Lizards Rapidly Evolve After Introduction to Island

[wautd]

Link

April 21, 2008
Italian wall lizards introduced to a tiny island off the coast of Croatia are evolving in ways that would normally take millions of years to play out, new research shows.

In just a few decades the 5-inch-long (13-centimeter-long) lizards have developed a completely new gut structure, larger heads, and a harder bite, researchers say.

In 1971, scientists transplanted five adult pairs of the reptiles from their original island home in Pod Kopiste to the tiny neighboring island of Pod Mrcaru, both in the south Adriatic Sea.

Genetic testing on the Pod Mrcaru lizards confirmed that the modern population of more than 5,000 Italian wall lizards are all descendants of the original ten lizards left behind in the 1970s.

(Related: "Evolution's 'Driving Force' Shifts Based on Behavior, Study Says" [November 16, 2006].)

Lizard Swarm

While the experiment was more than 30 years in the making, it was not by design, according to Duncan Irschick, a study author and biology professor at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst.

After scientists transplanted the reptiles, the Croatian War of Independence erupted, ending in the mid-1990s. The researchers couldn't get back to island because of the war, Irschick said.

In 2004, however, tourism began to open back up, allowing researchers access to the island laboratory.

(Read: "Kayaking the New Croatia" in National Geographic Adventure Magazine.)

"We didn't know if we would find a lizard there. We had no idea if the original introductions were successful," Irschick said.

What they found, however, was shocking.

The island was swarming with lizards," he said.

The findings were published in March in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Fast-Track Evolution

The new habitat once had its own healthy population of lizards, which were less aggressive than the new implants, Irschick said.

The new species wiped out the indigenous lizard populations, although how it happened is unknown, he said.

The transplanted lizards adapted to their new environment in ways that expedited their evolution physically, Irschick explained.

Pod Mrcaru, for example, had an abundance of plants for the primarily insect-eating lizards to munch on. Physically, however, the lizards were not built to digest a vegetarian diet.

Researchers found that the lizards developed cecal valves—muscles between the large and small intestine—that slowed down food digestion in fermenting chambers, which allowed their bodies to process the vegetation's cellulose into volatile fatty acids.

"They evolved an expanded gut to allow them to process these leaves," Irschick said, adding it was something that had not been documented before. "This was a brand-new structure."

Along with the ability to digest plants came the ability to bite harder, powered by a head that had grown longer and wider.

(Related news: "Komodo Dragon's Bite Is 'Weaker Than a House Cat's'" [April 18, 2008].)

The rapid physical evolution also sparked changes in the lizard's social and behavioral structure, he said. For one, the plentiful food sources allowed for easier reproduction and a denser population.

The lizard also dropped some of its territorial defenses, the authors concluded.

Such physical transformation in just 30 lizard generations takes evolution to a whole new level, Irschick said.

It would be akin to humans evolving and growing a new appendix in several hundred years, he said.

"That's unparalleled. What's most important is how fast this is," he said.

While researchers do know the invader's impact on its reptile brethren, they do not know how the species impacts local vegetation or insects, a subject of future study, Irschick said.

Dramatic Changes

The study demonstrates that a lot of change happens in island environments, said Andrew Hendry, a biology professor at Montreal's McGill University.

What could be debated, however, is how those changes are interpreted—whether or not they had a genetic basis and not a "plastic response to the environment," said Hendry, who was not associated with the study.

There's no dispute that major changes to the lizards' digestive tract occurred. "That kind of change is really dramatic," he added.

"All of this might be evolution," Hendry said. "The logical next step would be to confirm the genetic basis for these changes."

[Zixinus]

I don't see much with creationism here. The lizards had high pressure to evolve, common among island environments.

[cosmicalstorm]

I've heard some talk about there being different genetic programs in an organism that can be turned on and off depending on the enviroment but I might be wrong.

[Zixinus]

I have too heard such events: people changing their eye colour due to hormones, hair becoming less curvy they it was before childbirth.

[Ryushikaze]

I have too heard such events: people changing their eye colour due to hormones, hair becoming less curvy they it was before childbirth.

I'm an example of such an instance. My hair has drastically darkened in color as I have aged (I was a straight up blond when I was four, now I'm undeniably brunet), and my eye color has switched at least once.

[Alyrium Denryle]

I've heard some talk about there being different genetic programs in an organism that can be turned on and off depending on the enviroment but I might be wrong.

Aaah, praise be to pehnotypic plasticity. Usually the changes do not include a whole new structure though, typically it is a matter of up or down regulation of existing structures, like the spines of a stickleback.

*puts this on the list of cases to follow*

[Kanastrous]

After past experience with cane toads and rabbits and mongooses (mongeese?) in other parts of the world, I'm a little bit surprised that this experiment was conducted, at all.

Maybe the felt that consequences were unimportant because of the islands' location and size...?

[Patrick Degan]

But anyway, so much for the cretinist saw that evolution can't be confirmed by experimentation.

[Darth Servo]

But anyway, so much for the cretinist saw that evolution can't be confirmed by experimentation.

B-b-but they're still lizards!!! They didn't transform into whales!!!
</idiot creationist>

Seriously we really need to see if and how successfully they can still cross-breed with their parent population.

[DaveJB]

That shouldn't actually be that much of a problem... lions and tigers have had separate populations for hundreds of millennia and can still cross-breed, with most impressive results. The biggest obstacle would likely be that the new population has developed different mating behaviour, which the originals won't recognise.

[TithonusSyndrome]

Interesting to see how this affects the punctuated equilibrium versus phyletic gradualism debate, if at all.

[Napoleon the Clown]

That shouldn't actually be that much of a problem... lions and tigers have had separate populations for hundreds of millennia and can still cross-breed, with most impressive results. The biggest obstacle would likely be that the new population has developed different mating behaviour, which the originals won't recognise.

Ligers and tions, like mules, are almost always sterile, however. The better question would be if the offspring would be able to reproduce or if they'd be sterile the majority of the time.

[Darth Servo]

Hence the phrase "how successful" in my post above.

[Napoleon the Clown]

I was responding to DaveJB's liger example.

[Vehrec]

Interesting to see how this affects the punctuated equilibrium versus phyletic gradualism debate, if at all.

It's too bad we can't determine which animals came up with which mutations from the tiny original genetic pool that was available.

[Alyrium Denryle]

That shouldn't actually be that much of a problem... lions and tigers have had separate populations for hundreds of millennia and can still cross-breed, with most impressive results. The biggest obstacle would likely be that the new population has developed different mating behaviour, which the originals won't recognise.

Specific instances aside, this is why the biological species concept is going the way of the great Auk in favor of the evolutionary species concept.

After past experience with cane toads and rabbits and mongooses (mongeese?) in other parts of the world, I'm a little bit surprised that this experiment was conducted, at all.

Maybe the felt that consequences were unimportant because of the islands' location and size...?

As a rule of thumb no one asked if an experiment was "ethical" until after the 70s

[lordofFNORD]

Interesting to see how this affects the punctuated equilibrium versus phyletic gradualism debate, if at all.

It's too bad we can't determine which animals came up with which mutations from the tiny original genetic pool that was available.

That would be an interesting experiment. Introduce a population to an environment with new stresses, and actually examine each generation to observe the changes in process.

Hella expensive though, closely examining an entire population for years.