Its not really that the novels are written bad. The first novel was quite good, ,it had a coherent plot and purpose, and the conclusion with meeting the Emperor turned out as well as I expected. It was interesting and illuminating both, and showed up glimpses of many interesting aspects of the Imperium.
The second novel too started out pretty interesting for the same reason, because it had a purpose and things were getting more complicated (Draco is being hunted, The Inquisition is making plans, the Eldar are making plans, etc.) I even liked (as I later found out) the inclusion of his character from Space Marine (Lex) because Lex in my mind remained one of the few interesting aspects of the novel (The other being Grimm. I liked Grimm.)
But by the end of the second novel, ,things seemed to be falling apart a little. I mean the hunting for the Black Library was interesting, and in a way appropriate (because this was a very Eldar-themed novel) but things were really getting confused and not much was being resolved.
The Third novel, in my opinion, is quite unfortunately very incoherent. Alot of previous plot threads (the Hydra thing, the Eldar, etc.) remain unresolved, and then we get Chaos thrown into the bargain (for no purpose.) And Draco goes off on his Mad Quest For Personal Reasons leaving me with a very Anakin-esque sense of dislocation (as in the way I felt by Anakins falling to the Dark Side in ROTS.) It was like the story abruptly changed track for no purpose, and everything before was completely ignored (or shoddily "tied up" our last view of Carnelian and the Eldar is an example). Lex and Grimm were the best parts there, in my mind, and some of the views of the Imperium were still interesting (although the constant "destruction wherever Jaq goes" grimdark got tiresome by now too. Ian watson seemed to be a really big fan of grimdark by the end.)
Nonetheless, I w ould still recommend the first two books for the reasons that a.) they are well written, b.) the Characters are mostly likeable (I like Draco least, but Meh'Lindi, Grimm, and later Lex are a pleasure to read) c.) the series gives us quite diverse glimpses of the Imperium in all its myriad forms (From hive worlds like Stalinvast to Earth to Eldar craftworlds to far off frontier worlds or civilised worlds..) d.) plenty of technical or analytical bits to discuss on (from technology bits, to the discussion of the nature of the Emperor , to various warp related thingies.). e.) ITs a glimpse at the very very early era of 40K when things were different than the "modern" version.
That said, we begin the analysis....
Page 13
A description of different kinds of Hive cities that exist in the Imperium (other sources like Dark HEresy give further elaborations, but we won't get into that here.) Some of them seem to e quite Coruscant like wth the "layers" of metal skin.Some Hive worlds consist of shell upon shell of plasteel braced by great pillars, as if the planet has grown a meatal skin and then another skin and yet another, each successive skin being home to billions of busy human maggots, fleas, lice.
Other hive worlds are poisoned wildernesses punctuated by rearing plasteel termite mounds, vertical cities that punch through the clouds.
The cities of Stalinvast were more like coral reefs looming above a sea of hostile jungle. Kefalov bulged like some fossil brain adorned with innumerable ridges. Dendrov branched every which way, a forest of tangled stags' horns. Mysov was a mass of organ pipes, from which sprouted the fungi that were suburbs. Other cities were stacks of fans or dinner plates.
A thousand such cities, soaring, bulging, branching from the surface of Stalinvast and almost all involved in the manufacture of weapons for the Imperium.
..
The capital, Vasilariov, partook of most of the styles of coral architecture. Fifty kilometres long by forty wide by five high, currently Vasilariov was being scarred by some of its own weapons as Harq Obispal raged through the hive like an angry bear. Doing good work, oh yes...
Stalinvast, the hive world in question, had a thousand hive cities, all are like "coral reefs" - some are like a ridged fossil brain, some are like tangled clusters of stag horns, some are like a mass of organ pipes, and some are stacks of fans or dinner plates.
Page 14
- Stalinvast is a weapons manufacturing hive. It tests plasma cannon and barrage bombs, proudces warrior robots, juggernauts, and great armoured vehicles. You can tell this is an earlier version of 40K with the reference to Robots still existing.Stalinvast was a rich, important world. Its thronged reefs were proudly stained rose-red, scarlet, purple, pink. Between the cities the blue-green jungle was riven with great scars where plasma cannon and barrage bombs had been tested. Warrior robots, juggernauts, and land raiders used the jungles as a proving ground.
What is interesting is that this seems to be a planet that producse alot of stuff you'd expect to be on a Forge World.
Page 17
- mention of a "hovertank" plant. One wonders if this is a referencee to the "Shampoo bottle" attack tank or if it ssomething else.
Jaq summoned a facet into full prominence. It swelled. Around it, like a thronged ring of moonlets each with its own scenery, all the other facets squeezed.
A skirmish in a hovertank plant...
Page 17
Hastily he redirected his attention towards the circular screen that he had hung on the wall in place of an oil painting of some horned, scaly jungle monster.
His psychic sense of presence buzzed as he recontacted his spy-flies. The screen lit with a hundred crowded little images, a mosaic of miniature scenes. Now that screen was the faceted eye of a fly, though the view from each facet was unique.
The mosaic occupied much of his consciousness so that he was only dimly aware — out of the corner of his eye, and mind's eye — of Meh'Lindi, a flexible ebon statue of herself, yet still with an ivory face. Now she was inserting the throat and ear plugs with which she would hear and communicate and breathe.
Jaq summoned a facet into full prominence. It swelled. Around it, like a thronged ring of moonlets each with its own scenery, all the other facets squeezed.
- Jaq has a device that is a sceen linked to over a hundred tiny (fly-sized) observation devices, and is psychically controlled.
