Romans Vs. orks

[Next of Kin]

Well, as good as the Romans were, I'm not sure they could take Mordor. If it were just about the physical defenses, I'd give it to the Romans without hesitation. But there is also the power of the Ring, and the ability of the Nazgul to instill fear in their enemies. Also, as good as the Romans were, they came from a superstitious age. The sight of trolls and flying fell beasts such as the Nazgul rode would be unnerving, to say the least. The Ring, and other magical abilities might tip the balance in favor of Mordor, but without those advantages I'd say Mordor was about to have the Pax Romanaenforced on it.

The romans would get over the fell beasts and trolls as they have weakness and are beatable.