StarDestroyer.Net BBS

This may sound silly, but in ROTJ, when Chewie and some Ewoks use a vine to take over an AT-ST, I'm not sure who yells the tarzan-esq cry.
I had always assumed it was Chewie sounding a bit nervous on a vine, but a friend recently declaired it was an Ewok making that sound--my question is therefore, who yelled? I'll also add in an older question of mine: Do you think Chewie was showing off his tarzan-skillz and making a confident excited war whoop, or was he actually nervous and making the equivalent of a human-on-rollercoaster noise?

EDIT: Silly poll doesn't like me, but it should be working now

One of the Ewoks had his hand in the... err... wrong place.

lol that may explain what came out... but seriously now, who made that noise?

If it wasn't for the pesky suspension of disbelief, I'd write in a silly sound editor putting in an Easter egg.

I'd say it was Chewie saying, "Stop the ride! I wanna get off! I didn't sign on for this! Where's my agent?"

I think it was Chewie.

Your friend is wrong. It was definitely Chewie, the Tarzan yell has Chewie's voice pattern.

And I like to think he was yelling "HUGGBEES!"

I'm fairly certain it was chewie.

It was Chewie, it sounds like him and everthing.

Some have criticized it for being a "cheesy homage" but that is a hollow criticism, considering the large number of homages throughout the Star Wars movies. ; )

This confusion is probably widespread, no thanks to an article trom The Unauthorized Star Wars Compendium ("50 Reasons why Jedi Sucks" which btw, is full of such fallacious attacks on the third SW film).

They claim it was an Ewok. *sigh*

It isn't a note for note copy of Tarzan's yell either, it sounds exactly how you'd expect it to sound if Chewbacca was doing his best impression.

It was to high pitched(and I was the friend in the OP) CHewie has never been seen to make such non-gutteral nazal sounds. But they are par for the course for a couple of ewoks.

When have we seen Ewoks give yells like that? Their yells are even more high pitched and nasally. More like shrieks, really.

Chewie makes all kinds of sounds, not just the stock gutteral roar. Listen to his "mum mum mum" (hard to duplicate it in text form, sorry) when he's talking to Solo after Han gets out of the carbonite.

Actually, ewoks have domonstrated that frequency. WHen the one ewok was mourning the death of its friend. It used that same tone.

Definately an Ewok.

After watching the scene again, I can't help but believe it's Chewie.

The subtitles/cc's don't say who's yelling. Oh well, believe what you want.

Edit: Here's an interview with Peter Mayhew which mentions the subject:

http://www.theforce.net/jedicouncil/int ... yhew.shtml

Son of a bitch!!

Kiss my Wookiee

An irate Wookie, but not a happy Tarzan-yelling Wookie. A very interesting interview Kurgan, thank you.

Technically since Star Wars happend a long time ago, Chiewie first did the yell, Tarzan just stole it.

"A long time ago" is not exactly a precise term. All we know for sure is that the movies take place some time before 1977, and the first Tarzan book was written in 1914. Tarzan could still have very easily pre-dated Chewbacca.

Drooling Iguana wrote:"A long time ago" is not exactly a precise term. All we know for sure is that the movies take place some time before 1977, and the first Tarzan book was written in 1914. Tarzan could still have very easily pre-dated Chewbacca.

Yeah, I'm suuure that the first Tarzan book included a recording of the Tarzan yell