Page 4 of 12

Posted: 2006-02-04 07:12am
by Zac Naloen
Well, to be fair, I have been slowly working on that story for quite some time. It's been on the 'back burner' as it were. Just seemed a good time to pull it out.
its cool, there seems to be enough differences between your story and mine that im going to go ahead with it.

Posted: 2006-02-04 08:25am
by Jim Raynor
Darth Wong wrote:To be quite brutally honest, this is really no worse than some of the previous comicbook escapades. Come on, who did not groan when finding out that Palpatine reincarnated himself into a backup Empire at Byss that had somehow stayed hidden and passive all that time? That's at least as retarded as anything we're seeing here.
I think this is FAR worse than anything in DE. The Empire in DE was just the remnants of the original Empire, which was realistically still kicking around several years after Endor. The Deep Core is described as an uninhabited region, almost as obscure as the Outer Rim. There was a bunch of stupid crap in DE, but some of these ideas actually made sense.

On the other hand, this Legacy shit doesn't. New Empire?! 100 years after the real Empire was wiped away? How the hell can it even be connected (I'd seriously like to see the bullshit explanation they come up with)? Seriously, what the fuck is this shit? Setting a story in the future isn't a bad idea in and of itself. This idea sucks because it's so blatantly uninspired, pushing the reset button and rehashing a crapload of old ideas. It pretty much invalidates everything the characters fought for in the movie and post-ROTJ era. This is something I would expect from fanfic, and not even decent fanfic. :roll:

Posted: 2006-02-04 08:28am
by Jim Raynor
VT-16 wrote:Ladies and gentlemen, Quinlan Vos 2.0

:wanker:
And that new Sith appears to be a cross between Aayla Secura and Darth Maul. Fanboys are gonna love this. :roll: :wanker:

Posted: 2006-02-04 01:37pm
by Duckie
This idea sounds like a shitty PSW Fic idea that would dribble out of my brains were it to be fertalized with heavy doses of alcohol.

"Shit, man... the Empire... weren't they awesome? Let's put the Empire back in there."
"Let's set this is the fuuuuture...."
"Twi'Leks are hot... Darth Maul was sweet... Eureka- Twi'Lek *hic* Sithzors for villain!"

The only possible rationalization for a New Empire is that the New Republic is so inept (we've already seen it demonstrated) that the Imperial Remnant gets its act together and starts to reassemble the old one.

The Sith Order could have been some Dark Jedi or Force Adept stumbling on a Sith Holocron, however unlikely that would be.

Posted: 2006-02-04 01:57pm
by Adrian Laguna
Darth Wong wrote:To be quite brutally honest, this is really no worse than some of the previous comicbook escapades. Come on, who did not groan when finding out that Palpatine reincarnated himself into a backup Empire at Byss that had somehow stayed hidden and passive all that time? That's at least as retarded as anything we're seeing here.
*Raises hand and waves it around like an idiot*

Being in elementary school meant that my reaction upon seeing Dark Empire was along the lines of:
"OMG! MORE STAR WARS! THIS IS PURE AWESOMENESS!" Exept in spanish, and without the OMG, which ironically I only began using after that sickly thing called "my faith" went into a comma.

In any case, that comic holds a special place in my heart for introducing me to the EU. Furthermore, I'm willing to ignore any stupidity in it due to the fact that it has not one, not two, but three different super-weapons at the same time. World Devastators, Eclipse Star Destroyer, and Wankatine, ftw.

Posted: 2006-02-04 03:09pm
by LordShaithis
Here's what I posted. I know it's not going to last.
So let me get this straight. The Sith lie in wait for a thousand years, hiding their presence from the Republic, until finally they strike to destroy the Jedi and bring about the Empire. But between the redemption of the fallen Anakin Skywalker, and the efforts of his son Luke, the Sith are destroyed and democracy restored.

Whoops, hold the phone, there's still money to be made. I meant to say that the Empire was merely interrupted for a little while, and that the Sith were simply delayed for about one-tenth the time they spent lying in wait in the first place. Yeah, that's more like it.

Good job, too, on the "Skywalker, to the EXTREME with rad tattoos!" and the "Let's make Darth Maul a woman in a bikini!" character designs. Very tasteful. The only reason anyone could possibly object to this entire endeavor is because they fear what they don't understand, and not because it's blatantly exploiting the source material to sell comic books to teenage boys.

Good show.

