Page 1 of 1

vaginal piercing to be classified as Female genital mutilati

Posted: 2015-03-18 07:30am
by dragon
This also covers cosmetic alteration such as labia reduction to covered as FGM.
Women with vaginal piercings are to be classed as victims of female genital mutilation (FGM), health chiefs have said.

Under new NHS rules to be introduced next month, any woman whose labia or clitoris has been pierced must be recorded as suffering FGM, a procedure which is illegal in the UK.

The mandatory reporting regulations were sent to medical staff by the Department of Health, which said it is would start classifying the piercings 'within an abusive context'.

It means that even women who have consented to the piercing for cosmetic reasons will be deemed as a potential victim of crime. Those responsible for carrying out the piercing could also be implicated for committing a criminal offence.

The new rules are in line with guidance from the World Health Organisation, which last year classified piercing as 'harmful procedures' that are considered under the bracket of FGM.

There is already much debate about whether genital surgery procedures such as so-called 'designer vagina' operations should be treated by as FGM.

Last week, MPs released a report which said police, midwives and campaigners remain confused over whether the operations fall within FGM laws.

Under the Female Genital Mutilation Act 2003, it is illegal to cut girls' genitals unless there is a genuine justification.

The exemptions in the Female Genital Mutilation Act 2003 refer to operations carried out on the grounds of physical or mental health and do not cover cosmetic surgery.


The Home Affairs Select Committee said the act should be amended to reiterate that female genital cosmetic surgery on those who do not have a physical or mental health justification is potentially illegal. The Government has previously said it has no plans to make these changes.

Some 170,000 women and girls are estimated to be living with FGM in the UK.

More than 2,600 women and girls who went through FGM have been treated by the NHS since last September, with 499 women and girls with FGM seen in acute NHS trusts in England in January alone.

More than 200 FGM-related cases were investigated by the police nationally in the past five years.

A Department of Health man said: 'While there are challenges in this area and adult women may have genital piercings, in some communities girls are forced to have them. The World Health Organisation has quite rightly defined this as a form of FGM.

'We are taking every precaution to record genital piercings that have been done within an abusive context.

'The new data collection will help build a picture of the scale and the nature of the problem we are facing. We are continually working on ways to improve and develop the NHS response to this terrible practice.'
The 'Because I am a Girl' campaign to tackle FGM (related)

link

Re: vaginal piercing to be classified as Female genital muti

Posted: 2015-03-18 08:06am
by madd0ct0r
A Department of Health man said: 'While there are challenges in this area and adult women may have genital piercings, in some communities girls are forced to have them. The World Health Organisation has quite rightly defined this as a form of FGM.

'We are taking every precaution to record genital piercings that have been done within an abusive context.

'The new data collection will help build a picture of the scale and the nature of the problem we are facing. We are continually working on ways to improve and develop the NHS response to this terrible practice.'
I think that explains it nicely.
1) We don't know the extent of the issue, so we need to get some data in order to work out where to go.
2) we're quite happy to scare piercings shops off doing this work on children.
3) it stops people trying to dodge anti-FGM laws by doing things like 'the piercing got terribly infected and required surgery'.

Re: vaginal piercing to be classified as Female genital muti

Posted: 2015-03-18 10:30am
by Broomstick
It sounds like a good idea (prevent FGM in children) that requires some tweaking (adult women can choose what to do with their bodies).

Re: vaginal piercing to be classified as Female genital muti

Posted: 2015-03-18 10:44am
by Zaune
Also, not to put too fine a point on it, but am I the only one who thinks the very concept of a "designer vagina" is profoundly silly?

Re: vaginal piercing to be classified as Female genital muti

Posted: 2015-03-18 10:54am
by Elheru Aran
Now I'm having the mental picture of a bearded, turbanned Muslim guy bringing in a little girl wearing a hijab and telling the nurse something along the lines of "Verily, this child did get a clitorial piercing, and alas, it went septic..."

That's my fucked up mind at work, though. And where the hell are little girls 'forced' to get genital piercings? WTF?

Re: vaginal piercing to be classified as Female genital muti

Posted: 2015-03-18 01:47pm
by Broomstick
Zaune wrote:Also, not to put too fine a point on it, but am I the only one who thinks the very concept of a "designer vagina" is profoundly silly?
No, it is profoundly silly. I've yet to meet a hetero man who refused to have sex with a woman because her vag lips were asymmetrical or a bit longer than usual.
Elheru Aran wrote:That's my fucked up mind at work, though. And where the hell are little girls 'forced' to get genital piercings? WTF?
The "piercing" may be related to infibulation. Using thorns, pins, or other such objects to close the "gap" is a variant on the practice.

Also, certain types of piercings can act as a sort of chastity belt.

Re: vaginal piercing to be classified as Female genital muti

Posted: 2015-03-20 01:17am
by Grumman
The Home Affairs Select Committee said the act should be amended to reiterate that female genital cosmetic surgery on those who do not have a physical or mental health justification is potentially illegal.
Why the fuck is there a mental health exemption? If there's something wrong with someone's mind that makes them think they need cosmetic surgery, the mind is the problem that needs to be fixed.

Re: vaginal piercing to be classified as Female genital muti

Posted: 2015-03-20 07:20am
by Broomstick
The "mental health" exception might be to allow transition surgery for transsexuals?

Re: vaginal piercing to be classified as Female genital muti

Posted: 2015-03-20 08:16am
by Irbis
Grumman wrote:
The Home Affairs Select Committee said the act should be amended to reiterate that female genital cosmetic surgery on those who do not have a physical or mental health justification is potentially illegal.
Why the fuck is there a mental health exemption? If there's something wrong with someone's mind that makes them think they need cosmetic surgery, the mind is the problem that needs to be fixed.
"Something wrong with someone's mind" can be, say, transsexualism or any number of potency problems. How do you exactly say they need to be fixed? By locking in a monastery with cold showers? :roll:

Re: vaginal piercing to be classified as Female genital muti

Posted: 2015-03-20 08:33am
by Dominus Atheos
Broomstick wrote:
Elheru Aran wrote:That's my fucked up mind at work, though. And where the hell are little girls 'forced' to get genital piercings? WTF?
The "piercing" may be related to infibulation. Using thorns, pins, or other such objects to close the "gap" is a variant on the practice.

Also, certain types of piercings can act as a sort of chastity belt.
Probably, but it's still over-broad since it covers clitoral piercings.

Also, there's (almost) no such thing as a "clitoral" piercing, it's a clitoral hood peircing 99% of the time.

Re: vaginal piercing to be classified as Female genital muti

Posted: 2015-03-20 11:48am
by Broomstick
Well, there you go - clitoral HOOD piercing isn't explicitly forbidden.

Re: vaginal piercing to be classified as Female genital muti

Posted: 2015-03-24 01:07am
by Sidewinder
Sargon of Akkad is harshly critical of this policy, as seen here.

Re: vaginal piercing to be classified as Female genital muti

Posted: 2015-03-24 11:56pm
by Simon_Jester
Listening to random snippets from "Sargon's" commentary, he's a babbling idiot too self-righteous to comprehend what other people are saying.

Ah well, I guess even a stopped chronometer is right once in a millenium.