Page 2 of 2

Posted: 2004-01-27 10:13am
by Tribun
Kitsune wrote:I would like to add that I liked Spinter in the Minds Eye.
To me, it seemed to fit pretty well in the Universe
That's a joke, right?
It's the worst book I have ever read......

Posted: 2004-01-27 10:44am
by Tsyroc
Cal Wright wrote:I hated Shadow Hunter. It had a few cool parts. Probably the only part I liked was the ending. Most of it was just plain annoying.
I didn't care for it either. It had a few interesting action sequences and the ending was okay but in general it was rather boring.

The Darth Maul graphic novel where he takes on Black Sun was much more entertaining. Maul is really a character better suited to a visual medium anyway.

Posted: 2004-01-27 11:28am
by Shaidar Haran
Tribun wrote:
Kitsune wrote:I would like to add that I liked Spinter in the Minds Eye.
To me, it seemed to fit pretty well in the Universe
That's a joke, right?
It's the worst book I have ever read......
It's not a bad book so much as it was written only after A New Hope and so it has nothing of the rest of the trilogy, let alone the new EU.

Posted: 2004-01-29 08:35am
by Dargos
I just finished Shatterpoint and I must say . Mace Windu is one bad mofo.
I enjoyed the book.

Posted: 2004-01-31 05:12am
by Equinox2003
I just finised Shatterpoint, also my second Wars novel, and I agree.

Posted: 2004-01-31 09:29am
by Lord Pounder
I wasn't that fussed on Shatterpoint, i was so disgusted with it that as soon as i'd read it i sold it on Ebay.

Posted: 2004-02-02 10:58am
by Dargos
Lord Pounder wrote:I wasn't that fussed on Shatterpoint, i was so disgusted with it that as soon as i'd read it i sold it on Ebay.
Really? May I ask exactly what "disgusted" you about the book?