Translation:
Federation has pocket devices, small and effective with the exception of the people of El-Adrel.
As evidenced by-what, exactly?
Empire has huge robots that are massive targets, can't be carried by individuals, and are huge targets.
So being the approximate size and shape of a human adult makes one a huge/massive target. Uhuh.
Repair:
Federation has nano-bots that cover the hull and are near impossible targets.
As evidenced by what, exactly? Not that them being near impossible targets makes any sense in the first place, if they cover the hull you will AUTOMATICALLY hit them when you hit the hull, and Wars weapons WILL hit the hull.
Empire has huge droids that are cumbersome and difficult to move around. Easy targets for highly accurate Federation weapons...
So being the approximate size of a wastepaper basket qualifies as huge now, does it. Are those the same highly accurate Federation weapons that routinely miss several-times-the-size-of-a-Nimitz targets at ranges that modern day fighter pilots would consider a dogfight?
Countermeasures:
Federation can shoot down single bursts of enemy fire, even projectiles moving at the speed of c (as seen at the end of "The Price").
.
Projectiles cannot move at c by definition. Federation forces never, ever bother to shoot at incoming torpedoes (which generally make modern day missiles look agile). Neither does any other Trek power.
Empire has huge gun towers with manual gunners that frequently miss at point blank range. (As seen in A New Hope and Return of the Jedi).
Complete failure to show that the gunners have anything to do with the actual aiming (and we saw human gunners in ROTJ?), complete ignorance of the problem of using anti-capship guns against fighters. By his reasoning the Iowas had lousy targeting because her 16in guns couldn't hit incoming Zeros.
Accuracy:
Federation can hit single person from orbit, can hit projectile moving at the speed of light.
Projectiles can't move at the speed of light in the first place, they routinely miss massive targets at what are modern dogfighting ranges, they NEVER EVER shoot down incoming fire, I can't recall the Feds ever hitting a single person from orbit and even if they did what are the circumstances of them doing so?
Empire can't hit huge target right in front of them (In an New Hope when they couldn't shoot down a few fighters even while they were right in their faces.
In the presence of MASSIVE JAMMING, and oh, I'm afraid the Feds can't hit
massively HUGER targets right in front of them. Virtually EVER. The TIEs in ANH were gunning for highly agile fighters in a high level ECM environment. Fed ships routinely miss targets that make a supertanker look nimble.
Now even if though they were designed to hit capital ships, they still had manual gunning crews, and were nonetheless unable to hit a target).
Is this supposed to mean something?
Fighters had to get right next to the ventilation shaft to hit it (a joke even by contemporary standards).
That's funny, I remember both Luke and Red Leader being a considerable distance away from the ventilation shat when they released their torpedoes...
Not that modern day missiles are capable of doing 70,000 g turns but hey...
Sensors:
Federation can detect the DNA of a single cell from high distance (as seen in The Hunted, where a man was genetically engineered with altered organelle membranes to prevent the Enterprise sensors from detecting him. Not based on Comm badges now, is it?)
The same sensors that can't detect a ship hiding in a planet's magnetosphere? And how exactly is that going to help the Feds in a vs?
Ground Forces:
Federation phasers are accurate, precise, widley variable to fit many uses, and powerful.
Accurate and precise are basically interchangeable and both are wrong. TNG phasers are unaimable like nobody's business. The fact that people manage to hit with them AT ALL is a minor miracle.
They can fire at diffrent arc settings (a wide arc phaser would lay waste to a Jedi in a few seconds).
Because we have seen that happen so many times. Oh wait. We've seen stun widebeam exactly ONCE, and other widebeam settings at point-blank ranges. Assuming the Jedi stays in place to be HIT by the phaser how dow we know the widebeam retain enough punch to so much as tickle him?
They also can transport around an area at will
Assuming there is nothing as pesky as certain minerals or ordinary power transformers around. Or your technobabble inaccurately labelled scientific anomaly of the week. Or any of the
other thousand things that render transporters unfeasible.
, a huge tactical advantage over Imperial forces which either have to run from place to place or have to use huge transports (big target).
Does this guy actually know what huge MEANS? Empire APCs are no larger than modern day ones.
Imperial forces have lots of weapons that are totally pointless in a more advanced Federation-era state of warfare. Their huge transporters would be uneccessary to the Federation and could easily be wiped out by orbital bombardment.
Has this guy any idea about the firepower and speed differential ebtween Wars and Trek?
Valen has this guy any idea, period?
takes a long time to write you know.
