Salvation War Criticism Thread

UF: Stories written by users, both fanfics and original.

Moderator: LadyTevar

Post Reply
User avatar
Havok
Miscreant
Posts: 13016
Joined: 2005-07-02 10:41pm
Location: Oakland CA
Contact:

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Havok »

Count Chocula wrote:
Armageddon? from Cleaned Up Fanfics wrote:Chapter One

Eagle Flight, Over The Eastern Pacific
“I, Satan Mekratrig, Lord of Hell, Commander of the Legions of the Damned do hereby declare my dominion over the earth and all that it contains. Crawl to me, humans, knowing the eternity of torment that awaits you.”

“Balls.” Said Lieutenant Michael Wong.
FUCK YEAH!
Oh. Oh my.

I guess not.
Image
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.
Hit it.
Blank Yellow (NSFW)
"Mostly Harmless Nutcase"
User avatar
Ford Prefect
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 8254
Joined: 2005-05-16 04:08am
Location: The real number domain

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Ford Prefect »

Yeah. That's slightly creepier than I would usually expect, though.
What is Project Zohar?

Here's to a certain mostly harmless nutcase.
Pick
Sith Marauder
Posts: 3690
Joined: 2005-01-06 12:35am
Location: Oregon, the land of trees and rain!

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Pick »

Ford Prefect wrote:Yeah. That's slightly creepier than I would usually expect, though.
It's an easy way to draw people in, I'll admit.
"The rest of the poem plays upon that pun. On the contrary, says Catullus, although my verses are soft (molliculi ac parum pudici in line 8, reversing the play on words), they can arouse even limp old men. Should Furius and Aurelius have any remaining doubts about Catullus' virility, he offers to fuck them anally and orally to prove otherwise." - Catullus 16, Wikipedia
Image
User avatar
Ford Prefect
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 8254
Joined: 2005-05-16 04:08am
Location: The real number domain

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Ford Prefect »

I've done it myself, and though I think Stark is right about its negative effects, in principle I don't have much of a problem with it. I just think Chocula is being particularly sychophantic.
What is Project Zohar?

Here's to a certain mostly harmless nutcase.
Duckie
Sith Marauder
Posts: 3980
Joined: 2003-08-28 08:16pm

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Duckie »

actually it has the opposite on me. I've tried to read armageddon thrice now, since this thread provoked another attempt.

I can't get over the lameness of the first bit that chocula quoted in its entirety, as "Balls" said Lt. Wong is exactly where I quit each time.
User avatar
Stark
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 36169
Joined: 2002-07-03 09:56pm
Location: Brisbane, Australia

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Stark »

Pick wrote:
Ford Prefect wrote:Yeah. That's slightly creepier than I would usually expect, though.
It's a lazy way to draw people in, I'll admit.
my eyes rolled so far out of my head when i read 'mike wong lick lick rimjob lol satan' that i was blind for days
User avatar
Instant Sunrise
Jedi Knight
Posts: 945
Joined: 2005-05-31 02:10am
Location: El Pueblo de Nuestra Señora la Reina de los Angeles del Río de Porciúncula
Contact:

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Instant Sunrise »

Samuel wrote:What would be the best way to make them more of a threat? Have Hell stockpiling weapons to take on heaven for the last 50,000 years and unleash them upon human forces?
You're looking at this ass-backwards here. The question is not, "what minor revisions could make The Salvation War an interesting story as-is?" It's "what avenue of storytelling would serve the purposes of telling a compelling, interesting and dramatic story?"
Count Chocula wrote:Although Armageddon turned into "The Curbstomp War," it was a close run affair and if it had lasted a few months longer, or if Satan had had smarter lieutenants (or if he himself had adapted past the Bronze Age), humanity on Earth would have been in an assload of trouble.

In the first few chapters of The Salvation War, Stuart alludes to just how close humanity was to running out of ammunition and equipment to fight Satan's minions.
The biggest rule in screenwriting (and writing in general) Show, don't tell.

