HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

N&P: Discuss governments, nations, politics and recent related news here.

Moderators: Alyrium Denryle, Edi, K. A. Pital

User avatar
Alyrium Denryle
Minister of Sin
Posts: 22224
Joined: 2002-07-11 08:34pm
Location: The Deep Desert
Contact:

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Alyrium Denryle »

See; this has been part of draft systems in the civilized world ever since the disastrous experience of many countries in the First World War, where in the name of egalitarianism, a lot of really smart scientists, engineers, and skilled machinists joined up in August of 1914; and then...died in the mud of the Western Front; causing a shortage of skilled workers later on in the war.
If I remember properly, the guy that came up with the periodic table died in the trenches in ww1. It was either him or some other early chemist.
GALE Force Biological Agent/
BOTM/Great Dolphin Conspiracy/
Entomology and Evolutionary Biology Subdirector:SD.net Dept. of Biological Sciences


There is Grandeur in the View of Life; it fills me with a Deep Wonder, and Intense Cynicism.

Factio republicanum delenda est
User avatar
Questor
Jedi Council Member
Posts: 1601
Joined: 2002-07-17 06:27pm
Location: Landover

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Questor »

Alyrium Denryle wrote:If I remember properly, the guy that came up with the periodic table died in the trenches in ww1. It was either him or some other early chemist.
Must have been some other chemist. Mendeleev was russian and in the 19th century.
User avatar
Ritterin Sophia
Sith Acolyte
Posts: 5496
Joined: 2006-07-25 09:32am

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Ritterin Sophia »

RThurmont wrote:My own, somewhat controversial view, is that conscription is a human rights violation, tantamount to slavery, and should be prohibited via a constitutional amendment (and additionally, the US should, in cooperation with international partners, apply trade sanctions on countries such as Switzerland that have active conscription programs; alas, that's not going to happen).
So wait, you're saying that a country should not be allowed to make people who benefit under it's existence work for that benefit when it's threatened? :lol:
A Certain Clique, HAB, The Chroniclers
User avatar
Aaron
Blackpowder Man
Posts: 12031
Joined: 2004-01-28 11:02pm
Location: British Columbian ExPat

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Aaron »

It gets even funnier when you realize that small countires like Finland, Israel and Switzerland would likely not be able to defend themselves without it.
M1891/30: A bad day on the range is better then a good day at work.
Image
User avatar
Executor32
Jedi Council Member
Posts: 2088
Joined: 2004-01-31 03:48am
Location: In a Georgia courtroom, watching a spectacle unfold

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Executor32 »

Alyrium Denryle wrote:If I remember properly, the guy that came up with the periodic table died in the trenches in ww1. It was either him or some other early chemist.
You're thinking of Henry Moseley, who discovered that an element's atomic number was not just an arbitrary number assigned by chemists' intuition, but was experimentally verifiable using the element's X-ray spectra. This led to the discovery by Bohr that it was the positive charge of the nucleus, and therefore the number of protons. Moseley was killed in the Battle of Gallipoli.
どうして?お前が夜に自身お触れるから。
Long ago in a distant land, I, Aku, the shape-shifting Master of Darkness, unleashed an unspeakable evil,
but a foolish samurai warrior wielding a magic sword stepped forth to oppose me. Before the final blow
was struck, I tore open a portal in time and flung him into the future, where my evil is law! Now, the fool
seeks to return to the past, and undo the future that is Aku...
-Aku, Master of Masters, Deliverer of Darkness, Shogun of Sorrow
User avatar
Ritterin Sophia
Sith Acolyte
Posts: 5496
Joined: 2006-07-25 09:32am

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Ritterin Sophia »

Aaron wrote:It gets even funnier when you realize that small countires like Finland, Israel and Switzerland would likely not be able to defend themselves without it.
Yeah, Finland, Israel, and Switzerland don't have a high enough population to maintain an effective volunteer military given that the average number you can expect to volunteer is only 1% of the population. America has 300 million people and can expect ~1 million armed services personnel, Canada has 30 million and can expect ~300k. Finland could expect ~50k, Israel and Switzerland could expect about ~70k each. That's not a whole lot when you look at the enemies they could expect to fight.
A Certain Clique, HAB, The Chroniclers
User avatar
Knife
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 15769
Joined: 2002-08-30 02:40pm
Location: Behind the Zion Curtain

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Knife »

RThurmont wrote: My own, somewhat controversial view,
Well, at least you're smart enough to know that your view isn't the best one around.
is that conscription is a human rights violation, tantamount to slavery,
Good god and gravy, how do you figure that?
and should be prohibited via a constitutional amendment (and additionally, the US should, in cooperation with international partners, apply trade sanctions on countries such as Switzerland that have active conscription programs; alas, that's not going to happen).
I really don't think you've thought this through.

