Stuart wrote:Guardsman Bass wrote:It certainly wouldn't be surprising if the Goldstein "History of the World" or such in 1984 was just another layer of control they throw over the Outer Party, to catch any free-thinkers - just like how O'Brian pretended to be a subversive in order to catch Winston. We already know that they're more or less changing their history frequently ("We're always at war with Eastasia" to "We're always at war with the other guy"), so what's making up a false history document that conveniently fell into Winston's hands compared to that?
That's always been my theory; that Goldstein's book was created by the Party as a further means of pursuing their agenda. In The Business there's a saying, "The Secreter, the Truer." If some information comes from the public library, its much less believable than the same information stamped "Top Secret". I believe that Goldstein's book was simply intended to promote the Party line by wrapping it in a cloth of illegality. "Gee, this is banned so it must be true"
Indeed - and for that matter, we don't really get any evidence that they're receiving orders from what would presumably be the center of Oceania's power (back in the New World). The various Ministries are in Great Britain, Winston does his changing of history in Great Britain, the philosophy of Oceania is called "IngSoc", and so forth.
That said, keeping the name "Airstrip One" is rather bizarre. It would almost make me speculate that they
were part of some greater alliance until a calamity happened ("Atomic Wars" are mentioned, among other things), and after that alliance fell apart, they kept their designated name and pretense of it to justify their control.