Kitsune wrote:This does not include the Eclipse and Sovereign classes but Vader's Flagship.
This discussion is also mostly based on the Novels I have read, other Novels may cotriduct me.
Based on the fight of Isard's flagship in the X-Wing Novels, I think that the SSD is badly overrated. It was almost overmatched in combat by a single Star Destroyer and seemed to be definately overmatched when it was attacked by two of them.
The Executor's shields survived the simultaneous impact of a trio of Star Destroyers dropping directly out of hyperspace into them (IE, relatavistically traveling.) Sorry, try again.
The defeat of the Lusankya in The BActa War is vastly overrated. It hinged on the fact that:
A.) Wedge acquired eighty-some freighters that he equipped with capital scale warhead launchers acquired through Talon Karrde (Wayne Poe has pointed this out numerous times before.)
B.) The freighters targeting systems were coordinated through individual Rogue targeting computers (or in other words, they fired at the same moment as the X-wing their targeting was slaved to, allowing for the tactic of simultaneous detonations on a single point - which seems to improve the ability of overpowering shields.)
C.) The X-wings pulled their usual tactic of skimming close to the ship, (point blank range) - making it difficult if not impossible for the Lusankya's fighter defenses to shoot down either the fighters or their torpedoes (this has been demonstrated numerous times in canon, particularily TESB with the Falcon and ROTJ.)
Same applies with the Freedom (it was close to the ship and directly above it - not a good position to bring many guns to bear.) - This is also partly an example of Drysso's stupidity, since he did nothing to alter his position to bring more guns to bear. The Valiant was directly to the rear, battering the engines (the engines would complicate targeting - both because they represent a sensor blind spot as well as the fire arcs of the guns.
D.) Drysso. Not the most competent nor collected of captains. I do not believe that based on his performance he effectively fought the Lusankya as well as he should have.
Even considering all this, it has to be noted that the Lusankya was never really *destroyed*, just damaged enough to surrender (and the ship was never really damaged badly - it was salvaged and put into use by the Rebels after all. It also can be noted that Drysso never intended to destroy, only to capture, the Freedom. Not only did this enable it to be more of an offensive threat, the Lusankya was able to still maul the ship in fairly short order when an effort was actually made (and only by ion cannons!) Again, this is more due to Drysso's incompetence than anything else.
In reality, Wedge thought and feared that it would take at
least a dozen X-wing squadrons to be able to attack the Lusankya - and he didnt even seem confident of success in that case!