Here is the set up
The year is 20, 20, 20 AD or about a week before Voyager Arives Back home
Kirk has been thrown back in time agian and seeing the utter idoicy present in modern day Trek disgues himself and Runs for Preisdent
On the day before the Election he reivles he is infact the Legendary Captian Kirk and he wins in a landslide with 98% of the vote and declares he is going to clean out Starfleet
Admiral Paris terrifed that people will relise that most of SF High Command are Mail Boys who black-mailed thier way to the top Rebels taking the E-D with Picard though Riker stays behind, The Defianit was also stolen along with an assorted number of SF ships most tending towards the high end of Power, 61 in Total
Heres were we get twisted

Of those 61 Ships inculding the ED and Defiant 35 Romluan War-Birds which the Fedds arm with Q-Torps
Now then as Kirk hears of all this he recalls as many ships as possible to deal with the Threat but is only able to get Eight Defiant Class ships as assorted low end ships roughly fourty in number plus two Sovirgens for a total of 53 lets say
Now then Hearing of this chance for battle 200 Strong Klingon Ships Join the Die Kirk Side eager to pay that bastard back after kicking thier rear for so many times want to give some back
Now then the Enterpise-Nil is present but is not part of the Fight because SF can't attack it because if they beat Kirk they have to kick his rear onto the ship and send them back in time to be safe
However Kirk knows this and trys to expolite it
So basicly the Ent-Nil is in *riped shirt mode as the Evil Feddys can't attack it though he does not have time to re-arm it so its using its normal weapons, Also Kirk is not on the ship but rather on the ground sporting a straping Sweater given to him by a young child(Acutal Q in disgues) with special Kevelar Fibers in it so it can't be riped

Now heres where we get twised if this was not already twisted enough
Q splits the time line so he can observer the battle fought twice
The first is as above but the second....

The second Fight there are two slight Changes... First of Through an Unholy cermony involing Data's Cat a jar of Whisky and two dozen Twinkys summons forth the Spirit of Grand Admiral Thrawn to lead there fleet into battle aginst Kirk
To balance this out Q gives Kirk a Vic Class ISD
SO WHO WINS in Both senarior A and B?