Stuart TOLD us that it was a close battle and we very nearly lost but in no way does the story actually SHOW that.
Hi, I'm Liz.
Image
SoS: NBA | GALE Force
Twitter
Tumblr
User avatar
Ford Prefect
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 8254
Joined: 2005-05-16 04:08am
Location: The real number domain

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Ford Prefect »

Duckie wrote:actually it has the opposite on me. I've tried to read armageddon thrice now, since this thread provoked another attempt.

I can't get over the lameness of the first bit that chocula quoted in its entirety, as "Balls" said Lt. Wong is exactly where I quit each time.
That's why I said 'in principle'. :) When I did it, I did it because I couldn't be stuffed inventing a whole crew of characters, so I got users on the board to do it for me. In The Salvation War you get direct usage of usernames like 'Kuroneko' and 'Surlethe', which is awfully obtrusive. Has Doctor Surlethe even been given a first name?

also stark has a point too lol
What is Project Zohar?

Here's to a certain mostly harmless nutcase.
User avatar
Count Chocula
Jedi Council Member
Posts: 1821
Joined: 2008-08-19 01:34pm
Location: You've asked me for my sacrifice, and I am winter born

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Count Chocula »

Ford Prefect wrote: I just think Chocula is being particularly sychophantic.
Syncophantic? Syncophantic? Me? Mike and I don't exactly see eye to eye, but he's in the first chapter of Armageddon?.

I dispute your scurrilous accusation, you magnificent specimen of Australian man.
Image
The only people who were safe were the legion; after one of their AT-ATs got painted dayglo pink with scarlet go faster stripes, they identified the perpetrators and exacted revenge. - Eleventh Century Remnant

Lord Monckton is my heeerrooo

"Yeah, well, fuck them. I never said I liked the Moros." - Shroom Man 777
User avatar
Ford Prefect
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 8254
Joined: 2005-05-16 04:08am
Location: The real number domain

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Ford Prefect »

I'm just calling it like I see it, my man.
What is Project Zohar?

Here's to a certain mostly harmless nutcase.
Pick
Sith Marauder
Posts: 3690
Joined: 2005-01-06 12:35am
Location: Oregon, the land of trees and rain!

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Pick »

Duckie wrote:actually it has the opposite on me. I've tried to read armageddon thrice now, since this thread provoked another attempt.

I can't get over the lameness of the first bit that chocula quoted in its entirety, as "Balls" said Lt. Wong is exactly where I quit each time.
I said "people", not "me". I didn't actually realize it was Wong Wong the first time I tried to read it, but I still didn't get that much further in. I then skipped to a much later passage to see if the style changed, but it didn't.
"The rest of the poem plays upon that pun. On the contrary, says Catullus, although my verses are soft (molliculi ac parum pudici in line 8, reversing the play on words), they can arouse even limp old men. Should Furius and Aurelius have any remaining doubts about Catullus' virility, he offers to fuck them anally and orally to prove otherwise." - Catullus 16, Wikipedia
Image
User avatar
Ford Prefect
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 8254
Joined: 2005-05-16 04:08am
Location: The real number domain

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Ford Prefect »

Pick, could you expand on what you don't like about the style of writing? more for the sake of posterity* than anything else.

*well not really because of autoprune but hey
What is Project Zohar?

Here's to a certain mostly harmless nutcase.
User avatar
Darth Raptor
Red Mage
Posts: 5448
Joined: 2003-12-18 03:39am

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Darth Raptor »

At least names like "Wong" and "Schatten" are names that real people really have. Every time I read "Doctor Surlethe" or "Doctor Kuroneko" I died a little inside.

stuart may not know things about non-missiles film at eleven
User avatar
General Zod
Never Shuts Up
Posts: 29211
Joined: 2003-11-18 03:08pm
Location: The Clearance Rack
Contact:

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by General Zod »

Darth Raptor wrote:At least names like "Wong" and "Schatten" are names that real people really have. Every time I read "Doctor Surlethe" or "Doctor Kuroneko" I died a little inside.

stuart may not know things about non-missiles film at eleven
the obvious solution to this is to not read fanfics
"It's you Americans. There's something about nipples you hate. If this were Germany, we'd be romping around naked on the stage here."
User avatar
Ford Prefect
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 8254
Joined: 2005-05-16 04:08am
Location: The real number domain

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Ford Prefect »

Darth Raptor wrote:At least names like "Wong" and "Schatten" are names that real people really have.
Hey man, non-real person names are awesome. Then again, I might be more interested in The Salvation War if it was populated by people called Bear Fury, Athenian Grinn and Laser Circus. :)

ps these are my names do not steal
What is Project Zohar?

