Andromeda vs Enterprise-E

[The Nomad]

Situation : the same as in the vs Endgame Voyager Thread. Planets have one special environment each ( ice planet, desert, jungle, rock... ), and gas giants have inhabitable moons. Both ships have full crew and material complement.

Combat : Space fight, boarding, ground combat.

Tactical : same as in the Voyager thread.

Let the slaughter begin !!

[Mr Bean]

Very much so, the AD and Enterpirse while being strutrualy similar(IE roughly similar hull strengths) the AD has such a fucking huge range advantage its not even funny

If the Enterpise could get close enough to use its phasers on the AD it would be in serious trouble but its not likley to happen considering the 100 or so missles the AD can fling in the first ten seconds of the engagement, If they knew where the AD was and was able to warp in front of it then they could start bursting Torps at it and hope to get one through(Not likley with the massive ECM the AD has and point defense) or just use the Phaser and start poking Holes, though the Slip-stream core falure would probably kill the Enterprise to its worth noting that this is almost a far fight as each has a huge advnatage at a certian range


Sort of like a Man weilding a Greatsword VS a guy with a .306 Sniper Rifle

If the Swordsmen can close, that sniper rifle is not all that effective up close but thats the IF

[Renewed_Valour1]

If the Enterpise could get close enough to use its phasers on the AD it would be in serious trouble but its not likley to happen considering the 100 or so missles the AD can fling in the first ten seconds of the engagement,

320 missiles a second is the firing rate. Not one hundred every 10 seconds like you said.

Though the Slip-stream core falure would probably kill the Enterprise to its worth noting that this is almost a far fight as each has a huge advnatage at a certian range

We've never seen a slipstream core fail and explode during the entirety of the show. They are delicate and break easy but are highly impervious to damage. In Harper 2.0 a PSP punched through and took out part of the slipstream drives core. Now try that with most other ships and you have a nice bang.

Sort of like a Man weilding a Greatsword VS a guy with a .306 Sniper Rifle If the Swordsmen can close, that sniper rifle is not all that effective up close but thats the IF

Under 4 light seconds the AP cannons would disassemble the Enterprise in a few seconds.

[HemlockGrey]

Well, the Enterprise-E has never fired more than four or five torps at a time.

As Valor said, the Andromeda can launch 320 a second.

You do the math.

[The Nomad]

Do not forget that the thread includes the boarding and landing parties.


And they don't necessarily start the fight face to face. A few AUs away, at least.

And don't forget that the E-E has the advantage of FTL sensors.

[Mr Bean]

As Valor said, the Andromeda can launch 320 a second.

320 a Second is all well and good but those missles are not 120ish Mega-tons they are 1-20 tops though they are very fast, 4 hits from 120ish Mega-ton missles is 380 MT/20 thats 24 Missles, Remeber not everything comes down to amount, But the point stands though 320 is overkill and the AD has quite a few ECM and Point Defense Weapons

The thing to remeber about both is thier Hull Strength is not the top thing in the world so a large enough hit on either will kill either quite easily, however the Enterpise probably won't get the time to pull it and I forgot the AP cannons so now our sniper has a Hand-gun

So its now Man with Broad-sword VS man with Sniper Rifle and Hand-Gun

The comparsion still stands

[Renewed_Valour1]

As Valor said, the Andromeda can launch 320 a Second is all well and good but those missles are not 120ish Mega-tons they are 1-20 tops though they are very fast, 4 hits from 120ish Mega-ton missles is 380 MT/20 thats 24 Missles,

You seem to very dense on this topic. Andromeda carriers more types of missiles than the 20mt OM-5 Offensive missiles.

I forgot the AP cannons so now our sniper has a Hand-gun

More like a sawed off shotgun. Her AP cannons have a short punch several times more powerful than her missiles.

[Renewed_Valour1]

Do not forget that the thread includes the boarding and landing parties. .

Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum against a pajama clad security officer…
Andromeda's internal defenses against yellow shirts…. Dead yellow shits.

And don't forget that the E-E has the advantage of FTL sensors.

So she see gets to see her impending death in real time.

[Mr Bean]

The comparsion stands it does not matter if its a .90 Cal Sniper rifle or just a .308, either will kill the target

One much more dramtaticly however

Also it does not matter if its a .22 or a 9mm Hand-gun both will agian kill the target

Its the COMPARSION not the acutal firepower that matters