Given Crystal current look I am kind of sceptical of her having any magic items.Jub wrote:It could just be a high CR foe with some serious magic helping out its AC. At the levels the party seems to be at +5 deflection bonuses to AC aren't outside the realm of the expected, let alone anything else like a haste bonus to AC, or an item that grants a luck, dodge, or even untyped bonuses to AC.
As for natural 1, maybe, but Crystal movement in that frame and smug look after suggests she dodged them somehow, not that Haley just missed in critical moment, IMHO.