Here's to a certain mostly harmless nutcase.
Duckie
Sith Marauder
Posts: 3980
Joined: 2003-08-28 08:16pm

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Duckie »

'nobody is named surlethe or kuroneko' could be very bad if it turns out kuroneko actually is named kuroneko man. He'd never do your math homework for you ever again.

Also my name is totally Duckie. For serious yo.

Also Also, am I in this fic? Please tell me I'm not.
User avatar
Count Chocula
Jedi Council Member
Posts: 1821
Joined: 2008-08-19 01:34pm
Location: You've asked me for my sacrifice, and I am winter born

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Count Chocula »

The most obvious solution is to read Karen Traviss and then try to take a red pen to most any fanfic.
Image
The only people who were safe were the legion; after one of their AT-ATs got painted dayglo pink with scarlet go faster stripes, they identified the perpetrators and exacted revenge. - Eleventh Century Remnant

Lord Monckton is my heeerrooo

"Yeah, well, fuck them. I never said I liked the Moros." - Shroom Man 777
Duckie
Sith Marauder
Posts: 3980
Joined: 2003-08-28 08:16pm

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Duckie »

Count Chocula wrote:The most obvious solution is to read Karen Traviss and then try to take a red pen to most any fanfic.
Chocula: hurf hurf it's good if you lower your expectations *beats up on board hobbyhorse and chewtoy*

Chocula why are you in this thread.
User avatar
Ford Prefect
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 8254
Joined: 2005-05-16 04:08am
Location: The real number domain

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Ford Prefect »

Duckie wrote:Also Also, am I in this fic? Please tell me I'm not.
The chances that you are in either Armageddon or Pantheocide is the same as mine: precisely zero.
What is Project Zohar?

Here's to a certain mostly harmless nutcase.
User avatar
Count Chocula
Jedi Council Member
Posts: 1821
Joined: 2008-08-19 01:34pm
Location: You've asked me for my sacrifice, and I am winter born

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Count Chocula »

The duck's horns are goring. Ow. I read exactly one Traviss paperback and hated it...you may have noticed I'm not "hurf hurf" posting on any Traviss threads here, I just really didn't like the book I read. Zahn's, Daley's and Foster's novels were much better IMO. Splinter of the Mind's Eye especially.

I was here for fun but now you've made it SRS BZNZ. Ventedda!

EDIT PS I like Armageddon. And TSW. So there.
Image
The only people who were safe were the legion; after one of their AT-ATs got painted dayglo pink with scarlet go faster stripes, they identified the perpetrators and exacted revenge. - Eleventh Century Remnant

Lord Monckton is my heeerrooo

"Yeah, well, fuck them. I never said I liked the Moros." - Shroom Man 777
User avatar
Darth Raptor
Red Mage
Posts: 5448
Joined: 2003-12-18 03:39am

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Darth Raptor »

what can i say i'm a masochist and cannot spend all day writing my own terrible fiction

I gave up on Armageddon in short order. It was around when it became clear that the role of Abigor (the only character I ever gave a fuck about) was to be perpetually in awe of humanity. I'm not sure why I gave Pantheocide a try, but I did, and I got as far as "hay guise now we get to meet this dumb bitch from Thailand i totally had a boner for" before the bile came back and made it impossible to go on.
Pick
Sith Marauder
Posts: 3690
Joined: 2005-01-06 12:35am
Location: Oregon, the land of trees and rain!