Posted: 2006-02-04 04:40pm
by Crossroads Inc.
Wheres the link to where you posted this? I SO Want to see the various fanboys react...

Posted: 2006-02-04 05:13pm
by Spanky The Dolphin
Try the thread posted in the OP, Fluke.

Posted: 2006-02-05 12:19am
by Jim Raynor
000 wrote: It almost sounds like this "resurgent Empire" is cast in a positive light. Which would be interesting.
starwars.com
Set more than a century after the events of Return of the Jedi, Legacy is set in a galaxy held in thrall by a resurgent Empire seeking to destroy the last of the Jedi. Even as their power is failing, the Jedi hold onto one final hope: the last remaining heir to the Skywalker legacy.
Evil Empire, Jedi being hunted down, and A New...I mean one final hope. :roll: Make no mistake about it, they basically pushed the reset button on us.

Posted: 2006-02-05 01:29am
by Duckie
Apparantly one person on that Darkhorse thread said that "History repeats itself" to Shaithis' sarcastic post.

Of course. Let's illustrate this idea.

Length of the Republic- Ad Hoc ~25,000
Length of the Empire- Barely 50 years
Democratic Interregnum After Total Defeat By Rebels- 100 years
Rise of New Empire- 25,150 years from the start of the Republic.

That makes little sense.

For that to happen, it'd be something like this scenario:

Length of Kaiserreich/Weimar*- ~62 years
Length of Third Reich- 45 days. If Hitler's Chancellor position is the start, the Third Reich falls to Pro-Weimar rebels on March 15th, 1933.
Democratic Interregnum After Total Defeat By Rebels- 3 Months.
Dark Horse-type Rise of New Nazi Germany- July.

*Although not totally democratic, nice governments, they make a nice contrast of ancient tradition compared to the new Nazi philosophy, same as the Republican/Imperial ideologies.

I for one welcome our easily defeatable but rebound-capable Nazi overlords.

EDIT- Prussia removed to make point better. The proportions between Dark Horse's Empire and the Rebounding Nazis are now nearly exact.

Posted: 2006-02-05 01:38am
by Adrian Laguna
Someone has to post that in the Darkhorse thread!

Posted: 2006-02-05 03:37am
by LordShaithis
I will if MRDOD doesn't want to do so himself.

Posted: 2006-02-05 12:58pm
by Duckie
LordShaithis wrote:I will if MRDOD doesn't want to do so himself.
You can do it (Tell me more!), assuming you aren't banned for having an opinion in the meantime. :roll:

Too lazy to join up just to post something minor like that, really.

Posted: 2006-02-05 01:31pm
by Mange
All they seem to do in that Dark Horse thread is to call people that are explaining their concerns about the story as it has been presented is "trolls" and citing Karen Traviss' definition of "talifan"...

Posted: 2006-02-05 01:46pm
by Fire Fly
I'll venture to say that the concept of a descendent-of-Skywalker-turning-on-legacy isn't that bad of an idea. Now, if it was left just there with no new Empire or no Sith or whatever, something more akin to the Batman Beyond series where the legacy of Batman was dead for a while only to be revived again. Dark Horse Comics should focus, then, just on this new Skywalker's struggles to embrace or reject his destiny. That would be something readable.

Edit: missed a word.

Posted: 2006-02-05 01:56pm
by 000
Jim Raynor wrote:
000 wrote: It almost sounds like this "resurgent Empire" is cast in a positive light. Which would be interesting.
starwars.com
Set more than a century after the events of Return of the Jedi, Legacy is set in a galaxy held in thrall by a resurgent Empire seeking to destroy the last of the Jedi. Even as their power is failing, the Jedi hold onto one final hope: the last remaining heir to the Skywalker legacy.
Evil Empire, Jedi being hunted down, and A New...I mean one final hope. :roll: Make no mistake about it, they basically pushed the reset button on us.
This was actually the quote I was referring to:
More than a hundred years have passed since the events in Return of the Jedi and the days of the New Jedi Order. There is a new evil gripping the galaxy, shattering a resurgent Empire and seeking to destroy the last of the Jedi. Even as their power is failing, the Jedi hold to one final hope: the last remaining heir to the Skywalker legacy.
Randy Stradly said that the OS announcement was incorrect; apparently this new Empire is at odds with the "new evil" (Sith) and may not be hunting the Jedi.

