SFdebris is going to review DoctorWho!!

[Serafina]

*squee*

[mr friendly guy]

So it looks like he is going to review classic as well as Nu Who. Awesome.

[Bright]

I'm looking forward to it.

I had never seen Red Dwarf, but still found his reviews of it informative and interesting.

[Big Orange]

Great news and I'm looking forward to Sfdebris reviewing OldWho and NuWho, with their pros and cons. Also he can go against the grain of popular consent, as demonstrated in his Red Dwarf reviews where he felt Series VIII was not so bad and underrated. I wondered where his Red Dwarf reviews went, but it was actually because Sfdebris got into serious legal problems with Auntie Beeb and it had to be taken down, otherwise his account would've been rubbed out.

[Eternal_Freedom]

This looks brilliant. I haven't seen any stuff from SFDebris before, but I may have to start if it's as good as you guys think

On a sid enote, loving that photo of Ace with a SLR and a rifle grenade. Companion Militant methinks

[Zor]

Looking forward to this, i am just going to wonder how he is going to do this.

Zor

[Agent Sorchus]

He is reposting the Red Dwarf reviews with slight edits on his blip tv account, which is the same place that he is going to put the Doctor Who reviews.

[Tsyroc]

You can also get his reviews on iTunes.

[mr friendly guy]

This looks brilliant. I haven't seen any stuff from SFDebris before, but I may have to start if it's as good as you guys think

On a sid enote, loving that photo of Ace with a SLR and a rifle grenade. Companion Militant methinks

He reviews lots of Trek episodes.

I think he also used to post here under the name "Chuck."

[Agent Sorchus]

Name was Sonnenberg. You can look up his profile, he was really active at the time the board was founded. About two years ago life caught up and his web presence has been really minimal outside of the reviews.

http://sfdebris.blip.tv/ is where all his reviews that can't be one youtube are going.

[Eternal_Freedom]

Ohhhhh now I know who you're on about, I asked the "who is he" question after someone posted one of his TNG reviews

[Soontir C'boath]

Chuck better be getting some ad money out of blip.

[Eternal_Freedom]

I have just watched his reviews of "Trials and Tribble-ations" and "The Siege of AR-558" and they are utterly brilliant. Especially the latter'sexpoisition on the Defiant. Lols "If she [the counselor] is going to be two feet away that's only to make it easier for her to give me a lap dance while I'll killing Borg"

I haven't laughed so hard in some time

[Burak Gazan]

" I want a bridge like KIRK! "



Pure gold


And, this should be good

[Eternal_Freedom]

"I want a cloaking device, I'm gonna surprise those bastards"
"We can't do that, we don't have one and if we did the Romulans would get pissed"
"lemme do some negotiating"......"hey, Ambassador motherfucker, I need a favour" thud thud thud" Cloakign device will be here tomorrow"

Genius

[Serafina]

The review is up!
It's a (IMO) very good review of the very first episode of Doctor Who! Including a very good explanation of the Doctors character.

[Eternal_Freedom]

Seconded, an excellent review I felt. I found the discussion of his character most informative, I hadn't considered such an idea before.

Thanks to Serafina for posting the link!

[Bright]

There was another announcement a few hours ago:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3BHRagLNFy8

Basically, he's doing Babylon 5 as well. Damn, this guy keeps busy.

[fgalkin]

And the first B5 review is up. And it's "Passing Through Gethsemane," for some reason. Followed by a 10 minute discussion of prison rape and death of personality. Go figure.

http://blip.tv/file/4542811

Have a very nice day.
-fgalkin

[Zor]

The follow is definately worth a look into. Its an idea for fictional settings which i have an interest in and he covers it quite well (even if i don't agree with Chuck on everything on this matter).

Zor

[Darth Nostril]

And the first B5 review is up. And it's "Passing Through Gethsemane," for some reason.

Probably because as Chuck states at the beginning it's one of the few that could be considered a standalone episode.
With B5s overall story arc and mini-arcs it's going to be hard to do the kind of reviews that work with episodic content like Trek.

[fgalkin]

And the first B5 review is up. And it's "Passing Through Gethsemane," for some reason.

Probably because as Chuck states at the beginning it's one of the few that could be considered a standalone episode.
With B5s overall story arc and mini-arcs it's going to be hard to do the kind of reviews that work with episodic content like Trek.

There were plenty of standalone episodes in Season 1, and a couple in Season 2. I think it's really because he doesn't want to deal with the boring early episodes and starts in the middle of things in Season 3.

Have a very nice day.
-fgalkin

[Batman]

Besides, if he wants to keep doing B5 reviews Chuck'll have to do 'story arc episode ' reviews eventually anyway. I'm with fgalkin.

[Darth Nostril]

There were plenty of standalone episodes in Season 1, and a couple in Season 2. I think it's really because he doesn't want to deal with the boring early episodes and starts in the middle of things in Season 3.

Have a very nice day.
-fgalkin

Well there's a reason I only have seasons 2,3 & 4 on dvd so I'm going to have to agree with you about the boring bits

[Mayabird]

And the first B5 review is up. And it's "Passing Through Gethsemane," for some reason.

Because it was a request. Being given $50 is a good reason for doing any of the episodes, I'd think.
[line 2]