Page 7 of 19
Posted: 2005-05-27 05:12am
by Connor MacLeod
Imperial Overlord wrote:Connor said:
You'll also note the ICS entry does not even list the mass drivers at all. So the datafile listing is hardly all-inclusive. (Likewise for the Acclamator, its datafile does not include the SPHA-T beam cannons mounted ventrally on the ship.)
Minor nitpick: I think you mean Venator, not Acclamator.
Yeah, I meant the Venator, not the Acclamator. Thanks for spotting that for me.

Posted: 2005-05-27 05:32am
by Imperial Overlord
You're welcome.
Posted: 2005-05-27 05:52am
by weemadando
Can I please point out again the ICS' reference to non-Jango clone pilots.
And again - it would be a reasonable assumption that new clone stock is also in use for ground forces.
Posted: 2005-05-27 07:20am
by Cykeisme
It's a Movie Revelations page, though, so stuff that's revealed in the ICS won't be going into the page even though it's true.
If there were other clones I sure wish they showed them more clearly.
It won't be hard to establish (for the audience) that they're clones even if they're non-Jango clones: just show a whole bunch of identical-faced guys.
Btw, this thread has gone waaaay off course several times.
Mike's gonna have a real ball sifting through it. I hope he wasn't expecting a well-organized list of relevant points with no sidetracking

Posted: 2005-05-27 01:23pm
by Clone Sergeant
McC wrote:Grandmaster Jogurt wrote:I watched the movie again, and the "non-Jango clone" was shown right before Obi-Wan takes off for the Utapau system, not right before Order 66 as I had thought.
The clone appears to be blonde and has paler skin than Jango Fett, as well as different facial structure.
However, I'm rescinding this as a proposal for the revelations page, since it is disputed. Even after a second viewing I cannot be positive it was not a trick of the light, and lack of confirmation from others leads me to suspect I am seeing things.
I move that it be re-added. I saw this clone as well. There's definitely someone standing there with yellow-painted armor that does
not look like Jango.
One of the clones looked like Bodie Taylor, the actor who played the younger version of Jango but otherwise I don't think there were any non Jango clones in that shot. Another possibility is that some of the clone faces were digital blendings of the faces of Morrison and Taylor, which ILM had said they were planning to include some of the shots. The clone on the far right of the group, in particular looked like a blended face to me.
Posted: 2005-05-27 02:55pm
by Durandal
And we finally know for sure that Palpatine is Darth Sidious. This ends years of idiotic fanboy speculation that Palpatine was a good guy and that his evil clone or something took over.
Posted: 2005-05-27 03:00pm
by Lord Revan
this might have already said, but we get good view on how big a Juggernaugt (AKA Tuorbotank) is (when Yoda is leaving you can see a clonetrooper next to a wheel of Juggernaugt and he's not even to the lower edge of the hubcap)
Posted: 2005-05-27 03:12pm
by ali-sama
Illuminatus Primus wrote:Durandal wrote:Did anyone else happen to see the cannons on the Venator Star Destroyer ejecting shell after firing a round, or was that just me?
It was the
Invisible Hand. Those cannons are identified as proton torpedo tubes on the ROTS ICS; those ejected shells must be the "firing cylinders" for the torpedo identified in the SW ICS in reference to the X-Wing's torpedoes.
That is cool and dandy had they not been clearly firing beam weapons...
Posted: 2005-05-27 03:31pm
by The Original Nex
ali-sama wrote:Illuminatus Primus wrote:Durandal wrote:Did anyone else happen to see the cannons on the Venator Star Destroyer ejecting shell after firing a round, or was that just me?
It was the
Invisible Hand. Those cannons are identified as proton torpedo tubes on the ROTS ICS; those ejected shells must be the "firing cylinders" for the torpedo identified in the SW ICS in reference to the X-Wing's torpedoes.
That is cool and dandy had they not been clearly firing beam weapons...
They weren't beam weapons.
Posted: 2005-05-27 04:07pm
by ali-sama
The Original Nex wrote:ali-sama wrote:Illuminatus Primus wrote:
It was the Invisible Hand. Those cannons are identified as proton torpedo tubes on the ROTS ICS; those ejected shells must be the "firing cylinders" for the torpedo identified in the SW ICS in reference to the X-Wing's torpedoes.
That is cool and dandy had they not been clearly firing beam weapons...
They weren't beam weapons.
they fired beams... watch movie..
they are manned guns not tubes..
i'll look for screencaps.
ali
Posted: 2005-05-27 04:27pm
by Firefox
ali-sama wrote:they fired beams... watch movie..
they are manned guns not tubes..
i'll look for screencaps.
ali
I just rewatched the video game footage showing those weapons. They fire red bolts.
Posted: 2005-05-27 04:27pm
by The Original Nex
ali-sama wrote:
they fired beams... watch movie..
they are manned guns not tubes..
i'll look for screencaps.
ali
Watch TPM, ANH and RotJ. Projectiles, be they torps/missiles or some otehr non-beam weapon, LOOK a hell of a lot like beam weapons when fired. The Mass Drivers seen on
Invisible Hand launch some sort of projectile. Whether these are the Proton Torpedo Tubes or not is still in discussion, but they are not Turbolasers.
Posted: 2005-05-27 04:29pm
by The Original Nex
My biggest question is why Anakin wasn't anesthesized during the operation? Was it necessary to keep him conscious? (and feel the pain?)
The Sith probably don't believe in anesthetics.
Posted: 2005-05-27 04:31pm
by Connor MacLeod
The Original Nex wrote:ali-sama wrote:
they fired beams... watch movie..
they are manned guns not tubes..
i'll look for screencaps.
ali
Watch TPM, ANH and RotJ. Projectiles, be they torps/missiles or some otehr non-beam weapon, LOOK a hell of a lot like beam weapons when fired. The Mass Drivers seen on
Invisible Hand launch some sort of projectile. Whether these are the Proton Torpedo Tubes or not is still in discussion, but they are not Turbolasers.
the internally-mounted Venator "laser" cannons also launch projectiles that look like "bolts", yet clearly arc in non-linear trajectories.
Posted: 2005-05-27 04:39pm
by The Original Nex
Connor MacLeod wrote:The Original Nex wrote:ali-sama wrote:
they fired beams... watch movie..
they are manned guns not tubes..
i'll look for screencaps.
ali
Watch TPM, ANH and RotJ. Projectiles, be they torps/missiles or some otehr non-beam weapon, LOOK a hell of a lot like beam weapons when fired. The Mass Drivers seen on
Invisible Hand launch some sort of projectile. Whether these are the Proton Torpedo Tubes or not is still in discussion, but they are not Turbolasers.
the internally-mounted Venator "laser" cannons also launch projectiles that look like "bolts", yet clearly arc in non-linear trajectories.
I was wondering if the "arc" would be the colored tracer being affected by gravity? We know that the tracers are succeptible to directional changes due to gravitic forces even though the actual destructive bolt is not. (This phenomena is also seemingly observed in RotJ where we see many "tracers" not line up with the destructive fireball)
Is this a possible explanation? Or am I way off base?
Posted: 2005-05-27 04:49pm
by 2000AD
The Original Nex wrote:My biggest question is why Anakin wasn't anesthesized during the operation? Was it necessary to keep him conscious? (and feel the pain?)
The Sith probably don't believe in anesthetics.
Maybe he just had local anaesthetics
Posted: 2005-05-27 04:57pm
by Darwin
2000AD wrote:The Original Nex wrote:My biggest question is why Anakin wasn't anesthesized during the operation? Was it necessary to keep him conscious? (and feel the pain?)
The Sith probably don't believe in anesthetics.
Maybe he just had local anaesthetics
when you're connecting artificial limbs and the like, you would need the patient to be conscious and have a proper sense of touch in order to make sure everything is hooked up right! of course, being a cruel bastard, Palpatine probably made sure this was the most painful version of this procedure possible.
Posted: 2005-05-27 04:59pm
by Kreshna Aryaguna Nurzaman
2000AD wrote:Maybe he just had local anaesthetics
But he was screaming in pain during a scene of the surgery (followed by the scene showing Amidala was screaming as well).
Doesn't lack of anesthetics endanger the patient during surgery? (shock from the pain, etc). Granted Anakin is strong in the Force, but why exposing Anakin to pain when they can sedate him instead? (at least locally) Isn't anesthetics something taken for granted during any surgery? Why skipping that part?
EDIT: missed this post
Darwin wrote:when you're connecting artificial limbs and the like, you would need the patient to be conscious and have a proper sense of touch in order to make sure everything is hooked up right!
I see. So it was just his bad luck that he also happened to have burn wounds during the prothestic attachment?
But since the artificial limbs were attached to
open wounds, wouldn't some degree of anesthetics needed for that purpose? I don't think getting the patient screaming in pain is a proper medical procedure in Star Wars universe either.
Posted: 2005-05-27 06:33pm
by ali-sama
The Original Nex wrote:ali-sama wrote:
they fired beams... watch movie..
they are manned guns not tubes..
i'll look for screencaps.
ali
Watch TPM, ANH and RotJ. Projectiles, be they torps/missiles or some otehr non-beam weapon, LOOK a hell of a lot like beam weapons when fired. The Mass Drivers seen on
Invisible Hand launch some sort of projectile. Whether these are the Proton Torpedo Tubes or not is still in discussion, but they are not Turbolasers.
mass drivers? what mass drivers?
oh wow.