Posted: 2006-02-05 01:57pm
by 000
Jim Raynor wrote:
000 wrote: It almost sounds like this "resurgent Empire" is cast in a positive light. Which would be interesting.
starwars.com
Set more than a century after the events of Return of the Jedi, Legacy is set in a galaxy held in thrall by a resurgent Empire seeking to destroy the last of the Jedi. Even as their power is failing, the Jedi hold onto one final hope: the last remaining heir to the Skywalker legacy.
Evil Empire, Jedi being hunted down, and A New...I mean one final hope. :roll: Make no mistake about it, they basically pushed the reset button on us.
This was actually the quote I was referring to:
More than a hundred years have passed since the events in Return of the Jedi and the days of the New Jedi Order. There is a new evil gripping the galaxy, shattering a resurgent Empire and seeking to destroy the last of the Jedi. Even as their power is failing, the Jedi hold to one final hope: the last remaining heir to the Skywalker legacy.
Randy Stradly said that the OS announcement was incorrect; apparently this new Empire is at odds with the "new evil" (Sith) and may not be hunting the Jedi.

Posted: 2006-02-06 08:51pm
by montypython
Just wish people would stop making retreads, anything original would be an oasis in the desert.

Posted: 2006-06-07 09:16pm
by 000
#0 came out today. Unfortunately, I couldn't locate a copy of it, but here's a very detailed summary from The2ndQuest at the JC LF:
-Ossus was the first planet that was permitted to experiment with Vong terraforming to restore a previouslyd evastated planet.
-Cade's associates do not know he was a Jedi.
-Kol Skywalker, apparently Cade's father, disliked politics and preferred to stay at the less formal Ossus temple.
-Cade was rescued by pirates after the Ossus massacre.
-Deliah Blue, Zeltron & mechanic for the Mynock, Cade's ship. Looks like she's got a thing for Cade.
-Jariah Syn, Kiffar (it seems) & bounty hunter and Mynock copilot, weapons expert (including illegal weapons like razor and thud bugs), loathes Jedi.
-Shado Vao, Twi'lek & padawan to Kol Skywalker, former friend to Cadee, lightsaber expert
-Wolf Sazen, Zabrak, former padawan to Kol, former master to Cade. Is seeking out Cade.
-Rasi Tuum, possibly a human-like Bothan
-Hosk Tre'lyis, dog-faced Bothan
-Wild Nexu roam areas of Coruscant; Rainbow Bridge tourists are warned not to stray

-Finn, can't ID his species, bartender at Rik's
-Queen Jool, female Hutt owner of Rik's, information broker, has a cybernetic, jeweled, eye patch
-Naxy Screeger, compulsive gambler, he looks like a Sakiyan (Djas Puhr's race)
-Attatag Gosem, Gotal spy and information broker with suspected Sith connections
-Rav, Feeorin pirate, operates hunter services out of Socorro
-Chak, Wookiee smuggler and captain of The Grinning Liar (gee, I wonder who that's referring to? grin )
-Kee, Chak's human female copilot and mechanic

-Darth Talon, Twi'lek female, one of Krayt's Hands, executor of Krayt's will.
-Darth Nihl, Nagai and the other Hand, top enforcer of Krayt's will
-Darth Stryfe, human male, most brutal of Krayt's followers
-Darth Krayt, over 100 years old, founder of the new Sith order; abandoned Rule of Two for "Only the One"- the Sith order itself.
-Darth Wyyrlok, male Chagrian, third of that name, most trusted Lt. of Krayt's, master of Sith ritual and lore
-Darth Maladi, female Devaronian (I think), head of Sith Intel and Assassination, expert torturer

-Ganner Krieg, Imperial Knight, most tristed friend of Antares
-Sigel Dare, Imperial Knight, Does not like the Sith or the Jedi
-Antares Draco, leader of the Imperial Knights; formidably both with a saber and as a fighter pilot
-Roan Fel, third Emperor of the Fel dynasty, fully trained Imperial Knight
-Marasiah Fel, ala "Sia", Princess and daughter to Roan, his only child, next in line for the throne despite opposition from some Moffs, has recieved Imperial Knight training but never formally knighted.
-Bastion is still the most heavily fortified place in the galaxy