Page 18
- Stalinvast's hive cities (or at least one Jaq is observing) is at least two kilometers above the ground, presumably one of the "Stacked plate' ones from the description, meaning that it is seven kilometers in height. (2 above the ground plus the five in height.)A series of explosions tore at the stem of the plate-district where it was attached to the rest of the city. The entire plate sagged and snapped free. Briefly, the whole huge structure sailed on the air, then it fell. Rebels slid and scrabbled for hand holds, claw holds, as the district plummeted towards the fringe of the jungle two kilometres below.
Page 19-
Meh'Lindi is an assassin and her syn-skin outfit provides the following benefits.Meh'Lindi's hair was slicked down tight. When she sprayed her face, her visage became more of a blank than ever, a black mask with the merest hint of features. The syn-skin would protect her against poison gas or flame or the flash of explosions; it would boost her already-honed nervous system and her already-notable vigour.
By the time she wound the scarlet sash around her waist once more, miniaturized digital weapons hooded her fingers like so many baroque thimbles. The needier, laser, and flamer were precious, rare Jokaero devices.
Page 20
- mention of clingfire from the flamers - I don't know if this is just Jaq/Watson's term for what flamers fire out or if its supposed to be some specific kind of flamer fuel (different from promethium).Flamers sprayed at the fracas; and at last rebels could be distinguished from loyalists, just as it became obvious that the new arrivals on the scene — pink salamanders — were also loyalists. For the black basilisks screamed and writhed and quit fighting as soon as superheated chemicals clung burning to them. Deathbats — those of the brood — rushed frenziedly, even as they blazed, to attack the wielders of the flame guns. Precision laser fire sliced through the berserkers, killing human torch after human torch till the last had fallen.
Presently, perhaps tardily, foam engulfed the platforms to douse the clingfire — blinding this particular spy-fly, though by now Jaq had registered the loyalists' hard-won gain.
Also the implication that lasguns are susstained-fire cutting weapons, at least here they are.
Page20
- Another mention of Jaq's observation device, and that it is a Jokaero innovation, captured by the Ordo Malleus.Jaq's hundred roving spy-flies and the screen-eye were another Jokaero invention, perhaps unique, which the Ordo Malleus had captured. Those simian, orange-furred Jokaero were forever improvising ingenious equipment, not necessarily in the same way twice, though with an accent on miniaturization.
Debate still waxed hot as to whether the orange ape aliens were genuinely intelligent or merely made weapons instinctively as spiders make web. Grimm, a born technologist himself — as were all Squats — had pointed out that this eye-screen required psychic input from the operator. So some Jokaero must have psyches. At least.
Most planets seemed to harbour biological flies. Swamp-flies, dung-flies, offal-flies, sand-flies, flies that liked to sip from the eyeballs of crocodiles, corpse-flies, rotting-vegetation-flies, pseudo-flies that fed on magnetic fields.
Also, there exist 'pseudo flies" that feed on magnetic fields, these spy flies can imitate (mini mynocks?) And we get a glimpse of how the spy fly machine works. Also a referene to the good ol Jokaero..w hich definitely tells you this is earlier edition stuff its based on.
Page 21
- Jaq's spy-flies can transmit what they see and hear in a "compass of twenty kilometers" - the operational range of the spy flies from the screen, one presumes (whether this is radius or diameter I'm not sure, but I'm betting radius). Also mentions they are "vibrating crystalline machines. They evidently possess a measure of self-awareness, as when psychically directed to obseve or follow someone (in this case, an Imperial assassin) they do so.Who would notice a little fly buzzing, around nimbly? Who would mark that fly watching you, transmitting what it saw and heard back to the eye-screen from anywhere within a compass of twenty kilometres? Who would expect that the fly and its fellows were tiny vibrating crystalline machines?
Jaq can alter the size of the viewscreens he observes.
Page 24
The inquisitor was advancing in the vanguard of a squad of armoured Imperial Guardsmen. Guardsmen from the local garrison, rather than Space Marines from off-world. Obispal believed in the force of will, in his own ruthless aura; and indeed, except for the evidence of lurid, puckered scar tissue across one cheek, he might have seemed invulnerable. Presumably he didn’t rate the Stalinvast operation as requiring really major surgery - even though thirty hive cities had been devastated to date and several totally destroyed.
Casualties? Twenty million civilians and combatants? Out of a thousand cities, housing billions...
Wistfully, Jaq quoted to himself the words of an ancient leader of the middle kingdom on bygone Terra: ‘In the land of a thousand million people, what does the death of one million of these count in the cause of purity? ’
- mention of "a thousand cities, housing billions." Its not certain whether this means billions total, or billions per city.(meaning trillions overall) but given Stalinvast and latter commentary its likely that the former (billions) is meant.
- Jaq quotes a paraphrase from an ancient text: "In the land of a thousand million people, what does the death of one million of these count in the cause of purity."? This seems to suggest something about the size of the planet or city or maybe evne just the Hive.
If we treat Jaq's statement as semi-literally, contrasted with the "twenty million" (milions) of deaths mentioned before, the implication would be that there are tens of billions (at least twenty, maybe thirty billion) people on Stalinvast. Which would make it rather small, as Hive Worlds go.
It should be clarified that in teh book Stalinvast is described as having "planetary" guardsmen, which seems lower case. Though given above that Space Marines are hinted to also be classifed as a kind of "Guardsmen" by that time we may infer this is more of a generic term rather than a specific one to the Imperium's own military assets. This also seems to predate the Guard/PDF distinction as well (though in latter context we do know the Guard established Garrisons on many worlds, and Hive Worlds often seemed to warrant them, so the "planetary guardsmen" could be PDF, the Imperial Guardsmen part of Stalinvast's personal garrison, and the reference by Jaq to "Space Marines" as guardsmen merely an offhand statement.