StarDestroyer.Net BBS

Just curious what people think. He stomped in pretty brash (much like he was in his Hate Mail exchange as Visionrazor), but seemed to settle down after a while.

I'm not voting because I'm not sure.

I do think he posts a little too much, though. It's like he's everywhere.

Last I heard he was enjoying his VI title. In fact, he even wanted to form a VI club of sorts.

Wicked Pilot wrote:Last I heard he was enjoying his VI title. In fact, he even wanted to form a VI club of sorts.

That was a while ago now. And I think it was partially as a joke.

And he's improved but I think he still deserves it for now. If he keeps up the good behaviour then remove it in a while.

Mike: Can you put up an option for improved but still not long enough to see if its taken.

I think he deserves whatever title he would normally have. Or maybe a "Rehabillitated Village Idiot" title.

IRG CommandoJoe wrote:I think he deserves whatever title he would normally have. Or maybe a "Rehabillitated Village Idiot" title.

That's a good idea, let him have that until he's proven that he can behave.

How about "Village Idiot on Probation"?

Wicked Pilot wrote:How about "Village Idiot on Probation"?

Nah, he seems to be actually have improved and that makes it sound like he's one step from being banned.

He doesn't seem like such a bad guy now.

How about 'Recovering Village Idiot'?

I thought about putting up a poll like that.

He seems ok now. Is this the first Village Idiot we've had who may just lose his title?

Speaking of which, maybe we should have a Stardestroyer.Net BBS Village Idiot Day, where everyone can act like absolute fuckwits?

In the threads I've seen him in, he's been pretty reasonable. I say he's worthy of at least a probationary period.

Vympel wrote: Speaking of which, maybe we should have a Stardestroyer.Net BBS Village Idiot Day, where everyone can act like absolute fuckwits?

I believe I speak for every one else when I say: Hell No!

He seems alright. Let him out.

Oh, and NO Idiot Day Please!

Well, he has improved, I'll give him that. But, he's still an antagonist. However, he has been known to admit when someone has a better idea than he does. So... I have no idea what I've just said. God, I hate headaches... and it's frickin' cold.

Vympel wrote:Speaking of which, maybe we should have a Stardestroyer.Net BBS Village Idiot Day, where everyone can act like absolute fuckwits?

Nah, just go over to Section31 where everyday is Village Idiot Day

Stormbringer wrote:

Vympel wrote: Speaking of which, maybe we should have a Stardestroyer.Net BBS Village Idiot Day, where everyone can act like absolute fuckwits?

I believe I speak for every one else when I say: Hell No!

You mean were aren't supposed to be acting like Fuckwits?.

Ok, I've made up my mind. He has definatley improved. He just defended me over in the STvsSW board. He gets my vote.

Yeah, change it.

IG-88E wrote:How about 'Recovering Village Idiot'?

I understand that you can be rehabilitated...but you make it sound like idiocy is a disease...

Kelly Antilles wrote:Well, he has improved, I'll give him that. But, he's still an antagonist. However, he has been known to admit when someone has a better idea than he does. So... I have no idea what I've just said. God, I hate headaches... and it's frickin' cold.

Being an antagonist is not all that bad, it stimulates thought. The point should be is he a reasonable antagonist? He is capable of conceading points if he is wrong and does come up with some points as well.

I believe he should be relieved of the VI title, but Mr. Wong should and would reserve the right (he is the site admin.) to give the title back at any time.

Hey what about making him 'official antagonist'?

How about just leaving him alone and removing the VI tag?

Well, it seems that he's backed out of the debating, and seems normal to me. I say revoke the title.

Every post I've seen him make has been pretty civil. I say let him out of it.