started closing in.

And I thought the compactor was a closed of system, were nothing could get out.....

Oh, by the way, I think that this wasn't only water. Since the compactor is linked to the recycling system. Yuck. Luke took a bath in a mix of water and piss, because I bet that the toilets eject thier stuff into the compactors for recycling also....(otherwise I cound't imagine from where this water cames from.)
Nice to know that Luke bathed in the toilet water of guys like TK-241.......

Crazedwraith wrote:Hows does the dianoga (tentacle monster) survive the squishing process though?

Probably thought the doggy door at the bottom of the compactor back to it's dianoga house.

Darth_Zod wrote:i'd be more interested in why the death star had a tentacle monster lurking in its trash compactor than the trash compactor itself.

Perhaps the dianoga is used as part of the waste disposal system in a fashion similar to worms being used in bio composts.