Edit:

I see I'm not the only one. So, if this devolves into something I'll bow out so as not to dogpile. That said, I would very much like to see/read your reasoning on conscription=slavery.
They say, "the tree of liberty must be watered with the blood of tyrants and patriots." I suppose it never occurred to them that they are the tyrants, not the patriots. Those weapons are not being used to fight some kind of tyranny; they are bringing them to an event where people are getting together to talk. -Mike Wong

But as far as board culture in general, I do think that young male overaggression is a contributing factor to the general atmosphere of hostility. It's not SOS and the Mess throwing hand grenades all over the forum- Red
User avatar
Sea Skimmer
Yankee Capitalist Air Pirate
Posts: 37390
Joined: 2002-07-03 11:49pm
Location: Passchendaele City, HAB

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Sea Skimmer »

If conscription is slavery then so are taxes, indeed taxes would be far closer to slavery since you don’t escape them after two years, taxes are theft of your labor until death!
"This cult of special forces is as sensible as to form a Royal Corps of Tree Climbers and say that no soldier who does not wear its green hat with a bunch of oak leaves stuck in it should be expected to climb a tree"
— Field Marshal William Slim 1956
User avatar
The Duchess of Zeon
Gözde
Posts: 14566
Joined: 2002-09-18 01:06am
Location: Exiled in the Pale of Settlement.

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by The Duchess of Zeon »

Executor32 wrote:
Alyrium Denryle wrote:If I remember properly, the guy that came up with the periodic table died in the trenches in ww1. It was either him or some other early chemist.
You're thinking of Henry Moseley, who discovered that an element's atomic number was not just an arbitrary number assigned by chemists' intuition, but was experimentally verifiable using the element's X-ray spectra. This led to the discovery by Bohr that it was the positive charge of the nucleus, and therefore the number of protons. Moseley was killed in the Battle of Gallipoli.
And was a volunteer and a commissioned officer.
The threshold for inclusion in Wikipedia is verifiability, not truth. -- Wikipedia's No Original Research policy page.

In 1966 the Soviets find something on the dark side of the Moon. In 2104 they come back. -- Red Banner / White Star, a nBSG continuation story. Updated to Chapter 4.0 -- 14 January 2013.
User avatar
Alyrium Denryle
Minister of Sin
Posts: 22224
Joined: 2002-07-11 08:34pm
Location: The Deep Desert
Contact:

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Alyrium Denryle »

Jason L. Miles wrote:
Alyrium Denryle wrote:If I remember properly, the guy that came up with the periodic table died in the trenches in ww1. It was either him or some other early chemist.
Must have been some other chemist. Mendeleev was russian and in the 19th century.
Yeah, Executor was right. I was pulling from a decade old memory ;)

Still, I was not that far off. Go me.
My own, somewhat controversial view, is that conscription is a human rights violation, tantamount to slavery, and should be prohibited via a constitutional amendment (and additionally, the US should, in cooperation with international partners, apply trade sanctions on countries such as Switzerland that have active conscription programs; alas, that's not going to happen).
Yeesh, and I thought I took a hard line on the issue. Look, I would agree with you when said conscripts would be expected to fight in a foreign war over political issues or resources. Namely, a war in which the opponent is not an existential threat to the nation in question or its allies/not trying to take over europe. The military of Switzerland is there for one purpose. To maintain Switzerland and its Neutrality. They cant do that with just a volunteer military for the reasons stated. The same can be said for the Israeli military and the Finns. At the very minimum they need people who have put their time in that they do not have to train in the event that they are invaded so they can mobilize their large reserve force. Having the majority of your population go through military training and two years on active duty before being put into the reserve is a good option for those goals, and it is in the best interests of the entire population that it is the case.
GALE Force Biological Agent/
BOTM/Great Dolphin Conspiracy/
Entomology and Evolutionary Biology Subdirector:SD.net Dept. of Biological Sciences


There is Grandeur in the View of Life; it fills me with a Deep Wonder, and Intense Cynicism.

