CaptainChewbacca wrote:To take an oath I don't mean to a power I don't respect to save lives? I'd do it in a second.
Then how can you be trusted with any
other oath? Break one, and sooner or later, you'll break two. Then a third. And a fourth.
I'd always have to watch my back around you -- if you're willing to betray the bad guys, it's
possible, however remotely, that you might betray the good guys. I can't be CERTAIN about you any more.
The odds that you might actually do so are likely smaller than the odds of being struck by lightning out of a clear sky, but even odds that high are too risky for me. I'd prefer an evil guy with iron clad honor - whose behavior I can predict, whose behavior is bound by rules - to a good guy who can't be trusted to keep his word, and who can't be predicted.
I won't break an oath I give, however evil the oath is. But neither will I GIVE an oath I don't want to have to keep.
People who keep their oaths regardless are predictable. Trustworthy. They make the world a simpler place to deal with.
As someone else quoted in their sig, Death, lighter than a feather. Duty, heavier than a mountain. Or, stripped of the poetry - Life? Big deal. We're ALL going to die. Just a question of where and when. Save a child's life? Child's still going to die, just at a different time and place.
Whole universe is going to grow cold and die someday.
Honor, though? Honor has importance.
But that's just my take on things.
Someone once told me "Ed, you'd fit in well with a paranoid end-of-the-world, Montana militia group." My reply was that the militia group didn't take things grimly enough. Too damned cheerful.
Ed.