Page 1 of 2

Finally saw 2001:ASO for the first time...

Posted: 2003-08-31 05:16am
by UltraViolence83
...And I must say that Kubrick must have been on some trippy chems to put together those latter scenes.

Felt too self-indulgent. Too much showing off. The only scene I really liked was when Dave was disconneting HAL's higher logic functions.

"I'm scared, Dave."
"My mind's going. I can feel it, I can feel it..."

One of the eeriest things I've ever heard. :shock:


And what pisses me off isn't acutally the movie, it's that we could have had space stations and moon bases like that in the 80s! Damn space program!


PS: Seriously, though. What the fuck is with the last half hour or so? Tim Leary was the special effects guy or something?

Posted: 2003-08-31 05:26am
by Raxmei
The ending makes a lot more sense in the book. Or so I'm told.

Posted: 2003-08-31 05:32am
by Bug-Eyed Earl
Basically, the monolith was a sort of gateway to one of the aliens'work stations. The hotel room Bowman appeared in was extracted from images from his mind, and his rapid aging and death was the aliens' remaking him into the Star Child. For what purpose, I am not really sure.

Now you have to watch 2010. Arthur C. Clarke loved the movie, which you don't really hear from authors that mch.

Posted: 2003-08-31 08:40am
by Tribun
2001 by far one of the most boring movies, I have ever seen. I really wondert, why some people clim this orgy of ligh, nonsense and boredom a masterpiece.
Maybe, because they can't understand it?

Re: Finally saw 2001:ASO for the first time...

Posted: 2003-08-31 10:30am
by SyntaxVorlon
UltraViolence83 wrote:...And I must say that Kubrick must have been on some trippy chems to put together those latter scenes.

Felt too self-indulgent. Too much showing off. The only scene I really liked was when Dave was disconneting HAL's higher logic functions.

"I'm scared, Dave."
"My mind's going. I can feel it, I can feel it..."

One of the eeriest things I've ever heard. :shock:


And what pisses me off isn't acutally the movie, it's that we could have had space stations and moon bases like that in the 80s! Damn space program!


PS: Seriously, though. What the fuck is with the last half hour or so? Tim Leary was the special effects guy or something?
The last half hour where he's flying through the wormhole, is IMO to make him look like a protohuman. every couple of minutes you see his face in incredible terror and horror, practically try to get out of his space suit.

I like how in every show about space, they'll make some reference to 2001. In Futurama the love song that bender say when he was dating the ship was Daisy. :D

Posted: 2003-08-31 10:52am
by Frank Hipper
Tribun wrote:2001 by far one of the most boring movies, I have ever seen. I really wondert, why some people clim this orgy of ligh, nonsense and boredom a masterpiece.
Maybe, because they can't understand it?
Perhaps your boredom stems from exactly that, lack of understanding.

A lot of criticism is leveled at the length of the liner docking at the station sequence. Kubrick felt that editing The Blue Danube was a travesty, and made the scene fit the music.

The "wormhole" scene or whatever it was that Bowman went through was a bit tedious, and bizarre, but the bit in the "hotel room" is one of my favorite movie scenes. I get hungry watching it, those aliens serve some good looking food. :D

Posted: 2003-08-31 10:52am
by Brother-Captain Gaius
Tribun wrote:2001 by far one of the most boring movies, I have ever seen. I really wondert, why some people clim this orgy of ligh, nonsense and boredom a masterpiece.
Maybe, because they can't understand it?
:shock:

Burn the heretic!

Re: Finally saw 2001:ASO for the first time...

Posted: 2003-08-31 11:09am
by aerius
SyntaxVorlon wrote:The last half hour where he's flying through the wormhole, is IMO to make him look like a protohuman. every couple of minutes you see his face in incredible terror and horror, practically try to get out of his space suit.
The last part of the movie works better when you mute the TV and play the Pink Floyd song "Echoes". The music synchs up with the psychedelic effects and it's better than the normal soundtrack.

Posted: 2003-08-31 11:32am
by Tsyroc
Frank Hipper wrote: A lot of criticism is leveled at the length of the liner docking at the station sequence. Kubrick felt that editing The Blue Danube was a travesty, and made the scene fit the music.
Good for him. I absolutely love that part of the movie. Besides the music, the space plane & station, I like the whole concept of how the spaceport looks and so on. I guess I just like looking at the past's predictions of what the future will look like. :-) Plus, who would want them to shorten The Blue Danube? :-(
The "wormhole" scene or whatever it was that Bowman went through was a bit tedious, and bizarre, but the bit in the "hotel room" is one of my favorite movie scenes. I get hungry watching it, those aliens serve some good looking food. :D
I haven't seen the movie in awhile but I thought it was okay overall. After seeing 2010 it makes more sense to me and is a bit cooler but for the most part I'm not into this style of science fiction.

Posted: 2003-08-31 11:38am
by Demiurge
It's refreshing to see a sci-fi film that doesn't have giant killer robots and evil alien space empires. Don't get me wrong, I like those things, but it's good for a change.

Or a plot lol! Yes, I know that's what you were going to say.

Re: Finally saw 2001:ASO for the first time...

