Page 1 of 2

A question about Wongs story

Posted: 2002-12-30 09:27pm
by Jason von Evil
Well, besides the question on how a kickass story like that could exist, I was wondering what class of ship the USS Carolina was? I've been wondering since I read the story. I keep getting the image of an Excelsior being in that mess of a battle in the beginning.

Posted: 2002-12-30 09:54pm
by Sea Skimmer
This is a question for email or PM, or atleast for the FAN FICTION forum.

Posted: 2002-12-30 10:13pm
by LordShaithis
Don't be an ass, Sea Skimmer.

Posted: 2002-12-30 10:20pm
by Darth Wong
I never actually thought it was important, since the ship is turned into iron filings in the beginning of the story anyway. Leave it open to your own imagination.

Posted: 2002-12-30 10:46pm
by Jason von Evil
Darth Wong wrote:I never actually thought it was important, since the ship is turned into iron filings in the beginning of the story anyway. Leave it open to your own imagination.
Eh, Excelsior then.

Skimmer, I did email him, but I didn't want to wait six months for a reply.:P

Posted: 2002-12-30 10:59pm
by Grand Admiral Thrawn
Sea Skimmer isn't being an ass.

Posted: 2002-12-30 11:18pm
by Vympel
I envisioned the Carolina as a Sovereign for some reason ...

Posted: 2002-12-30 11:21pm
by Captain Cyran
I saw it as a Miranda

Posted: 2002-12-30 11:27pm
by Luke Starkiller
I saw it as a Nebula or Galaxy. To each his own I suppose.

Posted: 2002-12-30 11:35pm
by Master of Ossus
Darth Wong wrote:I never actually thought it was important, since the ship is turned into iron filings in the beginning of the story anyway. Leave it open to your own imagination.
That's a great answer, DW.

I always envisioned it as an Exelsior class ship, which (uncoincidentally) is also the SF design that I think looks the coolest.

Posted: 2002-12-30 11:41pm
by Bug-Eyed Earl
Darth WOng, is Chang an original character? Since he is Asian and is never referred to as such (as it should be; why do writers insist on giving ethnic characters ethnic characteristics bordering on stereotypes and the way alien races all act the same on ST), I assume that you created him. And this fact is a testament to the sad state of affairs in modern sci-fi.

Posted: 2002-12-30 11:52pm
by Subnormal
I wish it was a certain Intrepid Class, with a bitch of a female captain. Captain of course "Goes down with the ship."

Posted: 2002-12-31 01:04am
by Jason von Evil
Bug-Eyed Earl wrote:Darth WOng, is Chang an original character? Since he is Asian and is never referred to as such (as it should be; why do writers insist on giving ethnic characters ethnic characteristics bordering on stereotypes and the way alien races all act the same on ST), I assume that you created him. And this fact is a testament to the sad state of affairs in modern sci-fi.
There was a character from Voyager Elite Force (a PC FPS game, very cool one infact) named Austin Chang, he was the Hazard Ops demolitionist.

Anyways, it couldn't really be a Miranda or an Excelsior, since the Carolina used quantom torpedos and not even a damn Obreth, let alone a Jem'Hadar attack ship would run from an outdated piece of crap like the Miranda. :P

Posted: 2002-12-31 01:07am
by Master of Ossus
Aya wrote:
Bug-Eyed Earl wrote:Darth WOng, is Chang an original character? Since he is Asian and is never referred to as such (as it should be; why do writers insist on giving ethnic characters ethnic characteristics bordering on stereotypes and the way alien races all act the same on ST), I assume that you created him. And this fact is a testament to the sad state of affairs in modern sci-fi.
There was a character from Voyager Elite Force (a PC FPS game, very cool one infact) named Austin Chang, he was the Hazard Ops demolitionist.

Anyways, it couldn't really be a Miranda or an Excelsior, since the Carolina used quantom torpedos and not even a damn Obreth, let alone a Jem'Hadar attack ship would run from an outdated piece of crap like the Miranda. :P
No, it could be an Exelsior. Remember in "Paradise Lost," the Lakota was said to be carrying a load of quantum torpedoes, which it was then ordered to use against the Defiant.

Posted: 2002-12-31 01:18am
by Jason von Evil
I never saw that episode, but I do know what the Lakota is, I just wasn't aware of the quantomness of the torpedos.:P

Posted: 2002-12-31 12:40pm
by The Nomad
Well, why not a Defiant-class, then :twisted: ?

Posted: 2002-12-31 02:07pm
by Admiral Drason
I always saw it as an Akira.

Posted: 2002-12-31 02:49pm
by Grand Admiral Thrawn
Not Defiant. It didn't have a lot of people.

Posted: 2002-12-31 02:57pm
by 2000AD
Personally i can't identify different ships apart from TOS Enterprise, TNG Enterprise, Defiant and Voyager so i just slotted it into one of those, TNG Enterprise look i think.

Posted: 2002-12-31 03:09pm
by Ignorant_Boy
Something with a saucer, a neck, and nacells poking out the back :lol:

Posted: 2003-01-01 08:38am
by Peregrin Toker
I never bothered to think about it, I just perceived it as a GFS.
(Generic Federal Starship)

Posted: 2003-01-01 09:05am
by Shadow
I saw it as a Miranda, and I assumed it had been upgraded with quantum torpedoes.

Posted: 2003-01-01 09:39am
by Cpt_Frank
For me it was an Intrepid.

Posted: 2003-01-02 06:22am
by Jason von Evil
A Jem'Hadar wouldn't run from a Miranda, lol.

Posted: 2003-01-03 06:44pm
by Singular Quartet
Simon H.Johansen wrote:I never bothered to think about it, I just perceived it as a GFS.
(Generic Federal Starship)
Actualy, It might more be Generic Federation Starship. And personall, I saw it the same as Ignorant_boy. Saucer, nexk, two ovalish things coming out the back. You know, a GFS.