StarDestroyer.Net BBS

Is there some big supporter that trek would win a war with the empire. Sort of the Wong of trekkies. If so I think we should pull a heavy anti-him thing on another forum, finding errors in his work and discrediting him for it. Then see how the trekkies react when we do it? For one I think it would be funny, and perhaps useful. Oh, and who ever does it should hide under the guise of John Clark.

His name is Grahamn Kennedy. While the bulk of his site doesn't deal with "Star Wars vs Star Trek," his crossover fanfic does. He has Imperial turbolasers not being able to penetrate Federation shields, and the Defiant destroying the Death Star with a photorp.

According to this guy, a full broadside of an ISD against the Enterprise E would only cause a 1% loss in shields because as we all know, Feds are immune to lasers, regardless of power. The Enterprise would then return fire, doing rapid phaser shots, easily taking out all weapon emplacements in one short swoop.

Check it out at http://www.ditl.org.

"The more we fight trekkies, the more we become like trekkies"

This is less becoming trekkie like than it is mocking their tactics when they find the fallacy in them when turned on them.

Please don't feed the trolls.

fgalkin wrote:"The more we fight trekkies, the more we become like trekkies"

I pusume you have heard the Neizche quote relevent to this right....

Please don't feed the trolls.

Moreso, please don't be the trolls.

Yeah, but Kennedy is just an idiot. We need some site like Wong's to discredit. One that is big. Then again, if one is smart enough to create a site like Wong's (replete with calcs and everything), then he would almost HAVE to support SW, because he would recognize that ST would lose! I guess all the intelligent people already agree with us, so there really isn't a lot that we can do.

USAF Ace wrote:His name is Grahamn Kennedy. While the bulk of his site doesn't deal with "Star Wars vs Star Trek," his crossover fanfic does. He has Imperial turbolasers not being able to penetrate Federation shields, and the Defiant destroying the Death Star with a photorp.

According to this guy, a full broadside of an ISD against the Enterprise E would only cause a 1% loss in shields because as we all know, Feds are immune to lasers, regardless of power. The Enterprise would then return fire, doing rapid phaser shots, easily taking out all weapon emplacements in one short swoop.

Check it out at http://www.ditl.org.

HAHAHAHAHA I'm gonna have to read that for a laugh.

Christ I think he was typing that garbage one handed...

Nah, the fanfic is the result of ignorance, and putting quotes over canon evidence.

You know whats funny? He's says he only uses the movies for SW, but then turns around and uses the RPG stats for an ISD, not the model.

Standard Trekkie: Only uses stats from official sources that help him in his arguments.

Grand Admiral Thrawn wrote:You know whats funny? He's says he only uses the movies for SW, but then turns around and uses the RPG stats for an ISD, not the model.

He'll probably use what ever fits into what he wants, standard trekkie/troll tactic.

What is funny is that he says TPM has put him off SW for life yet he's still into Trrek despite garbage like Voyager and Insurrection. heh.

Of course he also assumes fusion is nuclear fusion, again from an official sourse, not a canon one. And then there's "The phenomena has a definite range over which it operates - approximately one hundred and fifty kilometres." Despite the fact the DS is 160 km long and only WEG thinks it's 120. Again, picking and choosing


And when I (a long time ago) showed him his figures for hyperspace speeds were wrong guess what he said? I'm sorry you didn't like the story!

*puts foot uop trolls ass*

yeah, i read that garbage fanfic.
I stopped reading it when picard compared a Star Destroyer's firepower to a friggin runabout. Master Mong's fanfic was the wet dream of SWvsST, while Mr. Kennedy's fanfic was the turd of SWvsST. Another great fanfic was chuck sonneburg's Worlds Without End trilogy at sfdebris.com. If you havnt read it, i suggest you do. The only thing is, he hast updated the site since November, 2001.

I hate those bastards that write good stories and then never finish them up.