looks exactly like
yeah. must be a ptorp.
Posted: 2005-05-27 06:37pm
by The Original Nex
That blue bolt is a TURBOLASER from a Venator, NOT from the Invisible Hand
Where did I say it was a proton torp? Show me. I simply said it is NOT a turbolaser.
Posted: 2005-05-27 06:37pm
by Grandmaster Jogurt
That blue shot in the first screenshot is from the Venator, not the Invisible Hand.
Posted: 2005-05-27 07:12pm
by ali-sama
Posted: 2005-05-27 08:23pm
by The Original Nex
Which proves what exactly?
Care to explain the large ammunition belts stringing out from each of those guns? As well as the expelled "shell casings" after each shot is fired?
Posted: 2005-05-27 08:44pm
by ali-sama
The Original Nex wrote:Which proves what exactly?
Care to explain the large ammunition belts stringing out from each of those guns? As well as the expelled "shell casings" after each shot is fired?
portable/ disposable mini chambers.
each bold shot uses up all the fuel which is then disposed of.
they are clearly not ptorps.
Posted: 2005-05-28 06:31am
by Warspite
The Silence and I wrote:
General Grevious's cough--he can survive vacuum without difficulty, has no apparent lungs I saw inside his chest cavity and does not appear to expell air while speaking; why does he cough?
He has lungs, when Obi-Wan opens the frontal chestplates in Utapau, we can see his lungs shriveled behind the heart.