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Pick »

Ford: It's the aforementioned showing-not-telling issue which got to me most. There didn't seem to be a lot of mystique or alternate interpretation, even in characterizations. Things were made clear which were unnecessary to be clarified. I think one of the most interesting things about including magic (well, an allegory to magic) is it allows you to play by rules which you have formulated, but aren't necessarily revealed outright, and certainly not in the same way that standard physics is hypothetically accessible to everyone. It's something I think is fair enough to revel in. Also, the wording hits me as being flat, but then again, that's more fitting for this kind of work than anything veering into purple. Nevertheless, to me it lacks "flair". [insert Office Space joke here]
"The rest of the poem plays upon that pun. On the contrary, says Catullus, although my verses are soft (molliculi ac parum pudici in line 8, reversing the play on words), they can arouse even limp old men. Should Furius and Aurelius have any remaining doubts about Catullus' virility, he offers to fuck them anally and orally to prove otherwise." - Catullus 16, Wikipedia
Image
User avatar
Ford Prefect
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 8254
Joined: 2005-05-16 04:08am
Location: The real number domain

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Ford Prefect »

Darth Raptor wrote:what can i say i'm a masochist and cannot spend all day writing my own terrible fiction
raptor we shoudl be fanfiction bros

when i start writing again of course

i have not read your particular brand of terribleness yet and am desirous of the experience
It was around when it became clear that the role of Abigor (the only character I ever gave a fuck about) was to be perpetually in awe of humanity.
Abigor is one of those characters who should be very cool. Much like Michael-Lan, though, he suffers from this incessant need to depict humanity as the end of days incarnate. It's been said a few times now, of course.

Also, Pick, I have to agree with you on quite a few counts there. While there is such a thing as prose which is too descriptive, Stuart's writing is very ... functional. It's not exactly bad, but it is the bare minimum required to tell the events. Given the number of conferences which go on, this can lead to a great amount of pretty dry moments. At times it can turn into detailed blow-by-blow break down of precisely what just happened, but it's still usually perfunctory.

Personally, my second biggest complaint has to be how basically every character is flat, which is in part because there are so many characters. For a great number of names in The Salvation War, there is no real differentiation I can pick up. It certainly wouldn't count as a character driven piece, in my mind.


destructionator what are you laughing about
What is Project Zohar?

Here's to a certain mostly harmless nutcase.
Pick
Sith Marauder
Posts: 3690
Joined: 2005-01-06 12:35am
Location: Oregon, the land of trees and rain!

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by Pick »

Yes, there's something about it that is very... hmm. Reminiscent of a history text. It recounts events, but it doesn't do so in a way that especially draws one's attention. How should I describe it? Like a logbook. And the characters speak in a way that solidifies the impression. Their speech is indistinct, which contributes to the issue you brought into more light: the difficulty of mentally categorizing the constituent characters when they're not presented in a context that brings out their individual features. I actually don't think that a huge amount of characters means they become interchangeable, but the task of making them sympathetic as actual people becomes much harder.
"The rest of the poem plays upon that pun. On the contrary, says Catullus, although my verses are soft (molliculi ac parum pudici in line 8, reversing the play on words), they can arouse even limp old men. Should Furius and Aurelius have any remaining doubts about Catullus' virility, he offers to fuck them anally and orally to prove otherwise." - Catullus 16, Wikipedia
Image
User avatar
ray245
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 7954
Joined: 2005-06-10 11:30pm

Re: Why am I reading Armageddon?

Post by ray245 »

Pick wrote:Yes, there's something about it that is very... hmm. Reminiscent of a history text. It recounts events, but it doesn't do so in a way that especially draws one's attention. How should I describe it? Like a logbook. And the characters speak in a way that solidifies the impression. Their speech is indistinct, which contributes to the issue you brought into more light: the difficulty of mentally categorizing the constituent characters when they're not presented in a context that brings out their individual features. I actually don't think that a huge amount of characters means they become interchangeable, but the task of making them sympathetic as actual people becomes much harder.
I think the word you are looking for is documentary. If people wants to tell a story in TSW and focus on a small group of characters, there's no stopping you from writing fanfic about TSW.

I find it funny that you guys are bitching about the story for not being personal enough, yet no one wants to write fanfics that focus on those aspects.
Humans are such funny creatures. We are selfish about selflessness, yet we can love something so much that we can hate something.
Post Reply