Posted: 2003-08-31 12:19pm
by Frank Hipper
aerius wrote:
SyntaxVorlon wrote:The last half hour where he's flying through the wormhole, is IMO to make him look like a protohuman. every couple of minutes you see his face in incredible terror and horror, practically try to get out of his space suit.
The last part of the movie works better when you mute the TV and play the Pink Floyd song "Echoes". The music synchs up with the psychedelic effects and it's better than the normal soundtrack.
"Echoes" makes anything better. ANYTHING. :D

Posted: 2003-08-31 12:24pm
by Trytostaydead
2001 was a BEAUTIFUL movie. I LOVED the Blue Danube scene.

I LOVED the entire movie in fact.

2010 was really 'eh' I would've really loved to learn more about those dang Monoliths.

Posted: 2003-08-31 12:38pm
by Singular Quartet
All I have to say is this:

At least it wasn't fifteen minutes of the main character just driving through Moscow, doing nothing, saying nothing, and with no music.

Posted: 2003-08-31 12:42pm
by Admiral Valdemar
Singular Quartet wrote:All I have to say is this:

At least it wasn't fifteen minutes of the main character just driving through Moscow, doing nothing, saying nothing, and with no music.
Hmm, the original Solaris is so much fun.

Posted: 2003-08-31 12:42pm
by HemlockGrey
It was the most boring movie I have ever seen.

Posted: 2003-08-31 12:43pm
by Trytostaydead
Singular Quartet wrote:All I have to say is this:

At least it wasn't fifteen minutes of the main character just driving through Moscow, doing nothing, saying nothing, and with no music.
What movie is that?

Posted: 2003-08-31 04:16pm
by PeZook
2001 for me was a string of cool-looking scenes that lasted far too long to maintain my interest. Like the start with the monolith and proto-humans - it seemed nice and interesting for the first few minutes, but I soon started to wish "Oh PLEASE, get to the goddamned POINT!"

Repeat ad nauseum through the rest of the movie. And I couldn't understand WTH Bowman was saying 3/4 of the time. If it wasn't for the awesome portrayal of space, I would have left before the ending.

In my humble opinion, 2010 was SO much better. I've seen it three times, while trying to watch 2001 again made me go play computer games after 10 minutes.

Posted: 2003-08-31 04:26pm
by DocHorror
IMHO 2010 is crap, 2001 is soooo much better. It shows space travel as it really is. Long. Empty. Boring and dangerous.

Its a movie you either appreciate or hate. Though I won't fault anyone who doesn't like it. Its all opinion after all.

Posted: 2003-08-31 05:36pm
by Dahak
Tribun wrote:2001 by far one of the most boring movies, I have ever seen. I really wondert, why some people clim this orgy of ligh, nonsense and boredom a masterpiece.
Maybe, because they can't understand it?
As Frank said, because YOU don't understand.

It *is* a masterpice. Just because there are no bombs, things exploding, funky starship battles, and no chicks showing their secondary sexual characteristic every other scene, doesn't mean its boring.

It only means you can't appreciate it.
Might as well stand in the Sistine Chapel and go "Oh, that's ugly shit up at the wall..."

Posted: 2003-08-31 06:12pm
by HemlockGrey
This 'oh, you don't understand it' is condescending crap. What are we supposed to understand? I don't really appreciate the artistic value of long, drawn-out space shots. Sorry.

Posted: 2003-08-31 07:07pm
by jenat-lai
I do. Space is long and drawn out. I like seeing some proper space physics, none of this zapping around doing 45 degree changes in direction in 5 seconds, but the type where velocities must be matched, and all of that. Finally, classical music is long. Just be glad he picked the Blue Danube not Mahler's 3rd Symphony :P (2 hours of music in that one) lol.


The only bit I truly didn't like was the whole monolith thing. I'd rather see a sci fi with no aliens at all. Though I don't know of one that exists yet lol.

No explosions, all just routine and boring.

The only space movie I'v truly enjoyed has been Apollo 13. Some of that is a bit hyped too, but at least it's pretty close.

Posted: 2003-08-31 07:15pm
by Robert Treder
2001 isn't bad, but it's the least good Kubrick movie. One of its problems is that it's disjointed; it connects several interesting scenes in uninteresting manners. Also, the entire ending sequence is stupid. And yes, believe me, I understand it, but I still think it's stupid. In fact, I don't like any of the monolith stuff. Except for the scene where they go down to see the moon excavation; that scene is good if only for the music.

I'll take Barry Lyndon or Dr. Strangelove or A Clockwork Orange over 2001 any day of the week.

Posted: 2003-08-31 07:42pm
by Mark S
I haven't actually seen 2001 all the way through yet. I keep meaning to every time it comes on tv but things just come up. That and everyone around me gets bored of it and wants to turn it off.

Posted: 2003-08-31 09:36pm
by Alyeska
2001 was a steaming pile of shit. It was fucking long and BORRING. I don't want any fucking bombs or people getting killed, I want SOMETHING to happen. Shit, might as well hold up ST TMP for the same fucking reasons people are holding 2001 in high esteme. Plenty of crap scenery BORRING shots.

I don't fucking see how people can call it artistic and fun to watch 30 minutes of a fucking shuttle docking with a station. I want PLOT, I want it to get to the point. Fuck, I never did see the whole movie through it was so fucking borring.

Posted: 2003-08-31 10:08pm
by Kuja
I liked the scenes with Hal. The rest: meh.