Edi wrote:The societies they come from are clan-based even if they masquerade in the trappings of modern states. In those societies, you are supposed to stand up for your own folks, but instead, these, the most fit fighting age males, have chosen to run and leave weaker and vulnerable back there defenseless. That's being a fucking deserter, even if it doesn't maybe fulfill a strict legal definition. I do not give a shit if it falls short on that score.
No they´re not. They were not part of an army so they´re not deserters.
Even if some of them deserted from one of the gazillions of factions of which almost non is a recognized nation and therefore not a recognized army from which you can officially desert they can still claim asylum.
There is a lot of merit to the saying of "When in Rome, do as the Romans do". If they come here, whether that here be Germany or Finland or elsewhere, they should adhere to that. If they refuse, and choose to come here to commit crimes, why the fuck should we have any obligation to not just kick them first in the nuts and then in the head before we kick them out? The ones who pull shit like what happened in Köln, and especially the ones who organized it, toward them we don't have any obligations of protection, not morally. You step on cockroaches like that until you hear a crunching sound.
According to the law they can be kicked out if they commit a crime that is worth 3 years in prison. Most of the crimes in Cologne probably do not fit this bill. And even then it can be difficult. So unless you propose disasembling equality before the law there is probably no way to kick most of these people out.
In cases where they can be thrown out I´d still put them in prison first and throw them out later. It would be too easy to re enter the country with a different name.
Yeah, that's tribal thinking. Humans happen to be tribal creatures, and there is a time when outsiders pull shit on your folks that you need to bash them in the head until they are bloody and then ask them if they've had enough. And if they give you anything other than acknowledgement, you finish the job. They do not need to be given a second chance, not like members of your own tribe do, who get beaten bloody, thrown in jail and only finished off if they still don't learn after that (locked away for life for example).
Equality before the law is one of the things that makes Europe good. If we disasemble it we lose.
Until these newcomers get that lesson taught to them in ways they cannot possibly mistake, shit like New Year's Eve in Köln is going to get repeated again and again. The next time it happens, having the riot police go to town on them until there is enough blood and broken bones for the lesson to sink in would be a good start.
It comes back down to some folks only understanding the language of violence. It's not going to change, and there are a lot of people in the west to whom this entire concept is so alien that they go into abject denial if it is so much as mentioned. And far too many of those morons are running the show.
It does not mean that we should use violence as the first tool, but it should be there on the table, visible and inert, until the time comes to wield it, and when that time comes, it should be wielded decisively. Basically, speak kindly and hold your hand out in friendship, but carry a big stick. And if your kindness and hand of friendship get spat on and bitten, swing the stick without mercy.
I don't agree with the hardline right-wing xenophobes and bigots who are out to fan the flames of conflict and incite hatred toward entire groups of people without so much as looking or giving any benefit of the doubt. I start from a position of giving the benefit of the doubt, but if that doesn't pan out, then I do not have any problem with harsh remedies. I'll gladly welcome outsiders who are good and decent folks, but the ones whose stunts have been the subject of recent discussion? No. Just get rid of them and there is no reason to care one whit what happens to them afterward, because they earned it by their actions.
I´d rather use tools that don´t require shitting all over our own ideals. Like sentencing these assholes like you would sentence every other asshole who did something like that.