StarDestroyer.Net BBS

Witch website is the best?

http://195.100.17.82/

Or

http://12.23.9.68/

Puting them as IP adresses dunno when the DNS change will take effect

I am pissed at one of these sites but I need an unbiased opinion witch one is better looking?

personally i prefer the second one, the first one was too sparse for my liking.

Faram wrote: http://12.23.9.68/

This one has some problems....mostly with the fact the drop down/pop up navigation is going behind the wonderful art in the middle of the page....so it's no use for navigation....

BOTH are very professional looking and very impressive!

I have a 21-inch viewable monitor with hi resolution, so on the "192" site there is A LOT of white space........ and it appears on the upper left side of my screen... for me that is a bit distracting.

The "12" site has really great color scheme, it is centered and really does catch my eye when it loads.

For an instant choice, I would pick the "12" site. Although I think both are very Excellently done and VERY professional.

Job WELL DONE SIR!!! Excellent work

just some background info

I was the admin for one of those sites, but due to coperate infighting somotherdude is now the admin for the other site.

Same company on both sites loads of cash spended on hip websites and data transfers consulting yaddayadda.

All in these times of cutbacks and savings...

SIGH

IMO the first one is better, looks more professional.

the second has a cooler IP addy, but the first looks better. The menus don't work properly in opera on the second page.

The second one is better, but both "suffer" from a need to force the viewer to use a specific screen size.

THe second one "looks" like it could stand to be bigger, and still hold up.

The second one has those goofy drop-down menus, which look cute but are a little draggy. On the other hand, the buttons for the first site could stand slightly more highlighting.