Page 1 of 1

Quantifying Executor Shields

Posted: 2005-05-30 02:20pm
by BringerOfLight
Newb question I know, but has anyone ever tried quantifying the Executor's shield strength (in terms of absolute lower limit) by calculating the aggregate amount of energy released by impacts of three ISDs traveling at C (or at some speed very near C)? I think I've seen some mass numbers (posted by Ender?) on these boards some time ago if that helps.

So can anyone do the calculations?

Posted: 2005-05-30 02:27pm
by Spanky The Dolphin
I don't believe that's really very possible, but Dr. Curtis Saxton has estimated Executor's power output is in the range of about 1.3E27 Watts. That's ~1.3 octillion Watts.

And here's what Saxton has to say about Executor's shields:
Shields

The Executor's shielding defences were one of its most formidable features [according to the Williamson Classic STAR WARS comic strips]. The ship was considered virtually unassailable in the years between the battles of Yavin and Hoth. During the Battle of Endor, Admiral Ackbar realised that the mighty flagship could be defeated if his Calamarian cruisers subjected the shields to an especially concerted barrage, resulting in shield failure and exposure of sensitive structures (eg. bridge and scanner globes) to pinpoint starfighter strafing.

In the present literature there are few quantitative indications of the Executor's precise shield strength. We know that a deliberate and concentrated bombardment by somewhere between half a dozen and two dozen Mon Calamari cruisers caused shield failure within a matter of minutes. Unfortunately we can't quantify the shield capacity directly because we don't yet know the maximum output of Mon Calamari warships' guns. To total yield of Ackbar's barrage was probably the equivalent of a continual bombardment by a comparable number of Imperial star destroyers over the same time period.

This upper limit on the shield capacity is complemented by a lower limit provided by the Classic STAR WARS comics, which chronicle an accident in which Admiral Griff's three destroyers or light cruisers (of at least one mile length) collided with the particle shields at presumably relativistic speeds (during reentry from hyperspace). The three impactors were annihilated, and Executor was unscathed but suffered serious temporary shield loss, requiring it to delay its mission.

The image of this incident carries interesting hints about the dynamics of particle shields. The fireballs from the collided ships were flattened along a smooth surface that stands several hundred metres above Executor's dorsal cortex. This presumably is the depth into the field at which the velocities of the fastest debris particles were damped to zero velocity relative to Executor. It may be representative of an equipotential surface corresponding to the kinetic energy or momentum density of the impactors.
http://www.theforce.net/swtc/ssd.html#shields

Posted: 2005-05-30 02:42pm
by Hardy
Dr. Saxton estimated the power output of an ISD to be 1E25 Watts based on the assumption of an exhaust velocity of c and a peak accleration of 3000 G. The mass of a single Imperator is therefore 1.1e12 kg.

Multiply this by three and input it here with the speed at .99c:

http://www.stardestroyer.net/Empire/Sci ... ivity.html

It may not be representative of the true KE, though. I honestly don't know the details.

Posted: 2005-05-30 03:09pm
by BringerOfLight
Posted by Spanky the Dolphin from SWTC
This upper limit on the shield capacity is complemented by a lower limit provided by the Classic STAR WARS comics, which chronicle an accident in which Admiral Griff's three destroyers or light cruisers (of at least one mile length) collided with the particle shields at presumably relativistic speeds (during reentry from hyperspace). The three impactors were annihilated, and Executor was unscathed but suffered serious temporary shield loss, requiring it to delay its mission.
Yes this is what I'm curious about, assuming the three destroyers/light cruisers have at least as much mass as an ISD (they are at least as long as an ISD), we get a limit of 1.740E30 J using Harding's calculations (assuming I didn't somehow mess up).