Factio republicanum delenda est
Zed
Padawan Learner
Posts: 487
Joined: 2010-05-19 08:56pm

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Zed »

I was wondering - is the bill suggested in the O.P. advocating male draft only, or does it include women? I've always been a tad peeved at the sexism involved in most drafts.
User avatar
General Zod
Never Shuts Up
Posts: 29211
Joined: 2003-11-18 03:08pm
Location: The Clearance Rack
Contact:

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by General Zod »

Zed wrote:I was wondering - is the bill suggested in the O.P. advocating male draft only, or does it include women? I've always been a tad peeved at the sexism involved in most drafts.
You could always read the bill for yourself, which the OP actually links to.
"It's you Americans. There's something about nipples you hate. If this were Germany, we'd be romping around naked on the stage here."
Chirios
Jedi Knight
Posts: 502
Joined: 2010-07-09 12:27am

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Chirios »

PeZook wrote:You need a strong tradition to pull off something like Rangel wants. For example, members of the British royal family are expected to serve and fight if there's a war (in practice, of course, no sane commander will send a prince into the front if he values his career),
Harry was sent to the front lines secretly until the papers found out.
Edward Yee
Sith Devotee
Posts: 3395
Joined: 2005-07-31 06:48am

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Edward Yee »

If I recall correctly, Prince Harry had threatened to resign from the Army unless allowed to deploy to Afghanistan with his unit.
"Yee's proposal is exactly the sort of thing I would expect some Washington legal eagle to do. In fact, it could even be argued it would be unrealistic to not have a scene in the next book of, say, a Congressman Yee submit the Yee Act for consideration. :D" - bcoogler on this

"My crystal ball is filled with smoke, and my hovercraft is full of eels." - Bayonet

Stark: "You can't even GET to heaven. You don't even know where it is, or even if it still exists."
SirNitram: "So storm Hell." - From the legendary thread
User avatar
PeZook
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 13237
Joined: 2002-07-18 06:08pm
Location: Poland

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by PeZook »

Edward Yee wrote:If I recall correctly, Prince Harry had threatened to resign from the Army unless allowed to deploy to Afghanistan with his unit.
Yeah, he had to use threats to get deployed. A common mook would need to do it the other way around :D

And, of course, it does show the stuff I was talking about (strong tradition) at work here.
Image
JULY 20TH 1969 - The day the entire world was looking up

It suddenly struck me that that tiny pea, pretty and blue, was the Earth. I put up my thumb and shut one eye, and my thumb blotted out the planet Earth. I didn't feel like a giant. I felt very, very small.
- NEIL ARMSTRONG, MISSION COMMANDER, APOLLO 11

Signature dedicated to the greatest achievement of mankind.

MILDLY DERANGED PHYSICIST does not mind BREAKING the SOUND BARRIER, because it is INSURED. - Simon_Jester considering the problems of hypersonic flight for Team L.A.M.E.
Edward Yee
Sith Devotee
Posts: 3395
Joined: 2005-07-31 06:48am

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Edward Yee »

PeZook wrote:
Edward Yee wrote:If I recall correctly, Prince Harry had threatened to resign from the Army unless allowed to deploy to Afghanistan with his unit.
Yeah, he had to use threats to get deployed. A common mook would need to do it the other way around :D

And, of course, it does show the stuff I was talking about (strong tradition) at work here.
Not surprisingly it was more likely he who could "get away" with this than Prince William due to being a step further down the line of succession (in the sense of a more senior MoD officer or official 'relenting'), and even then he was reportedly assigned a personal security detachment (PSD) from the SAS.
"Yee's proposal is exactly the sort of thing I would expect some Washington legal eagle to do. In fact, it could even be argued it would be unrealistic to not have a scene in the next book of, say, a Congressman Yee submit the Yee Act for consideration. :D" - bcoogler on this

"My crystal ball is filled with smoke, and my hovercraft is full of eels." - Bayonet

Stark: "You can't even GET to heaven. You don't even know where it is, or even if it still exists."
SirNitram: "So storm Hell." - From the legendary thread
User avatar
Ritterin Sophia
Sith Acolyte
Posts: 5496
Joined: 2006-07-25 09:32am

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Ritterin Sophia »

Edward Yee wrote:and even then he was reportedly assigned a personal security detachment (PSD) from the SAS.
Well fuck, I know he had to have been getting shit from his mates for that. :lol:

Motherfucking SAS following him around like nannies. :P
A Certain Clique, HAB, The Chroniclers
User avatar
Broomstick
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 28846
Joined: 2004-01-02 07:04pm
Location: Industrial armpit of the US Midwest

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Broomstick »

Highlord Laan wrote:ADDITION: This just crossed my mind, so I'll ask it here. I know that women aren't required to sign up for the Selective Service (the draft), but are they allowed to opt-in if they wish to?
Zed wrote:I was wondering - is the bill suggested in the O.P. advocating male draft only, or does it include women? I've always been a tad peeved at the sexism involved in most drafts.
The draft in the US has been strictly men-only. The current selective service registration is also men only. No, there is no opt-in for women. Women can volunteer for military service, of course, but they can't be drafted.

