Page 1 of 1

How accurate is this site (WW2 - eastern front)?

Posted: 2009-01-25 03:58pm
by Serafina
I have a simple question: How accurate is this site about the Great Patriotic War?

It has a interesting mutimedia map/presentation about the eastern front in WW II, from a russian point of view.
It seems to have good research, and showing little bias.
However, being no expert in history, i wanted to ask what you think about this site?
Is it good enough to be used as a reliable source, or should i discard it as "nice but unreliable"?

(Warning: The presentation is rather long, due to it showing 4 years of war. There is no need to watch it completly (if you do not want to - a good first impression is all i want.)

Re: How accurate is this site (WW2 - eastern front)?

Posted: 2009-01-25 04:19pm
by phongn
I wouldn't use it as a reliable source - there's plenty of other sources for that. That said, it is a nice site!

Re: How accurate is this site (WW2 - eastern front)?

Posted: 2009-01-25 04:23pm
by Serafina
Why, thank you.

Of course there are other sources - but on this site, i have a nice, compressed, enjoyable source.
Thus, i can easily show it to other people (friends/sibilings) and either educate them or discuss it with them.
But if the information is inaccurate/biassed, i would not want to use it (obviously).

Re: How accurate is this site (WW2 - eastern front)?

Posted: 2009-01-25 04:39pm
by fgalkin
It is somewhat biased in its delivery of information, but it is still very good for seeing the general ebb and flow of the war.

Have a very nice day.
-fgalkin

Re: How accurate is this site (WW2 - eastern front)?

Posted: 2009-01-26 01:55am
by K. A. Pital
There's no potential for major bias there anyway. It's mostly about the military operations. And the remembrances of people are genuine, so the issue is not the reliability of the "website" itself, but the reliability of the people's witness accounts and recollections.

This site is a good example of what modern technology can do to condense the history of a gigantic war into a short and concise interactive presentation. It's more visual as a general overview, far better than a book with static mapsets - so if you want to just have an overview of the war, by all means use it.

Re: How accurate is this site (WW2 - eastern front)?

Posted: 2009-01-27 04:39am
by Serafina
Well, thank you all for the information.

Re: How accurate is this site (WW2 - eastern front)?

Posted: 2009-01-27 10:20am
by wautd
I love that site. Saw it a few months ago but forgot to bookmark it. It must have taken an impressive amount of work to put all of that together