That does not surprise me at all. Having been a graduate of Catholic prison camp myself, I will testify to the quality of education you get from them as opposed to Fundie Thought Reform camps.Silver Jedi wrote:Actually, it is possable to get a decent high school science education in Texas. I Did. Of course, I had to go to (of all places) a catholic school to get it. Go figure.Patrick Degan wrote: Science textbooks are subjected to even greater scrutiny as far as accuracy is concerned (well, except perhaps in Texas, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, and Florida, where accuracy in science is not exactly considered important).
You see, in the Catholic church, a sharp intellect is valued because it can be honed as a weapon for theological combat, so its training has always been important. And also, the exact word and accuracy of the Bible has never been that high a premium among the Catholics, unlike with the Fundies. Since for most of its history, the Mass was said in Latin and in the Middle Ages most persons either had no opportunity to become educated in Latin or were forbidden to translate the Bible from Latin, the Church could interpret Biblical doctrine in any way it was convenient. The Protestants were the first to translate the Bible into contemporary languages as a means to break Popery —until eventually developing their own mechanisms to impose ignorance and conformity, of course.
Some of the sharpest debaters you'll find are Jesuits. Now, I wasn't educated by Jesuits (indeed, in my school, it was a joke that at Jesuit, you seperated the boys from the men with pry-bars, but that's neither here nor there) but all Catholic schools do hone that mind even while bending it into the loop that locks you into the Faith. They don't care whether Genesis can be reconciled with evolution, physics, and geology or not. They don't care whether the Flood was real or that the world is much older than 6000 years and evidently took a lot longer than seven days to create.
Just so long as you can prove that angels do dance on the heads of pins and provide a population count.