Frankly, I think it should apply equally to all genders. If you want the perks of citizenship you should also shoulder the responsibility of same. While there are military jobs women can do on account of biology (we've had that discussion before) they are quite capable of filling many other roles, which would enable a larger pool of men for those positions that really do require male muscle.

Also - by making a draft equally likely to scoop up women as men you would drastically reduce the chances of it actually being instituted in the US, at least with our current society.
A life is like a garden. Perfect moments can be had, but not preserved, except in memory. Leonard Nimoy.

Now I did a job. I got nothing but trouble since I did it, not to mention more than a few unkind words as regard to my character so let me make this abundantly clear. I do the job. And then I get paid.- Malcolm Reynolds, Captain of Serenity, which sums up my feelings regarding the lawsuit discussed here.

If a free society cannot help the many who are poor, it cannot save the few who are rich. - John F. Kennedy

Sam Vimes Theory of Economic Injustice
User avatar
PeZook
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 13237
Joined: 2002-07-18 06:08pm
Location: Poland

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by PeZook »

I disagree that a draft should include women. Let's face it: the draft is supposed to be a mechanism used when a society faces a grave threat to its existence. Such threats have a nasty habit of grinding up a lot of the soldiers involved.

Post-war demographic disruption is minimized if young females of child bearing age don't get maimed and killed en masse.
Image
JULY 20TH 1969 - The day the entire world was looking up

It suddenly struck me that that tiny pea, pretty and blue, was the Earth. I put up my thumb and shut one eye, and my thumb blotted out the planet Earth. I didn't feel like a giant. I felt very, very small.
- NEIL ARMSTRONG, MISSION COMMANDER, APOLLO 11

Signature dedicated to the greatest achievement of mankind.

MILDLY DERANGED PHYSICIST does not mind BREAKING the SOUND BARRIER, because it is INSURED. - Simon_Jester considering the problems of hypersonic flight for Team L.A.M.E.
User avatar
Ace Pace
Hardware Lover
Posts: 8456
Joined: 2002-07-07 03:04am
Location: Wasting time instead of money
Contact:

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Ace Pace »

PeZook wrote:I disagree that a draft should include women. Let's face it: the draft is supposed to be a mechanism used when a society faces a grave threat to its existence. Such threats have a nasty habit of grinding up a lot of the soldiers involved.

Post-war demographic disruption is minimized if young females of child bearing age don't get maimed and killed en masse.
I have no idea what makes you think it's impossible to have an army with females serving in it that doesn't involve sending them to the front lines. I assume you are aware that a majority of a modern force spends its' time behind the front lines?
Brotherhood of the Bear | HAB | Mess | SDnet archivist |
User avatar
Alyrium Denryle
Minister of Sin
Posts: 22224
Joined: 2002-07-11 08:34pm
Location: The Deep Desert
Contact:

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Alyrium Denryle »

PeZook wrote:I disagree that a draft should include women. Let's face it: the draft is supposed to be a mechanism used when a society faces a grave threat to its existence. Such threats have a nasty habit of grinding up a lot of the soldiers involved.

Post-war demographic disruption is minimized if young females of child bearing age don't get maimed and killed en masse.

I sort of agree. I can definitely see and could support women being "drafted" into the gaps left in certain sectors of the economy left vacant by men during the draft. But you are right. Unfavorable alteration of sex ratio and age structure via sending your young women to the meat grinder is a demographic collapse waiting to happen.
GALE Force Biological Agent/
BOTM/Great Dolphin Conspiracy/
Entomology and Evolutionary Biology Subdirector:SD.net Dept. of Biological Sciences


There is Grandeur in the View of Life; it fills me with a Deep Wonder, and Intense Cynicism.

Factio republicanum delenda est
User avatar
PeZook
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 13237
Joined: 2002-07-18 06:08pm
Location: Poland

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by PeZook »

Ace Pace wrote: I have no idea what makes you think it's impossible to have an army with females serving in it that doesn't involve sending them to the front lines. I assume you are aware that a majority of a modern force spends its' time behind the front lines?
Yes, I suppose you could easily have women serving in support roles.