-Pellaeon-class Super Star Destroyers are built at KDY, features a sleeker outline to make the command tower less of a target and have greater shield protection; has one really large central engine with 6 smaller ones at it's sides.
-Sienar predator improves upon TIE Intereptors, has shields, hyperdrive and multiple wing positions
-Tev "Crasher" Rimon, Imperial pilot
-Jae "Storm" Alura, Imperial pilot
-Captain Gunn "Gunner" yage, Imperial pilot, one of the Empire's top pilots, daughter to Moff Rulf Yage ("the hero of Ossus"), does everything to earn her father's respect

-Moff Morlish Veed, Tactical skills only surpassed by his ambitions for the throne
-Nyna Calixte, in carge of Imperial Intelligence, Veed's partner, she was the contcat the Sith first approached the Empire through.
-Konrad Rus, heads the Imperial Mission, a quiet man of peace advocating the first Emperor Fel's "Victory Without War" initiative.
-Imperial Mission has stations on planet's throughout the galaxy. Missionaries dedicate themselves to the hightes principles of service of what truley emboies the Empire the most
-Astraal Vao, female Twi'le nad twin sister to Shado Vao. Orphaned as chidlren, found and raised by the mission, Shado was later recruited by the Jedi but Astraal feels she eblongs with the Mission.

-Incom CF9 Crossfire Fighter, main fighter of the GA, a logical extension of the X-Wing and Headhunter
-Jedi X-83 Twintail Fighter, latest version of the X-Wing, with hyperdrive and hardwired astromechs that give each ship it's own "personality"
-Jedi Shuttle, primarily diplomatic transport, some were outfitted for battle during Imperial-Sith War.

-Stormtroopers are mostly recruits, some families have served for generations.
-501st still premeire Stormtrooper unit
-Aliens allowed in Stormtroopers, with customized helemts to accomodate them.
-Armor strength upgraded to absorb and duffuse blasts
-Use ARC-9965 blaster rifles
Like I said, I still haven't read the actual comic yet, but it actually looks almost like the new Empire is the descendant of the Empire of the Hand rather than the Imperial Remnant proper, given the influences of the Fels, the 501st, and the appeareance of several Chiss in previews. Or I could be completely off base.

The most likely ancestors at this point of Emperor Roan Fel are Jaina Solo and Jagged Fel, although this might not be the case.

In any case, it's looking better than I expected.

The Pellaeon-class Super Star Destroyer (or Star Dreadnaught, if you like) is an ugly-ass starship, though.

Posted: 2006-06-07 09:36pm
by Publius
"Imperial Knight" rather sounds like "Bene Gesserit," particularly with the Emperor's daughter having received the training. This sounds not unlike fan fiction, but badly written.

Posted: 2006-06-07 09:59pm
by Fingolfin_Noldor
I would have preferred a Star Dreadnaught that looks more sleek and also carry a nicer name.

Seems that's a far fetched idea.

Posted: 2006-06-07 10:20pm
by Vympel
:roll:

How predictable. Over a century has passed and they still have TIE fighters, Stormtroopers, Star Destroyers ..... no bloody creative mind at all.

Posted: 2006-06-07 10:27pm
by Noble Ire
Vympel wrote::roll:

How predictable. Over a century has passed and they still have TIE fighters, Stormtroopers, Star Destroyers ..... no bloody creative mind at all.
You know, as many people have said before, I don't mind rough similarities in technology and style; in a galatic civilization as long-lived as the SW one, things realistically have to stay static for a long time (hell, civilian cargo ships should have resale value for at least a century). Of course, that does limit the originality a good setting can have...

Which is exactly why they should have set this one thousand years past ROTJ, not a mere century (which is only a scant fifty years after the established EU, if not less). That's where the creative bankruptcy really shows; they were desperate to keep some connection to the old characters (ie, the Skywalker/Solo lines), and moving it so far into the future would make it hard to continue to milk the same, tired personalities and familial struggles.

Really, this is where KotoR really took a chance, and succeeded, I think at least. I don't see why these people can't follow in its footsteps.

Posted: 2006-06-07 10:29pm
by Darth Lucifer
In the name of all that is sacred in the Star Wars Universe...I haven't seen wanked out characters this ridiculous since my days of playing WEG Star Wars.

And they HAD to throw in that skull tattoo shit to stroke the Fandahorians. :roll:

Edit: I know it's not the Mandalorian symbol, but it looked similar to me.

Posted: 2006-06-07 10:47pm
by Shadowtraveler
I can understand Pelleon getting a ship class named after him, being a badass old guy and all, but...Emperor Fel?

Just seems a bit silly.