However, being in theater but "behind the front line" doesn't quite mean you're not going to get killed during a major war. There aren't quite that many support positions that are completely risk-free, as air power, partisans infiltrators and deep breakthroughs will still hunt logistical convoys, HQs, supply dumps, artillery positions, etc.
Image
JULY 20TH 1969 - The day the entire world was looking up

It suddenly struck me that that tiny pea, pretty and blue, was the Earth. I put up my thumb and shut one eye, and my thumb blotted out the planet Earth. I didn't feel like a giant. I felt very, very small.
- NEIL ARMSTRONG, MISSION COMMANDER, APOLLO 11

Signature dedicated to the greatest achievement of mankind.

MILDLY DERANGED PHYSICIST does not mind BREAKING the SOUND BARRIER, because it is INSURED. - Simon_Jester considering the problems of hypersonic flight for Team L.A.M.E.
Cecelia5578
Jedi Knight
Posts: 636
Joined: 2006-08-08 09:29pm
Location: Sunnyvale, CA

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Cecelia5578 »

Alyrium Denryle wrote:
PeZook wrote:I disagree that a draft should include women. Let's face it: the draft is supposed to be a mechanism used when a society faces a grave threat to its existence. Such threats have a nasty habit of grinding up a lot of the soldiers involved.

Post-war demographic disruption is minimized if young females of child bearing age don't get maimed and killed en masse.

I sort of agree. I can definitely see and could support women being "drafted" into the gaps left in certain sectors of the economy left vacant by men during the draft. But you are right. Unfavorable alteration of sex ratio and age structure via sending your young women to the meat grinder is a demographic collapse waiting to happen.

I'm at least partially sympathetic to the draft for the reasons Rangel is, plus I think having more members of the military from urban areas/the coasts would be healthier than the Southern dominated military we have.

I'll admit to not thinking of the demographic consequences of large numbers of women getting killed, but I think in order to be truly fair and just a draft would have to include everyone, regardless of gender or class, and it would inevitably end up being neither of those.

There are a lot of jobs in the military that don't require 2 years of training or anything close to that(not all combat arms either) but they are hardly the most glamourous or sought after.
Lurking everywhere since 1998
Edward Yee
Sith Devotee
Posts: 3395
Joined: 2005-07-31 06:48am

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Edward Yee »

Cecelia5578 wrote:I'm at least partially sympathetic to the draft for the reasons Rangel is, plus I think having more members of the military from urban areas/the coasts would be healthier than the Southern dominated military we have.
Ironically this is also an argument that's been used against excluding ROTC from colleges/universities due to DADT, but I'd think that the main reason for the demographic skew was differences in work opportunities as well as cultural/political differences (i.e. in foreign policy / the legitimacy of enlisting?).
I'll admit to not thinking of the demographic consequences of large numbers of women getting killed, but I think in order to be truly fair and just a draft would have to include everyone, regardless of gender or class, and it would inevitably end up being neither of those.
Admittedly such for me is reason enough not to go with a draft.
There are a lot of jobs in the military that don't require 2 years of training or anything close to that(not all combat arms either) but they are hardly the most glamourous or sought after.
Another issue as well, as some apparently MOSes rely on "sounding cool" for recruiting purposes, i.e. the little brouhaha over PsyOps being renamed military information support operations (MISO)...
"Yee's proposal is exactly the sort of thing I would expect some Washington legal eagle to do. In fact, it could even be argued it would be unrealistic to not have a scene in the next book of, say, a Congressman Yee submit the Yee Act for consideration. :D" - bcoogler on this

"My crystal ball is filled with smoke, and my hovercraft is full of eels." - Bayonet

Stark: "You can't even GET to heaven. You don't even know where it is, or even if it still exists."
SirNitram: "So storm Hell." - From the legendary thread
Cecelia5578
Jedi Knight
Posts: 636
Joined: 2006-08-08 09:29pm
Location: Sunnyvale, CA

Re: HR 5741 A bill that won't make it off the ground.

Post by Cecelia5578 »

I was thinking, at least as far as the American Army is concerned, such jobs like paralegals (I don't think they are called that exactly) chaplains assistants, all of the (speaking from experience) quartermaster MOSs at Ft Lee, etc. You could easily get two years worth of conscripted service out of those jobs.
Lurking everywhere since 1998
Post Reply